Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
Clarinetist, saxophonist and broadcaster who spent most of his professional life in symphony orchestras.
Eight records
Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Sir Thomas Beecham
The first one I'd like to be one of the very first pieces I did play with Sir Thomas Beecham and the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra.
String Quintet No. 3 in G minor, K. 516Favourite
This quintet ... has meant a lot to me and to my family because my wife's a viola player and we spent a lot of our spare time as students and a little later playing this sort of music ... and this being a work for two violas, I would be playing second viola on the clarinet and my wife first viola, and this was a family affair.
Violin Concerto in D minor, Op. 47 (Slow Movement)
Isaac Stern, Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Sir Thomas Beecham
This is a thing of particular significance because my son was born in 1951 ... a message was handed in to a recording session at EMI, where we were recording the Sebelius Violin concerto ... Sir Thomas made a speech. We then started with the slow movement which has a clarinet duet to start it ... it takes me right back to that very instant after the announcement of the birth of this son, Tim.
Nocturne in D-flat major, Op. 27, No. 2
I came back after about half an hour, found the place completely in darkness. And Solomon was practising. For his own delight he was playing the D flat nocturne of Chopin, and it was the most incredibly private audition of this man purely enjoying himself, and I would like to remind myself of that wonderful moment.
The Marriage of Figaro: Barbarina's Aria (L'ho perduta, me meschina)
I should like to remind myself, I think, of this delightful ... activity at Blindborn, and also my favorite composer, Mozart, by playing Barberina's Tiny Aria from Figallo.
I'd like this to reflect my interest in jazz, because I am interested in jazz, but it certainly wouldn't be a clarinet record I'd take with me because that would be too frustrating to have to actually analyze a clarinet record while not being able to play.
String Quartet No. 14 in C-sharp minor, Op. 131 (Opening Fugue)
This to me epitomises how a composer can take a form in music, like a fugue, which is a dullest ditchwater thing really, but by the treatment of it make it into almost a lament, and the incredible way that this great composer, at the end of his life, could get this fugue ... to mean so much, is I think something I should like to remind myself of.
Paul Tortelier, Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Sir Thomas Beecham
It was when Strauss was in the studio and when the young Tortellier came to record Don Quixot with this magnificent orchestra as a young man and with Strauss and with Beecham there, he was able to achieve, I think, something quite tremendous. And I feel that this would remind me of the beginning of the whole thing.
The keepsakes
The book
A volume of two or three books
Charles Dickens
I think I'd like to explore some Dickens if I could. A volume of two or three of his books would be lovely.
The luxury
Could I please have a piano of some sort? It needn't be a new one, it could be quite old, as long as somebody could have left inside it a few of the Beethoven sonatas.
In conversation
Presenter asks
Is it going to be difficult to take loneliness [on the island]?
I think I would find it extremely difficult to take loneliness ... I would not like being on a desert island alone, because I really do believe that one human being without another has no significance whatsoever. I think it's a dead loss.
Presenter asks
Why did you start to play the clarinet?
Purely because there was one in the house ... My father, who was an amateur player, he was a builder, and he did play the clarinet ... and at the age of about four I discovered this delightful toy and ... I made it mine and that was it. Like climbing Everest. You have to do it because it's there.
Presenter asks
What was your ambition? What did you want to be?
Well, obviously I did want to be a musician, but at that time, which was in the late twenties, [with] talking films having just appeared, unemployment among musicians was very serious, and therefore it was silly to even try to be one ... So I decided I was going to be a schoolmaster, and in particular I wanted to be a teacher of physical training
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 3
Hello, I'm Kirsty Young, and this is a download from the Desert Island Discs archive.
Speaker 3
For rights reasons, we've had to shorten the music. The programme was originally broadcast in 1979.
Jack Brymer
As usual, the castaway is introduced by Roy Plumley.
Jack Brymer
Uh
Presenter
Uh
Jack Brymer
On our desert island
Presenter
This week is the clarinetist, saxophonist and broadcaster Jack Brymer. Jack, most of your professional life you've spent in the company of about ninety other people in symphony orchestras. Is it going to be difficult to take loneliness?
Presenter
I think I would find it extremely difficult to take loneliness. Not for that reason, because I'm a bit of a loner.
Jack Brymer
Oh no.
Presenter
But I would not like being on a desert island alone, because I really do believe that one human being without another has no significance whatsoever. I think it's a dead loss.
Presenter
How did you set about choosing your aid records? You looking back?
Presenter
I've just thought of things which were significant to my life and to those around me, and uh they've automatically slotted in, I think. What's the first one?
Presenter
The first one I'd like to be one of the very first pieces I did play with Sir Thomas Beecham and the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra. It's an overture by Berlius called The Corsair.
Presenter
Le Corsaire by Bellio's Sir Thomas Beacham conducting the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra. Now, Jack, you're from the northeast. Yes, from the Tyneside area. From South Shields, actually. Near the sea. Very close to the sea, indeed. Was there a lot of music in your family?
Presenter
No, very little, except that we all did play music around the piano, and the way that these things did happen in families at that time. A big family? Only three of us, my two sisters and myself. Why did you start to play the clarinet?
Presenter
Purely because there was one in the house.
Presenter
Who had left it there? My father, who was an amateur player, he was a builder, and he did play the clarinet, or as we all called it then, the clarionnette.
Presenter
And there was one there and at the age of about four I discovered this delightful toy and uh I made it mine and that was it. Like climbing Everest. You have to do it because it's there.
Presenter
Was there a lot of music at school?
Presenter
Very little indeed, really, because um we were more interested in scholarships and football in that order. What was your ambition? What did you want to be?
Presenter
Well, obviously I did want to be a musician, but at that time, which was in the late twenties, uh talking films having just appeared, unemployment among musicians was very serious, and therefore it was silly to even try to be one.
Speaker 4
Uh
Jack Brymer
Uh
Presenter
So I decided I was going to be a schoolmaster, and in particular I wanted to be a teacher of physical training, because I was very interested in games, and as this seemed to be a reasonable thing to do, and I could get to a college, to London University, to do it, this I decided to do.
Jack Brymer
Right.
Presenter
At which point let us break off your second record.
Presenter
Well this I would like to be
Presenter
By a composer whose work has always meant a tremendous amount to me, Mozart.
Presenter
Because I've discovered to my delight in recent years that I was born on his birthday, the 27th of January. But as Kaiser Wilhelm was also born on the same day, it doesn't really mean all that much. However, I must say that this quintet, it's a string quintet, by the way, not a clarinet quintet, has meant a lot to me and to my family because my wife's a viola player and we spent a lot of our spare time as students and a little later playing this sort of music, my transposing furiously on the clarinet, and we got to know it from the inside, as it were. And this being a work for two violas, I would be playing second viola on the clarinet and my wife first viola, and this was a family affair.
Presenter
The opening of the Mozart string quintet number three in G minor, Otto Grummio and Four Friends.
Presenter
So you were going to be a teacher.
Presenter
And you were studying at London University. Which college? Goldsmiths. A a great music centre, I guess. Well now, yes, but then only lesser. Uh but uh all the same.
Jack Brymer
Well now
Presenter
Luckily, uh there were people there terribly interested in orchestral music, and there was a symphony orchestra run as a sort of evening institute, and that was my first taste of a really large symphony orchestra playing there.
Presenter
We were doing jazz gigs as well because you'd got rather good as a jazz man, hadn't you? Yes, I wasn't allowed to, but I did actually sneak out of my hostel on one or two occasions and down to the local roadhouse with an illicit saxophone and do a little bit of work there. But I wasn't supposed to do this because these were very unpermissive days and we were expected to be indoors by about 10.45 instead of 1.15 or whatever it was. You had to climb in, didn't you? Oh yes.
Speaker 4
As
Presenter
I used to leave the saxophone under the porch in the garden and get in through the window.
Speaker 4
I
Jack Brymer
Uh
Presenter
Ha ha ha.
Presenter
Now when you had finished your teaching studies, what was your first job?
Presenter
I went back to the North East and there I taught um general subjects in um a a junior mixed school at home in South Shields.
Presenter
I then decided that I wanted to come South. There was a reason for this. My fiancé was in Croydon. Oh, yes. And I got a job in a grammar school there, teaching music, physical training and English. Your third record, please.
Presenter
This is a thing of particular significance because my son was born in 1951.
Presenter
And um it was a very bad time for my wife, because there had been a lot of complications and uh nobody expected that this would be a successful event.
Presenter
I when it ha actually happened, a message was handed in.
Presenter
to a recording session at EMI, where we were recording the Sebelius Violin concerto, Sir Thomas Beacham and Isaac Stern.
Presenter
Everything stopped, and there was dollification, and Sir Thomas made a speech. We then started with the slow movement which has a clarinet duet to start it, and Sir Thomas beat sixteen instead of eight. And when I had pointed this out to him, all he said was, My dear boy, who's had this child? Have you or have I?
Presenter
And this, I think, will be the only real bit of clarinet playing you'll hear in this programme. But it takes me right back to that very instant after the announcement of the birth of this son, Tim.
Presenter
The opening of the slow movement of the Sebelius Violin Concerto, Isaac Stern with the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra and
Presenter
Sir Thomas Beacham again as conductor.
Presenter
How had you got into the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra? We we had left you in this grammar school, teaching boys and girls sport.
Presenter
physical education and music. Now this all started with one unexpected telephone call.
Presenter
Yes, now lots of people have taken the blame for this call, you see. Um I had been mingling with musicians as a sort of semi-professional, playing for the Goldsmith Symphony Orchestra, playing for Ernest Reed and his uh various orchestras, and they were always augmented by famous players like Gerald Jackson, Archie Camden, Dennis Brain.
Presenter
Um somebody must have hinted to Sir Thomas that there was a clarinetist around who might be uh available and might be suitable. And um to my astonishment one day the telephone rang and I clambered down from the roof where I'd been um spreading a little pitch after bombing and um
Presenter
A voice said, mister Brimer, I believe you play the clarionet.
Presenter
This is Sir Thomas Beacham.
Presenter
Of course I immediately thought, I wonder which of my friends this is. But it turned out to be Sir Thomas, and he did want to hear me play the clarinet.
Presenter
And that was the beginning of the whole thing. He had just formed the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra. Yes, I think it had been going for nine months. And Reginald Kell, who was the very famous clarinet, this was the first clarinet, was going to leave. And Sir Thomas had to find a replacement. And instead of doing the obvious thing and finding a well-known player, he thought, well, I'll have a go and find an unknown one, and did this. You were with Beecham for many years? Sixteen.
Presenter
No, not quite. I I joined him in nineteen forty eight and he died in'sixty one, but I stayed on with the orchestra a little longer. A wonderful character, of course. You had to keep your wits about you.
Presenter
Yes.
Presenter
He was not unpredictable. You could tell exactly the sort of man he was. But.
Presenter
You had to be pretty wide awake because he was so wide awake. He would not ever let you know quite how a work was going to be performed until the actual performance. The rehearsal was to some extent just a familiarization.
Presenter
He would then almost sculpt the work in front of your eyes. It was like seeing somebody creating an image.
Presenter
He did it all by gesture, and it was a most remarkable thing, the way he could actually take a work and present it by gesture.
Presenter
I believe within a fortnight of becoming a professional musician, you were being conducted by Richard Strauss as well.
Presenter
Yes, Strauss was in the last year of his life and we were doing the Strauss Festival and Sir Thomas was conducting some works and Strauss was conducting his great domestic symphony.
Presenter
And Strauss was at every rehearsal and every recording session, supervising everything that went on, leaning over our shoulders, putting marks in the parts, and giving advice. And of course it was a wonderful baptism of fire to be with this man who had produced some of the finest music of his generation.
Presenter
And at a time when his name was already a legend. Well, that must have been pretty exciting. It was.
Presenter
Record number four.
Presenter
Well, this I would like to think would remind me of several delightful occasions when I played with pianist Solomon.
Presenter
There was a lovely occasion when I was working at Brighton.
Presenter
And having rehearsed, I I went out, but forgot something, and I came back after about half an hour, found the place completely in darkness.
Presenter
And Solomon was practising. For his own delight he was playing the D flat nocturne of Chopin, and it was the most incredibly private audition of this man purely enjoying himself, and I would like to remind myself of that wonderful moment.
Presenter
Solomon playing Chopin's D flat nocturn.
Presenter
I've been looking at your new book, Jack, from Where I Sit, and uh you also mention in those early days working with Stravinsky.
Presenter
Yes, well, I did work with Stravitsky a great deal, uh almost until the end.
Presenter
Uh it was a great privilege.
Presenter
He appeared to bring something with him, an understanding of his music, which you couldn't get from anybody else. He had this incredible feeling, a natural feeling for odd rhythms. He could think in fives and sevens and elevens and thirteens that we couldn't. And he was able to really reveal what he felt about this.
Presenter
Now we talked about Beecham who was your your mentor.
Presenter
You must have worked with most of the great conductors.
Presenter
during the last years since the war.
Presenter
Yes, I missed one. I missed Toscanini. I only saw Toscanini at work, but I did play with all the rest, I think, and uh have great memories of many of them, because a great conductor is a most memorable person always. What is the attitude when you're sitting there at your desk and you've got
Presenter
The 29th conductor in your experience teaching you how to play the Beethoven fifth.
Presenter
can be remarkably revealing. You can get a man like Rudolph Kempe who will take
Presenter
Abraham Score
Presenter
And although you've played it for forty years, he'll point out something you hadn't noticed, and something quite significant.
Presenter
After you left the Royal Philharmonic, you went to the BBC. Was that an improvement or not? I mean, what about conditions? Well, nothing could be an improvement on the ARPU, as it was on Beecham's Day. There's not been anything like it before or since.
Presenter
The BBC did not suit me particularly because I like the variety of orchestral playing and I like the variety of places. I hate to go to the same seat every day. It was a good job. It was a pleasant job. But it had this disadvantage. It was a cloistered occupation and I didn't appreciate it so much. The BBC Symphony Orchestra possibly plays a wider variety of music than most orchestras. You had all the modern stuff. How do you take to that?
Presenter
Well, um no, I don't take to it.
Presenter
Not really. I'm interested in all sorts of music and I do actually quite enjoy playing avant-garde music, but I hate rehearsing avant-garde music because it's terribly time consuming and um quite painful.
Presenter
And you finished up, of course, in the London Symphony Orchestra. Yes.
Presenter
For many years you were at Gleinborn every summer. Now that must have been a marvellous occupation. That was quite delightful because we used to go as a family, my wife, myself and son, and settle down there and thoroughly enjoy everything that was going on, the golf, the tennis, the swimming, the parties, lovely hotels, wonderful dinners. And a little opera in the air. Occasional bits of opera, yes.
Jack Brymer
Yeah.
Speaker 4
Everybody
Jack Brymer
Occasional bits
Presenter
But it was so much a family affair, you were so much a part of the scene, and um the the the people who worked there were amazingly pleasant to be with, and great artists, tremendous artists, all of them.
Presenter
Well, some more music.
Presenter
Well, I should like to remind myself, I think, of this delightful um
Presenter
activity at Blindborn, and also my favorite composer, Mozart, by playing Barberina's Tiny Aria from Figallo. This is uh a girl, a peasant, looking for a uh a scarf pin that's been lost, and she's confused and quite breathless, but entirely delightful.
Speaker 4
From the screen!
Speaker 4
Fuck his song of race.
Speaker 4
For kissing
Speaker 4
A lot of
Speaker 4
Oh not marvel.
Speaker 4
In the screen, I don't know what
Speaker 4
A Christmas.
Speaker 4
Uh
Speaker 4
Chris Hoover
Presenter
Margaret Price as Barberina at the opening of the fourth act of Mozart's The Marriage of Figaro.
Presenter
Now apart from regular sessions with the orchestra, there are all the freelance jobs, the films and records. You've been a a session man, as as it's known in the trade, for many years. Yes, and you know, it's a remarkable life, inasmuch as you can run into almost anything. I remember going one day to do a session which was obviously uh an advertisement for something or other for Christmas.
Presenter
And uh a very fine musician called Francis Chagrin had written a duet for flute
Presenter
and a clarinet.
Presenter
Thousands of notes excruciatingly difficult. It lasted about thirty five seconds, and took us about three hours to master the art of playing it at all. Gerald Jackson and myself
Presenter
And at the end of this terrific scramble a gentleman came close to the microphone and simply said, For Christmas.
Presenter
And I discovered afterwards that he not only got three times as much money as we did, but he got a repeat every time the thing appeared, and we didn't. There's no justice.
Presenter
You've always been devoted to chamber music.
Presenter
Very much so.
Presenter
I should hate to be a chamber musician only, because this I think, rather like being um a sonata player, which I am also, of course, that's a sort of chamber music, can be a lonely activity.
Presenter
And I think to travel around with just a quartet
Presenter
Oh, just for the pianist?
Presenter
and meet a few people and um
Presenter
Then be on your own isn't quite the same as travelling with a large company. And of course you're also a BBC disc jockey, a rather superior one on Radio Three.
Jack Brymer
The wrong soup
Jack Brymer
Radio
Presenter
It's not all discs happily. It's uh it's also presenting um orchestral programmes. You know, it can be anything, and uh I'm delighted with it. I I love doing it.
Presenter
Record number six.
Presenter
Well, I'd like this to reflect my interest in jazz, because I am interested in jazz, but it certainly wouldn't be a clarinet record I'd take with me.
Presenter
because that would be too frustrating to have to actually analyze a clarinet record while not being able to play. Um I'd like to hear Oscar Peterson and the older Oscar Peterson uh style, a man tremendously interested in the the the the harmonic progressions of his jazz.
Presenter
Have you met Miss Jones?
Presenter
Oscapita Smith.
Presenter
Now what are your occupations outside music?
Presenter
Hobbies. Well, I'm rather fortunate in that I live with a golf course literally at the bottom of the garden. So that's one thing I have to uh do. And then of course the garden itself, which is a big one. Does demand a lot. Uh other than that, there's not much I have time for. You did mention at one time that you were up the on the roof putting some pitch on it or something, which means that you are a handyman.
Jack Brymer
New
Presenter
Uh fairly, yes. I don't make furniture or anything like that, though I've tried. But I can wield a hammer and a few nails, and um What I'm getting at is how good you're going to be at looking after yourself on the island.
Presenter
A as a boy, did you do any camping out? Yes. Uh I'd be pretty good at that sort of thing. Um and I think I could manage to do a bit of fishing.
Presenter
And I think I'd fix up some sort of shack. Mm-hmm. I'm quite certain I'd also fix up a boat or a raft of some sort. Yes, um mostly rowing rather than sailing, however. I was at one time connected with the Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve Band as a youth.
Jack Brymer
Book
Presenter
And we made a terrible mistake. We were told we could take our choice of rowing in cutters or whalers. Now a cutter sounds delightfully small in comparison with a whaler. It wasn't until we got in that we realized it's three times as big. And I was at the bow where you had you're the only one with only one oar.
Jack Brymer
And I was
Presenter
So I was on my own. It's quite a tough game. You'll know next time. I'll know next time. Record number seven.
Presenter
This I should like to be uh one of the most important philosophical uh pieces of chamber music, I think, uh by Beethoven.
Presenter
One of his late quartets, the um C sharp minor.
Presenter
This to me epitomises how a composer can take a form in music, like a fugue, which is a dullest ditchwater thing really, but by the treatment of it make it into almost a lament, and the incredible way that this great composer, at the end of his life,
Presenter
Could get this fugue, which is a a musical tapestry, to mean so much, is I think something I should like to remind myself of.
Presenter
The opening of the string quartet in C sharp minor, opus one hundred and thirty-one, the Amadairs quartet.
Presenter
Now we come to your last record. What's that to be?
Presenter
Well, I'd like it to be something that I recorded with Sir Thomas again, but this was very early in the picture. It was when Strauss was in the studio and when the young Tortellier came to record Don Quixot with this magnificent orchestra as a young man and with Strauss and with Beecham there, he was able to achieve, I think, something quite tremendous. And I feel that this would remind me of the beginning of the whole thing.
Presenter
The closing passage of Don Quixote by Richard Strauss, Paul Tortellier with the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Sir Thomas Beacham. If you could take just one disc out of the eight, which would it be? I think it would have to be Mozart and I think it would have to be the G minor quintet.
Presenter
and you're allowed to take one luxury with you.
Presenter
Could I please have a piano of some sort? It needn't be a new one, it could be quite old, as long as somebody could have left inside it a few of the Beethoven sonatas. Right, and it it will be an up, right? You don't mind that. I don't mind that at all.
Speaker 4
The majority of the
Presenter
And one book, apart from the Bible and Shakespeare, which are already on the island, and we frown on big encyclopedias. Yes, well, I think I'd like to explore some Dickens if I could. A volume of two or three of his books would be lovely. Right, we'll choose two or three and we'll have them bound together for you. And thank you, Jack Brimer, for letting us hear your Desert Island discs. And thank you so much, Roy, for the privilege of actually being on your programme. Thank you. Goodbye, everyone.
Speaker 3
You've been listening to a download from the Desert Island Discs archive.
Speaker 3
For more downloads, please visit the Radio 4 website.
Jack Brymer
Desert Island Discs was introduced by Roy Plumley, who also devised the programme.
Jack Brymer
Producer was Derek Drescher.
Jack Brymer
Next Saturday the castaway will be Sir Robert Meyer, founder of Youth and Music.
Jack Brymer
And of the Robert Meyer Concerts for Children.
Jack Brymer
That's next week, at the same time, six fifteen.
Presenter asks
How had you got into the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra?
I had been mingling with musicians as a sort of semi-professional ... somebody must have hinted to Sir Thomas that there was a clarinetist around who might be ... suitable. And ... to my astonishment one day the telephone rang ... A voice said, mister Brimer, I believe you play the clarionet. This is Sir Thomas Beacham ... and he did want to hear me play the clarinet. And that was the beginning of the whole thing.
Presenter asks
After you left the Royal Philharmonic, you went to the BBC. Was that an improvement or not?
Well, nothing could be an improvement on the ARPU, as it was on Beecham's Day ... The BBC did not suit me particularly because I like the variety of orchestral playing and I like the variety of places. I hate to go to the same seat every day ... It was a cloistered occupation and I didn't appreciate it so much.
“I really do believe that one human being without another has no significance whatsoever. I think it's a dead loss.”
“He would then almost sculpt the work in front of your eyes. It was like seeing somebody creating an image. He did it all by gesture, and it was a most remarkable thing, the way he could actually take a work and present it by gesture.”
“I do actually quite enjoy playing avant-garde music, but I hate rehearsing avant-garde music because it's terribly time consuming and ... quite painful.”