Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
Anatomist and anthropologist whose special interest is the study of primates.
Eight records
my earliest memory of I suppose a pop tune… used to play this interminably
Falling in Love AgainFavourite
I suppose it was my first love and my last love, as far as I am concerned
Choir of King's College Chapel, Cambridge
I remember walking through the streets … to find King's College Chapel … a very emotional time
Howard Keel and the Drury Lane Company
Being so impressed at the professionalism, the punch, the enthusiasm of their production
a tune to remind me of those balmy days when we're trying to be a scientist in the day and a magician in the evening
Whenever I lectured on the hands, I would always play a few bars of this record at the beginning of the lecture
We heard um the next record very many times during that period … and in fact it is the battle hymn of the republic
Igor Stravinsky conducting the Columbia Symphony Orchestra
it would be a joy to have that in my collection
The keepsakes
The book
Erskine Childers
The Riddle of the Sands, which to my mind is the finest um spy story that's ever been written.
The luxury
A Charles I. Silver Tankard to drink my cocoanut milk from. Just one touch of gracious living.
In conversation
Presenter asks
Could you endure loneliness?
I think quite easily. I've never been lonely. I've never … had the opportunity to be lonely. I've been solitary. … I enjoy my own company oddly enough.
Presenter asks
What would you be happiest to have got away from?
Oh, silly things really, like Sunday newspapers and sugar tongs. … things that annoy one.
Presenter asks
What was your first ambition as a boy?
My first ambition was to be an actor. … But my mother would never allow me to do this because she said it just wasn't a sound enough pattern of life. I had to be either a cobbler or a medical student. … so I became a medical student.
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 1
Hello, I'm Kirstie Young, and this is a podcast from the Desert Island Disc's Archive. For rights' reasons we've had to shorten the music. The programme was originally broadcast in nineteen seventy six, and the presenter was Roy Plumley.
Presenter
Our castaway this week is a scientist. He's an anatomist and anthropologist, and his special interest is the primates, which include us. It's Professor John Napier. Now, Professor Napier, you'll be the only primate on the island. Could you endure loneliness?
Presenter
I think quite easily.
Presenter
I've never been lonely. I've never at that say I've never had the opportunity to be lonely.
Presenter
I've been solitary.
Presenter
There is a difference, I think. Indeed. Um yes, I I enjoy it. I enjoy my own company oddly enough.
Presenter
What would you be happiest to have got away from?
Presenter
Oh, silly things really, like Sunday newspapers and sugar tongs. You know, things that annoy one.
Presenter
Yes.
Presenter
Um is music important to you? Um yes, very important, but not intellectually.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Presenter
Have you any skill at music? Do you play an instrument?
Presenter
No. No. I play I used to play the drums, but everybody used to play the drums, so I don't count that. No, I think I emotionally, yes, I think it counts a lot. You've chosen your eight records on a basis of emotional.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Presenter
Yeah. Where do we start? What's the first one? Uh the first one is uh my earliest memory of I suppose a pop tune.
Presenter
Uh and that is who?
Presenter
Sung by Jack Buchanan and Binnie Hale. I used to play this interminably, lying on Axminster carpet with a wind up Columbia grammophone beside me.
John Napier
Town my heart away.
John Napier
Makes me dream all day, dreams I know can never come true.
John Napier
Seems as though I'd ever be blue.
Presenter
Jack Buchanan and Benny Hale singing Who from the musical show Sunny. What's your second disc?
Presenter
Falling in Love Again sung by Marlena Dietrich.
Presenter
Why do you choose it?
Presenter
Well, it's a it's a long story. When I was about eleven I broke my leg when I was at school.
Presenter
very badly and it was uh treated rather badly. And I was in and out of hospital for
Presenter
Five or six years. So my schooling went all to pot.
Presenter
I had to get back to school, then there'd be another operation and then I'd have to have a rest and recuperation.
Presenter
And um
Presenter
Finally, um
Presenter
Um my parents were of course in India.
Presenter
And I used to uh be uh
Presenter
Treat it to a trip out.
Presenter
to see them quite often. I must have gone out about three times.
Presenter
You know, we used you could go for fifty pounds return on the on the piano in those days.
Presenter
Of course, even travelling posh. Posh? Don't you know posh? Oh, posh is uh that's where it all comes from. Port out, starboard home. Oh, it's a lot of power. Posh, of course. That's forgotten. But uh
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Speaker 1
But uh
John Napier
Ha.
Presenter
This was a wonderful time for me because I was twelve and thirteen, that sort of age then.
Presenter
And uh it was terribly romantic. My father, as I say, was in tropical medicine, and he had a big apartment in uh Calcutta, overlooking the Maidan, for those of you who know Calcutta.
Presenter
The Victoria Memorial.
Presenter
and uh every evening at drink time.
Presenter
We'd be sitting round in whiskey chairs on the veranda.
Presenter
and having drinks.
Presenter
and you see all round you the night it was dark by then.
Presenter
and you could see the lights of all the little villages or bustis in the distance, and you could hear the music coming from these villages. You could almost smell the smells of India, sort of a combination I always think of patchouli,
Presenter
and drains, but an unforgettable sort of smell. And it was a very romantic time for me.
Presenter
And e every evening my father used to play this this record.
Presenter
He put it on and uh I just
Presenter
I suppose it was my first love and my last love, as far as I am concerned.
Speaker 3
Love's always been my game, lead how I may.
Speaker 3
I was made that way.
Speaker 3
I can't help it.
Speaker 3
Men clustered to me, like moths around the flame.
Speaker 3
And if they're wing firm, I know I'm not to blame.
Speaker 3
Falling into love again.
Presenter
Marlena Dev.
Presenter
What was your first ambition as a boy? My first ambition was to be an actor.
Presenter
Was the acting in the family?
Presenter
my mother and her brother, my uncle.
Presenter
Uh we're both actors at the Ovik.
Presenter
during the last part of the war and the early post-war period.
Presenter
My uncle unfortunately died in the eighteen.
Presenter
Flu epidemic.
John Napier
Thought.
Presenter
But I was very much brought up in the theatrical world because my mother had so many friends.
Presenter
and, as far as I could see, it was the only thing to be was to be an actor.
Presenter
But uh my mother would never allow me to do this because she said it just wasn't a a sound enough pattern of life.
Presenter
I had to be either.
Presenter
A cobbler.
Presenter
or a medical student. Why those two alternatives, I don't know, but they were her two alternatives. They won't for see why medical student, because my father was a doctor.
Presenter
But uh I was given that choice and so I became a medical student. Where did you study? I studied balance.
Presenter
And you became a surgeon.
Presenter
Eventually I became a surgeon in the in the early years of the war. You became a a rather specialized surgeon on uh
Presenter
An orthopaedic surgeon specializing in nerve injuries of the hand. Yes, well that was because it it was wartime and that is really the sort of things we were seeing.
Presenter
Uh I I specialized in uh nerve injuries, but one also had normal sum of gunshot wounds of military and also wounds from air raids.
Presenter
In fact, um my surgical practice was related to wounds and wounds alone.
Presenter
So somewhat naturally when the war sort of came to an end,
Presenter
I felt
Presenter
that I oughtn't to I couldn't launch myself on.
Presenter
on the the poor Richardsvillian population.
Presenter
'Cause all I was any good at was gunshot wounds. So I decided in fact to go into research and to to leave uh practice. And you took a series of academic posts?
Presenter
Oh yes, as an anatomist. Yes. Uh reader in anatomy at the Royal Free Hospital. Um then you were director of primate biology.
Presenter
At the University of London. Yep. And you founded the primate biology unit at the Smithsonian. That's in Washington, isn't it? Yes, that's in Washington.
Speaker 1
Yes, that
Presenter
Well, we had been um teaching primate biology in this country and the Smithsonian, which is really a magnificent, incredible research institution, felt that they must uh have a a specialist department of the sort that we'd had in the university in in in England.
Presenter
And, um, I accepted an offer to go and start one off, largely for research purposes, not for teaching purposes, for research. Yeah. That was a marvellous time, wonderful time.
Presenter
Well, we've had a a very brief rundown of your uh professional career. Let's break at this point for your third record. What's it to be?
Presenter
thirty-nine the beginning of the war.
Presenter
I was in Cambridge.
Presenter
Because baths have been evacuated.
Presenter
My fiance, who was now my wife, came up for Christmas and it was incredible because it was the first Christmas of the war. Cambridge was dark.
Presenter
and there was snow everywhere, but
Presenter
I remember walking through the streets um to find King's College Chapel, because I want very much wanted to hear the Festival of Lessons and Carols.
Presenter
And I remember walking in, no cures, no booking,
Presenter
And I was remember this.
Presenter
I suppose a very emotional time.
Presenter
And it was the processional hymn once in Ronald David's City.
John Napier
God's fear.
John Napier
He has helped.
John Napier
To taste for God's being.
John Napier
A trend who sat best.
John Napier
Completion.
Presenter
Once in Royal David City, the choir of King's College Chapel, Cambridge.
Presenter
You've lectured and and broadcast and written a number of books. Your wife works in the same field. She does. She works in the field of uh monkeys and apes and primates. Uh she works in the British Museum, in fact, Natural History Museum.
Presenter
You have collaborated on the wrote a book together called The A Handbook of Living Primates. uh listing all the primates and, you know, describing their characters and showing photographs of them. And it's a book that has really done remarkably well, in fact, although uh it comes a myths from me to suggest it. But it really has become a standard work, I think. We've published this ten years ago and it's still very much used.
Presenter
I've been reading your book, Monkeys Without Tails, which explains very simply where we've come from, how we've evolved. But where are we going to? How do you think man will evolve in the future to to meet our changing environment?
Presenter
I don't know that he really will do much evolving in the future. I think you might imagine that a man could live
Presenter
Well, forever, as long as there's a to live on.
Presenter
Or for perhaps not more than a hundred years. I think it depends what happens. I think he's living on the edge of danger all the time, as a for extinction of the species.
Presenter
Uh as far as physical change is concerned,
Presenter
I don't think he's going to change very much.
Presenter
Um I think that it may well be that in uh a few decades, perhaps even, we'll gradually find men and women are growing much more alike.
Presenter
to look at, because what is happening is natural selection is removing the extremes, or rather man's selection is removing the extremes of type. The great caveman type is going.
Presenter
Andy
Presenter
beautifully Rubin-esque kind of female is going. And what they're left with are sort of intermediate types in which the um male and female look very much alike. Let's have record number four. What's that to be?
Presenter
Uh it was the end of the war and um Oklahoma was the first of the new musicals.
Presenter
to come to England from America. And uh I think it was almost the first theatre that I'd been to since the war. It was going to Oklahoma Drury Lane.
Presenter
And um
Presenter
Being so impressed at the professionalism, the punch, the enthusiasm of their production.
John Napier
Yeah.
Presenter
Howard Keel with the rest of the Crowdie Lane Company of Oklahoma.
Presenter
Professor Napier, you're fascinated by legendary creatures and monsters. You've written a book called Bigfoot, about the Yeti, primarily.
Presenter
Ah, yes, I'm afraid I did. Well, you see
Presenter
Yetis and abominable snowmens and Sasquatches and
Presenter
monograndis, as they're called in South America. They're all very much the same. There is a giant man myth.
Presenter
The the general description about people who have seen these creatures, or claim to have seen them, is that they are ape-like.
Presenter
There's something between uh a modern ape and a modern man.
Presenter
Well, I suppose it was my interest in the primates, in apes particularly, made me feel that this ought to be looked into. So that's what I did in Bigfoot, and tried to analyse it as one would analyse a a living animal that you could touch and see.
Presenter
Uh one had to to create one's animals from the reports, of course.
Presenter
Right, let's get on to another facet of your life which is very important: magic.
Presenter
Well, it was important really, but it was fun.
Presenter
This is I suppose this is to sort of throw back to my theatrical ambitions. I used to do a sort of solo.
Presenter
Copperty type A.
Presenter
uh with mainly with rope. It was great fun. I did all sorts of cabarets and so on for clubs and um
Presenter
And a little pocket money too, incidentally. Then my wife and I decided we put on an act together, a musical act what is known in the trade as a silent act. That means there's music all the time. And this was disastrous in many ways, because we were always many bars behind the music.
Presenter
We'd never catch up if anything went wrong. We were miles behind, and records would end before we'd even sort of got half way through the trick. I remember once, it was really the the apotheosis of of my magic career, is Pru and I appeared at the Albert Hall. We played, as the expression is, the Albert Hall.
Presenter
Now, if you asked me how many people were there when we played the Albert Hall, I'd have to admit to you there were only fifty, but I'll
Speaker 1
But I don't know.
Presenter
Not really. But nevertheless, we did play the Albert Hall, and that was the moment to end my magical career. Right, let's have record number five.
Speaker 1
BEAP
Presenter
Well now this in fact is is a tune to remind me of those balmy days when we're trying to be a scientist in the day and a magician in the evening. And Pro and I used to do this act to th this tune.
Presenter
Frank Posell and his strings Les Levandière du Portugal.
Presenter
You've done a great deal of television through the years, haven't you? Um well, I don't know how much I've uh well, it's a great deal. Uh but I've been in it since about uh nineteen fifty nine, fifty eight, fifty nine.
Presenter
Uh I mean in days when television programmes went out live, if that p puts it in a perspective of a sort.
Presenter
Can you recall one or two particularly successful programmes that you thought came out very well?
Speaker 1
Yeah.
John Napier
Yeah.
Presenter
I don't know whether their successor is wonderful for me, and that's in the very early days of the Horizon programme, which is still running, as you know.
Presenter
I introduced it for a season and um this was uh very exciting, it was very hard work, and I learnt a lot about television during that time. And then uh more recently I did a series called The Animal Game from Bristol. But I I I I remember one
John Napier
But
Presenter
television programme that I must um mention. One of my very first programmes.
Presenter
and it was to be on the hands.
Presenter
And I thought to myself, Well, now this is an opportunity to put across to the great British public marvellous information about the hand. This is my chance. And we recorded the programme and I did all my heavy, heavy stuff. And I said, Well, are we having any music at the beginning? And um the producer said, Oh, don't worry, I'll I'll I'll put that on top, I'll dump that on and you'll hear it when you hear the see the programme.
Presenter
So the programme uh duly went out.
Presenter
And my horror
Presenter
The opening music
Presenter
that was to introduce this serious programme.
Presenter
was this
Presenter
Hands to hold someone you care for You need hands to show that you're sincere
Presenter
When you feel nobody wants to know you
Presenter
You need hands to brush away the tears.
Presenter
That was of course Max Bygraves seeing you need hands. Well having got over the cultural shock on that occasion, I became very, very fond of m Max's hands. And in fact, I'd rarely say it it's it's one of my favorite records. And uh it's because it really
Presenter
Sort of seems to be my signature tune. Whenever I lectured on the hands, I would always play a few bars of this record at the beginning of the lecture. How would you manage on this desert island? Are you an efficient sort of man at looking after yourself? Not bad.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Yeah.
Speaker 1
Yes, I
Presenter
Yes, I'm not sure.
Speaker 1
They're not
Presenter
Never any fishing, no.
Presenter
But I think shorter fishing I would be moderately handy most other things. Would you try to escape?
Presenter
No, I don't think so.
Presenter
I think I should be enjoying it.
Presenter
Let's have record number seven.
Presenter
Uh record number seven uh really is uh to remind me of nearly three years in Washington.
Presenter
And we were in Washington at the time when
Presenter
Things were pretty tough, I must admit. Uh Martin Luther King had been assassinated, Bobby Kennedy had been assassinated.
Presenter
and the the Black Riots had uh started in Washington. And in fact I was in New York, on the B B C offices on Fifth Avenue in New York.
Presenter
When the riot started in Washington, as with the American correspondent of the BBC, who then was Gerald Priestland.
John Napier
Yeah.
Presenter
And uh I I remember him picking up the telephone and saying, What, Washington's Burning?
Presenter
and slapping it down, pick up another telephone saying, Get me a satellite I thought those were immortal words, get me a satellite and I imagine he did get the satellite. Anyway, um we heard um the next record very, very many times during that period uh and in fact it is the battle hymn of the republic.
Presenter
A Battle Hymn of the Republic sung by the Mormon Tabernacle Choir.
Presenter
Which brings us to your last record. Yes, sadly I'm afraid it is. This is the Stravinsky Rite of Spring, and I would like to take it with me because it reminds me of a very, very happy, if somewhat arduous, time when I was lucky enough to be asked to do the Christmas lectures for the young people at the Royal Institution. They were broadcast on BBC.
Presenter
And in one of the lectures I was talking about the
Presenter
extinction of the dinosaurs and uh we showed them the
Presenter
piece about the dinosaurs from Disney's Fantasia. And of course he used the Rider Spring music uh to show the fate of those poor dinosaurs. And uh it would be a joy to have that in my collection.
Presenter
An excerpt from Strabinski's The Right of Spring, the composer conducting the Columbia Symphony Orchestra. If you could take just one disc, which would it be?
Presenter
I think it would be falling in love again. Marlena Dietrich.
Presenter
And one luxury to take to the island with you?
Presenter
Hmm.
Presenter
Yes, I know exactly what I want. I would like
Presenter
A Charles I. Silver Tankard to drink my cocoanut milk from. Just one touch of gracious living. And one book apart from the Bible, Shakespeare, or big encyclopedias.
Presenter
I think it would have to be The Riddle of the Sands, which to my mind is the finest um spy story that's ever been written.
Presenter
By asking Childers. And thank you, Professor John Napier, for letting us hear your Desert Island Discs. Thank you for asking me.
Presenter
Goodbye, everyone.
Speaker 1
You've been listening to a podcast from the Desert Islandists Archive. For more podcasts, please visit bbc.co.uk/slash radio four.
Presenter asks
How do you think man will evolve in the future to meet our changing environment?
I don't know that he really will do much evolving in the future. … I think it depends what happens. I think he's living on the edge of danger … as far as physical change is concerned, I don't think he's going to change very much. … it may well be that … men and women are growing much more alike.
Presenter asks
Can you recall one or two particularly successful television programmes that came out very well?
I don't know whether their successor is wonderful for me … I introduced [Horizon] for a season … it was very exciting … I remember one television programme that I must mention … on the hands … I did all my heavy stuff … the opening music … was this … 'You need hands' … became very, very fond of Max's hands.
Presenter asks
How would you manage on this desert island? Are you an efficient sort of man at looking after yourself?
Not bad. … Never any fishing, no. … I think shorter fishing I would be moderately handy most other things. … No, I don't think [I would try to escape]. I think I should be enjoying it.
“I've never been lonely. I've never at that say I've never had the opportunity to be lonely.”
“You could almost smell the smells of India, sort of a combination I always think of patchouli, and drains, but an unforgettable sort of smell.”
“I suppose it was my first love and my last love, as far as I am concerned.”
“Being so impressed at the professionalism, the punch, the enthusiasm of their production.”
“A Charles I Silver Tankard to drink my cocoanut milk from. Just one touch of gracious living.”