Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
A Spanish operatic tenor, renowned for his powerful voice and operatic performances.
Eight records
if you ask to a tenor which is the the most impressive and most important voice of ever, talking about tenor voices, is of course Enrico Caruso.
A very light Rossini song, the famous Tarantella, La Danza.
Che gelida maninaFavourite
I think he's somebody who changed a little bit the the way to sing. I think he's a an incredibly sensitive singer and uh fantastic voice.
I think that's an incredible voice, an incredible singer, and every opera lover uh knows that b Bjoling is probably with as I said before, with Caruso and and Distefano, the most beautiful voice.
Dies Bildnis ist bezaubernd schön
in my opinion, the the greatest Mozart specialist on the last twenty years or thirty years and is also one of the most beautiful voices with a purity and with a style
the exponent of the Belcanto opera, I mean the Belcanto music... sung by, in my opinion, the the greatest Belcanto singer, which is Moncelad Caballier.
Symphony No. 6 in A minor (Andante moderato)
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Herbert von Karajan
I'm a big Mahler fan. And it's also very difficult to choose from all the Mahler production a a piece or a symphony or whatever. But I think the number six, the the Dante, the third movement, it's something very special
Mario! Mario! Mario! (Act I Duet)
Maria Callas and Giuseppe Di Stefano, conducted by Victor de Sabata
I think that's the most exciting recording of an opera never done.
The keepsakes
The luxury
Painting: Las Hilanderas (The Spinners) by Diego Velázquez
Probably that would be the Picture from Velafkev called uh Las Islanderas. I don't know in English how that uh it
In conversation
Presenter asks
Could you adapt yourself to loneliness [on the island]?
Well, not really, I don't know.
Presenter asks
How did you become interested [in music]?
Well, that's a a funny story. I went to the cinema with my family when I was a child to see this beautiful film called The Great Caruso by Mario Lanza... after seeing this uh this film, the day after I start to sing at home... and then uh they decide then I had a musical inclination and they sent me to the conservatoire to study.
Presenter asks
You also studied chemistry. You didn't know which way to go?
No, well, I I always was thinking to be an opera singer and I study music, as I said, and and piano and voice a little bit later. But because my brother, my oldest brother, he start a little very small chemical plant. They decide well, you never know with uh with artistic career, it's better if to have something sure, you know. And for that reason I start in Barcelona at the uni at the university, studying chemistry.
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 1
Hello, I'm Kirsty Young, and this is a podcast from the Desert Island Disc's Archive. For rights reasons we've had to shorten the music. The programme was originally broadcast in nineteen eighty, and the presenter was Roy Plumley.
Presenter
This week, our castaway is a singer, the Spanish operatic tenor José Carreras.
Presenter
Mr. Carreras, could you adapt yourself to loneliness? You're on this island, you don't know how long you're going to be there. Could you face it?
Jose Carreras
Well, not really, I don't know.
Presenter
Now you have eight records, eight records only, did you find it very difficult to choose?
Jose Carreras
Well, it is very difficult, but I tried as an an opera singer to choose the voices that really impress me and and of course tenor voices, but it's quite difficult.
Presenter
Right. Well, what's the first voice you've chosen? Whose is it?
Jose Carreras
Well, I think then if you ask to a tenor which is the the most impressive and most important voice of ever, talking about tenor voices, is of course Enrico Caruso.
Presenter
And what would you choose to hear him sing?
Jose Carreras
Well, why not uh from Hippagliachi Vestira Juba?
Speaker 2
Funny.
Speaker 2
Uh
Speaker 2
Unit war
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Speaker 2
Look at it.
Presenter
Enrico Caruso singing Vesti La Giobe from Pagliacci.
Presenter
Now, you were born in Barcelona, is that correct?
Jose Carreras
Yeah.
Presenter
Now, in the the the mid-forties Spain was in in rather a poor state after the war, after the civil war.
Jose Carreras
Yes, yes. And uh I was born exactly on nineteen forty six and that was as you say not on the best conditions. Yes. You come from a large family?
Jose Carreras
I have another three brothers, one sister and two brothers, and we are very.
Jose Carreras
You need uh family. Well, in Spain, you know, uh tightly knit. Yes, yes, very much. And is it a family interested in music?
Jose Carreras
Well, n not particularly before I started to sing. How did you become interested?
Jose Carreras
Well, that's a a funny story. I went to the cinema with my family when I was a child to see this beautiful film called The Great Caruso by Mario Lanza. And of course, this is a reason for our next uh tenor, which is Mario Lanza himself.
Presenter
Well go on and tell me about the film what was the effect it had on you.
Jose Carreras
Well, uh after seeing this uh this film, the day after I start to sing at home, uh I was, I don't know, six or seven years old, and I start to sing operatic areas. The ones that you had heard Mario Lando. Yes. And of course my family at the first moment they was afraid. And then uh they decide then I had a musical inclination and they sent me to the conservatoire to study.
Presenter
Mario Land.
Presenter
Med your
Jose Carreras
Uh
Presenter
Debut as a singer
Jose Carreras
Very early.
Presenter
Yeah. Uh
Jose Carreras
Yes, um my first appearance was in Barcelona in an opera called El Retablo de Maisa Pedro, composed by Manuel de Fala. And I think I was eleven at the time. What was the part you played? Well, the part is El Trujaman, that's the boy who explains what happens with the Marionetta theater. Yes. It's it's a fragment from Don Quixote de la Mancha.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Now, you decided that you were going to be a singer. Obviously, this was very important to you. But you also studied chemistry. Yes, that's right.
Presenter
You didn't know which way to go.
Jose Carreras
No, well, I I always was thinking to be an opera singer and I study music, as I said, and and piano and voice a little bit later. But because my brother, my oldest brother, he start a little very small chemical plant. They decide well, you never know with uh with artistic career, it's better if to have something sure, you know. And for that reason I start in Barcelona at the uni at the university, studying chemistry.
Speaker 1
Uh
Speaker 2
Yeah.
Presenter
Uh
Speaker 2
Yeah.
Jose Carreras
Right.
Presenter
What was your first appearance as a grown-up?
Jose Carreras
Well, the very, very first thing was in Barcelona, in a very small role, in Norma.
Jose Carreras
The character is Flavio. Who was singing Norma? Was the for the occasion of the first Montserrat Cabadia Norma?
Jose Carreras
A
Presenter
She and and and her brother Karlos were were very impressed with you, weren't they? They helped you a lot.
Jose Carreras
Yes, they were fantastic with me from the beginning.
Jose Carreras
And you know, when you are very young and an artist like Montserrat Cavalier say to you, Well, I think you have a a talent, I think you have a beautiful voice, I think you can make
Jose Carreras
A beautiful career that gives you an an incredible, a tremendous moral support. And that that's the case.
Presenter
Well, now you've already told us who your next tenor is going to be. That's Mario Lanza, whom you saw and heard playing Caruzzo. What's he to sing?
Jose Carreras
A very light Rossini song, the famous Tarantella, La Danza. Which he sang in the Great Caruso. Yes.
Speaker 2
Jo Luna Medzo Mare Mamma Mia Sisatara, Lore Bell La Perdanzwara Kinna Marumangera, Jo Lone Zoare Mamma Yasatara, Lore Bell La Perdanzware Kinna Marumangira Mm-hmm.
Speaker 2
Jalanune Medzan Mar Mahamami Asis Altera Restpin Danza Ponda Thunda Dunemi Veni Hitiqua Undazambella Jukunda Chescura Hottera Finkin Chel Brillana Stella Elanona Splenderella Tutanota Danzera Mamma Mia Mamma Mia Jollane Medzamare Mamma Mia Mamma Mia Mahami Assaltera Fringe Fringe Fringe Fringe Fringe Fringe Mamma Mia Sisaltera
Speaker 1
I'm not sure if I can do it.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Presenter
Rossini's La Danza sung by Mario Lanza. It's always been the Italian repertoire that's interested you. Yes, yes, yes. When did you first sing in Italy?
Jose Carreras
Well, I'm facing in Italy due I want a Verdi competition in Parma, and that gives me the the opportunity to sing in Italy for the first time.
Presenter
Well, to to sing Verdi in in in Palma must be rather alarming, because it Verdi's town and the inhabitants know all about it and exactly how it should be sung.
Jose Carreras
Yes, of course. And the people there are of course very proud. And I mean, it's quite difficult. But if they love you, they are really very enthusiastic, very, very, very much.
Presenter
But
Presenter
And winning their competition led to an important contract.
Jose Carreras
Dia, I had my first
Jose Carreras
appearance in Italy, in Parma. And then I I went to after this series of performances in Italy, to the United States to sing for the first time in New York, but not at the Metropolitan, but at the New York City Opera. And that was a a long contract.
Presenter
Yeah. You were with Julius Rudolph for
Jose Carreras
That's it, exactly. For how long?
Presenter
Yeah.
Jose Carreras
Well, three seasons exactly. And uh you sang some very important roles then. Yeah, I I had the opportunity in in New York with the New York City Opera Company to sing the many roles for the first time, like Alfredo in Traviato, Edgardo Lucia, uh also Cavaradosi, Pinkerton, plenty. Yes. And that was a very great help for me.
Presenter
And that was a
Presenter
To be settled in one place and and and learn the repertoire and learn English.
Jose Carreras
Yes. And learn English?
Jose Carreras
Yeah.
Presenter
Uh
Jose Carreras
Well, my English is very bad. I'm very poor. I'm sorry about that. It's very good. Let's have your third record. What's that to be?
Jose Carreras
Well, that's going to be my favorite tenor. That's uh Giuseppe Di Stefano. I think he's somebody who changed a little bit the the way to sing. I think he's a an incredibly sensitive singer and uh fantastic voice. The color of that voice is only comparable to Caruso or Biolin. And uh of course the the the phrase, the interpretation and and I think Di Stefano is for me the greatest tenor of ever. And what is he sing on this record? Cajoli Damanina from La Boem.
Speaker 2
Please let me your heart is here. These are heroes.
Speaker 2
Reitra
Speaker 2
Oh, Adam Yes.
Speaker 2
Lee My Song in the Holy Spirit.
Speaker 2
Because I didn't hear why.
Speaker 2
Uh
Speaker 2
Oh my
Presenter
That famous aria from the boem sung by Giuseppe De Stefano.
Presenter
Yeah.
Jose Carreras
When did you first Big
Presenter
Uh
Jose Carreras
England.
Jose Carreras
My first appearance was at the Royal Festival Hall in a concert version performance of mm Dorizetti's Maria Stuarda with Monceau Cavalier and Shiloverette. And at Cotton Garden? Mm, that was in nineteen seventy four and was uh
Jose Carreras
Alfredo Intraviata.
Presenter
Things were happening very quickly. I mean once you got started with your career, then it was all very exciting.
Jose Carreras
Well, I must say then uh professionally speaking I'm I'm a very lucky man, but I think also it's because it's lucky to be a tenor.
Jose Carreras
Every opera has a a important tenor role, that means probably it's much easier for a singer to make a career if he's a tenor.
Presenter
'Cause there aren't all that number of good tenors about, or or so they say in the musical world.
Jose Carreras
Nowadays we have
Jose Carreras
Very, very good tenors. But, you know, you need a tenor for every opera.
Presenter
Yeah.
Jose Carreras
Yeah. Yeah.
Jose Carreras
Yeah.
Presenter
And you sung, well, all the major opera houses now, the Metropolitan. You come to Covent Garden every year, I believe. Yes, I am very happy about that. And Vienna, La Scala, Salzburg. Now, you're a lyric tenor. You're not yet interested in the in the heroic roles, the very dramatic roles.
Jose Carreras
Well, not really, because I I don't have yet the the the voice to sing certain roles.
Jose Carreras
Let's see how the voice develops and on the
Jose Carreras
Next few years.
Presenter
You've been working for Herbert von Karigan and he persuaded you to undertake one or two stronger roles than you're accustomed to. Erademes, for example, and Aida, you tackled for the first time with him.
Jose Carreras
He asked me to sing Radames and he says to me he likes a new approach to the role, showing the romantic Rademez, not only the soldier, the the hero. And he says I want to make a mo much more lyrical approach to the role, to the opera, and the proof that he talked Mira Lafreni for Aida, which is a fantastic singer, but not a dramatic uh soprano. And I'm not a dramatic tenor, but a but a lyric tenor, as you say. But I think we did for two years, Aida in Salzburg. We made the recording as well, and I'm very happy about it, I'm saying.
Presenter
Very interesting production.
Jose Carreras
Yes.
Jose Carreras
Uh Uh record number four, another tenor? Yes, another tenor, and uh the opinion of many people that's called The Voice, and that's Jussie Bjorling. I think that's an incredible voice, an incredible singer, and every opera lover uh knows that b Bjoling is probably with as I said before, with Caruso and and Distefano, the most beautiful voice.
Presenter
What should he
Jose Carreras
It
Presenter
So
Jose Carreras
In Jamisco from Verde Requiem.
Speaker 2
Uh
Presenter
Josie Björling, the Verde Requiem, conducted by Fritz Reiner. What was the first recording you ever made?
Jose Carreras
Well, it was uh in United States and uh was a Rossini opera called La Pietra del Paragone. That was many years ago.
Presenter
That was when you were at the city opera.
Jose Carreras
Yes, that's it.
Presenter
Yes. Recording, of course, now plays a very big part in your career. Yes.
Presenter
You're one of the few singers who isn't ashamed to admit that they use recordings of great singers of the past in studying their roles.
Presenter
Yeah.
Jose Carreras
I I think ev everybody does, but somebody cannot admit it. I don't know why. I think it's a great help for us. And you learn things you have to do and you learn things you never have to do.
Jose Carreras
I mean listening to other uh artists, to other uh singers.
Speaker 2
Yes.
Jose Carreras
And I really do uh when I have to learn a new role, I really try to have this opera from
Jose Carreras
As much interpret as possible to listen critically.
Presenter
Listen
Jose Carreras
Good.
Jose Carreras
Of course then you have your own interpretation, your own feelings and your own capacity and your but I think it's fantastic to have the opportunity to listen to all the others.
Presenter
You've recorded some arias from Spanish Zazuelas, the the the the Spanish operettas. Have you played in any of them?
Jose Carreras
On the stage. Never, unfortunately. I mean, I would like very much it would, but I didn't have the opportunity.
Jose Carreras
But I enjoy very much to sing that kind of music sometimes.
Presenter
It's a very distinctive kind of of operetta, isn't it? We we don't hear very much of that music in
Jose Carreras
England?
Presenter
Yeah
Jose Carreras
That's a big market, of course, in in South America. And
Jose Carreras
In Spain, but uh unfortunately we don't have the opportunity to put that on stage with uh dignity. I mean, because of course to make not only opera but also operatic is very expensive. And in uh Spain, unfortunately, uh music goes ahead because private uh subventions, not because the government holds the the art. And that that's a pity, but it's it's like that.
Jose Carreras
Record number five we got to.
Jose Carreras
Well, that's coming back to Mozart. Uh that's the, in my opinion, the the greatest Mozart specialist on the last twenty years or thirty years and is also one of the most beautiful voices with a purity and with a style, in my opinion it's uh better than anybody else for this kind of music. And that's uh Fritz Wunderlich. And which aria shall we hear? Well, the famous picture aria from the Magic Lot.
Speaker 2
Spilled and easy, but so but share.
Speaker 2
Peace fear us.
Speaker 2
Whee.
Speaker 2
As we discreet or beard Mine house made annoyed.
Speaker 2
My heart
Speaker 2
That made no rain of
Presenter
Fritz Wunderlich and the Picture Arier from The Magic Clute.
Presenter
Is your home still in Barcelona, Mr. Speaker?
Jose Carreras
Can you spend much time there?
Jose Carreras
Well, the other day I was counting how many nights I spent in in Barcelona in nineteen eighty and it's something around seventeen. And we are already at at the end of the year. Oh, that is sad.
Presenter
Where do you do most of your recording?
Presenter
In London, here in London, yes.
Presenter
Is there any one role which you particularly love so that sometimes you wake in the morning and say, Oh, good, I'm singing whatever it is to night? One role that you really relax in and enjoy and enjoy?
Jose Carreras
Um
Jose Carreras
Many.
Jose Carreras
Many, I can say, maybe Rodolfo in Bohem, Verter, Don Carlos, Edgardo in Lucia. But I think uh the the one which is not relaxing because it's very difficult, but which I really love to do, it's Ricardo in Balloon Mascara. I think that's my favorite role.
Speaker 1
There
Presenter
Yeah. Yeah.
Jose Carreras
It's an exciting opera.
Presenter
Any roles that you still haven't had a chance to do in the theatre that you're very keen to tackle?
Jose Carreras
Well, Don Jose and Carmen, I will sing that for the first time at Coven Garden, nineteen eighty two, eighty three. Oh, splendid. And also Travatore, I'm going to sing that for the first time at Coven Garden in 1983. And of course then it's Ovello that's something for the tenor, you know. But I don't yet feel not vocally, not artistically, and not as a man.
Speaker 1
For that
Jose Carreras
Mature enough to take this role. That's a great testing role, yes.
Presenter
Oh, yes, that's something something else. What about recitals, the concert hall? How important is that to you?
Jose Carreras
Well, I think that's very important and I'm very glad I have the opportunity to do several recitals a year combined with my opera performance. I try to do a twelve, fifteen recitals in a year because it's a complete different contact with the audience and also that give you the opportunity to reach places that you cannot uh reach with uh singing opera because they don't have an orchestra or an opera house.
Jose Carreras
And also it's very good for the style, for your voice. I think it's health for the voice to do recitals because it's
Jose Carreras
Very different to sing with a a full orchestra than to sing with a piano.
Jose Carreras
And that gives you the opportunity to to put yourself in a discipline, you know.
Presenter
The piano's not going to cover anything, isn't it?
Jose Carreras
Uh
Presenter
Yeah.
Jose Carreras
Uh Yeah.
Presenter
Sixth record, what's that?
Jose Carreras
That's for me the exponent that's that's right in English? The the the exponent exponent of the Belcanto opera, I mean the Belcanto music.
Presenter
The the exponent.
Jose Carreras
And that's Aria from Bellini's Il Pirata, sung by, in my opinion, the the greatest Belcanto singer, which is Moncelad Caballier.
Speaker 2
Turn somewhere.
Speaker 2
Oh yes.
Speaker 2
They for me of see my dreamy hair.
Presenter
Montserrat Caballier singing the closing aria from Bellini's Il Pirata.
Presenter
Now, presenting opera is a highly technical operation. There are an awful number of things that can go wrong, and
Presenter
That do go wrong. What's the worst experience you've had in an opera production?
Jose Carreras
Uh well, uh no s not involved in an opera production, but I remember being a spectator in a theater, I don't going to say where, but uh in Italy exactly then that was a performance of Ippaliacci and the Bariton comes to the stage to sing the famous prologue and unfortunately he he was in not a very good voice, he was not in a
Jose Carreras
A great night.
Jose Carreras
And he did two or three cracks in the famous.
Jose Carreras
A flat the the and also again on the G the end of the area, and he got boo, but very loud, incredible.
Jose Carreras
And then after
Jose Carreras
One minute of booze and all the days.
Jose Carreras
He managed to stop the audience, and he say very loud in Italian.
Jose Carreras
Are you booing me? Well, wait wait for the tenor.
Presenter
Uh
Presenter
You haven't heard anything yet. Oh, that's a lovely story.
Jose Carreras
You haven't heard anything yet. Yeah.
Speaker 2
Oh, that's a lovely story.
Presenter
Right. Let's get on to your seventh regard.
Jose Carreras
Yeah, that's a much much more serious thing.
Jose Carreras
I would like to say that I'm a big Mahler fan.
Jose Carreras
And it's also very difficult to choose from all the Mahler production a a piece or a symphony or whatever. But I think the number six, the the Dante, the third movement, it's something very special, particularly when conducted by Hervard von Karion and the Berlin Philharmonic Play.
Presenter
The beginning of the third movement of Mahler's Sixth Symphony.
Presenter
Carian conducting the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra.
Presenter
How well could you look after yourself on a desert island? Are you a practical man? Could you build somewhere to live?
Jose Carreras
No, no, no, I'm
Presenter
I'm
Jose Carreras
Yeah. Terrible I mean, uh I don't know if it's because I have to live always in hotels and and and traveling around and
Jose Carreras
I cannot do anything by myself.
Presenter
Dear. What are you going to eat? Can you do any fishing?
Jose Carreras
No.
Presenter
Never tried.
Jose Carreras
Never try.
Presenter
Do you know anything about boats?
Jose Carreras
Nothing at all.
Presenter
Sailing. Nothing. You wouldn't try to escape.
Jose Carreras
I will, I think.
Jose Carreras
I don't know how, but
Jose Carreras
To be alone, that's I'm really afraid about that, really. And I will find a solution. I don't know how, but uh really
Presenter
Cheers.
Presenter
You'll have to think something out.
Jose Carreras
Yes.
Presenter
Yeah.
Jose Carreras
A what What's your last record?
Jose Carreras
And that's Tosca conducted by Victor de Sabota and sung by Maria Carlos, Giuseppe Di Stefano and Tito Gobbi. I think that's the most exciting recording of an opera never done.
Presenter
Which section are we going to hear?
Jose Carreras
Well, I think it's the first duet between Cavaradosi and Tosca, the first act duet.
Speaker 2
It only suffered from my good boy.
Speaker 2
I've already been slain.
Presenter
A duet from the first act of Buccini's Tosca, Callas and Di Stefano with Victor De Sapater conducting.
Presenter
If you could only take one disc out of the eighth play disc, which would you select?
Presenter
I think the
Presenter
Do they
Jose Carreras
Lady Stephen has one.
Presenter
You haven't chosen one of the
Jose Carreras
Buran.
Jose Carreras
N no, not really. You wouldn't? No, because I did plenty of recordings, but I'm not still hundred percent happy about any of of them.
Presenter
That's very modest of you. And you're allowed to take one luxury to the island. What would you like?
Jose Carreras
Probably that would be the
Jose Carreras
Picture from Velafkev called uh Las Islanderas. I don't know in English how that uh it
Presenter
Uh well you you described the picture to me once. It's a spinning women.
Jose Carreras
Yeah.
Presenter
And one book, apart from the Bible and Shakespeare, which are already on the island.
Jose Carreras
Well, probably a book uh poem is from uh Rabindranath Tagore. The Indian Rabbi. Yeah.
Presenter
Good. And thank you, Jose Carreras, for letting us hear your Desert Island Disc.
Jose Carreras
I thank you very, very much. Goodbye.
Presenter
Right.
Jose Carreras
Yeah.
Presenter
Goodbye everyone.
Speaker 1
You've been listening to a podcast from the Desert Island Discs archive. For more podcasts, please visit bbc.co.uk slash radio four.
Presenter asks
What was the worst experience you've had in an opera production?
Uh well, uh no s not involved in an opera production, but I remember being a spectator in a theater... in Italy exactly then that was a performance of Ippaliacci and the Bariton... did two or three cracks in the famous... A flat... and he got boo, but very loud, incredible. And then after... he managed to stop the audience, and he say very loud in Italian. Are you booing me? Well, wait wait for the tenor.
Presenter asks
How well could you look after yourself on a desert island? Are you a practical man?
No, no, no, I'm... Terrible I mean, uh I don't know if it's because I have to live always in hotels and and and traveling around and I cannot do anything by myself.
“when you are very young and an artist like Montserrat Cavalier say to you, Well, I think you have a a talent, I think you have a beautiful voice, I think you can make a beautiful career that gives you an an incredible, a tremendous moral support.”
“professionally speaking I'm I'm a very lucky man, but I think also it's because it's lucky to be a tenor. Every opera has a a important tenor role, that means probably it's much easier for a singer to make a career if he's a tenor.”
“I think ev everybody does [use recordings of great singers of the past], but somebody cannot admit it. I don't know why. I think it's a great help for us. And you learn things you have to do and you learn things you never have to do.”
“to be alone, that's I'm really afraid about that, really. And I will find a solution. I don't know how, but uh really”