Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
Cricket commentator and writer, best known for his cricket commentary.
Eight records
And it was Rubenstein's melody in F that he used to play and in a way it speaks to me about that very kind man.
A very fine actor and one of the most moving singers I've ever known in my life. And I thought he did something with the Negro spiritual, which I don't believe anybody else ever did better.
I think this is a quite outstanding example of discipline. Balance, poise, timing, singing, culling cat.
Fern HillFavourite
It was the voice of a man who wrote his poetry, almost engraved it, so that every word had to have its true value.
An important poem because it's supposed to indicate a lost love in Hardy's life.
I think if I'm on a desert island I want a laugh. I'm sure the Yetis would infallibly give me one.
since I'm hoping to be rescued, we might as well have a sea shanty, I suppose, and again, ain't there some splendid discipline, he a voice discipline.
My last disc I think would be the boar's head carol sung by the Elizabethan singers.
The keepsakes
The book
Laurence Sterne
Handsomely bound. And the first edition. And a first edition, of which, of course, volumes 5, 7, and 9 were all signed by Stern himself. Yes, he didn't trust his publisher. So announced, they came at in twos, you see. They announced that the only genuine copies had been signed by him. A cautious author.
The luxury
Perpetually renewed case of champagne
It was Alec Waugh, wasn't it? He said one of the compensations of cryole is that you're learning to appreciate champagne.
In conversation
Presenter asks
How would you feel about being on a desert island for a while?
I think I wouldn't mind a desert island for a while. I couldn't endure it forever, but uh... Yes, I think time to contemplate one's toenails without interruption.
Presenter asks
What would you be happiest to have got away from on this island?
Noise. ... traffic noise, the noise above all of the juggernauts which really fill me with an illogical and for me fairly unusual hate. I just abominate the things that I've been doing.
Presenter asks
When did you start commentating on cricket?
Quite by accident, and it was sheer accident, I was in the Eastern service broadcasting, that is, to India, Malaya, Southeast Asia, the Eastern Service to the PBC. And they decided to let India know that they realized an Indian cricket team had come here. They sent me off to do ten minutes a day on each of the first two matches, intending not to do any more. They sent me solely for the reason that since I worked in that section, I was presumed to know how to pronounce the Indian names. That's the only reason I was set. That was the beginning of a very distinguished commentating career.
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 1
BBC Sounds, Music, Radio Podcasts. Hello, I'm Lauren Laverne, and this is the Desert Island Discs podcast. For rights reasons, the music is shorter than on the original broadcast. The presenter is Roy Plomley. I hope you enjoy listening.
Presenter
This week, our castaway is the writer and cricket commentator, John Arlot.
Presenter
John, how would you feel about being on a desert island for a while?
Presenter
I think I wouldn't mind a desert island for a while. I couldn't endure it forever, but uh
Presenter
Yes, I think time to contemplate one's toenails without interruption.
Presenter
What would you be happiest to have got away from on this island? Noise.
Presenter
Any particular noise that sets your teeth on it.
Presenter
traffic noise, the noise above all of the juggernauts which really fill me with
Presenter
An illogical and for me fairly unusual hate. I just abominate the things that I've been doing.
Presenter
Is music important in my life?
Presenter
Yes, it is.
Presenter
I'm not a serious musician. I don't know very much about it. Associative music, certainly.
Presenter
But
Presenter
The voice to me
Presenter
was so long a professional matter when I was a
Presenter
producer and I was an instructor in the B V C training school, I was so concerned with the voice and what could be done with it that I think that almost replaced
Presenter
Instrumental music for me. Yes. So that obviously that is a a key to your desert island choice.
Presenter
It is, yes. What do we start with?
Presenter
Well, start with not the voice at all. Rubenstein's melody and F. Yes. Which does really in fact speak to me because my father, who was
Presenter
And the Dickensian phrase, very good to me, was a very
Presenter
good, versatile musician who could play wind instruments and string instruments. And very late in life he taught himself to play the piano.
Presenter
And it was Rubenstein's melody in F that he used to play and in a way it speaks to me about that very kind man.
Presenter
Rubenstein's Melody and F played by Philippe Entremont.
Presenter
What's your second choice?
Presenter
I think I'd like to Edric Connor, Negro Spiritual.
Presenter
A very fine actor and one of the most moving singers I've ever known in my life. And I thought he did something with the Negro spiritual, which I don't believe anybody else ever did better.
Presenter
I'd like to pray his mercy pouring down.
John Arlott
What a mercy pouring down!
John Arlott
What a mercy for and love What a mercy for and dove my Lord in the heart when I sin a man dies
John Arlott
Television perandum.
John Arlott
Salavis foreign Salavis
John Arlott
My Lord in the heart when I see the man die.
Presenter
Etric Connor singing Mercy Pouring Down
Presenter
John, you're known as a Hampshire man. Were you born on Hampshire soil? Yes, I was. I was.
Presenter
Born in Basingstoke, which can hardly be called, well, I suppose you could call it Hampshire, but hardly call it soil now. Changed a lot since I was there, anyway. As a youngster, what did you want to be? I think I would rather have liked to be a farmer, because if you grew up in the days of the slump, you had the impression that farmers would never be out of work, and everybody else was likely to be. Now, I have it on good authority that you failed your school certificate. What was your first job?
Presenter
My first job was in a town planning office, an office boy in a town planning office, one of the early ones in fact.
Presenter
And that.
Presenter
And then I'm a dun too.
Presenter
stores clerk in a mental hospital.
Presenter
And then to the police force. Yes, you became a plainclothes man in Southampton. The job of a detective in a seaport sounds exciting.
Presenter
You never think of it as exciting if you're doing it, of course, and one did
Presenter
Initial
Presenter
years on the bait, which probably were more hazardous, if anything was hazardous, than fine clothes duty ever was.
Presenter
But in fact Southampton had the reputation, which I think it still enjoys, of being about the cleanest port on the seven seas. And there wasn't an awful lot of violence. There were places where occasionally
Presenter
You like to go with another policeman, but on the whole it wasn't a bad place. It wasn't a very dangerous life at all. Except of course during the air raids it really was bad. Yes, indeed. How was your cricket at that time?
Presenter
Oh, passionate but indifferent. You did in fact play twelve man for the county. I fielded twelve man for Hampshire on two or three occasions, but I think that was really a an indulgence to my enthusiasm rather than any indication that I was
Presenter
Anywhere near county standard as a player. When did you start to write?
Presenter
Started right during the war, about 1941 to 42. Never dreaming that anybody would ever publish anything I wrote. What was your first published piece? First published piece of poem called Cricket at Worcester.
Presenter
Which was sent by a friend of mine, Sir George Hamilton, in fact, was sent by him to Cyril Connolly, who was then editor of Horizon, is, I suppose, the
Presenter
outstanding intellectual publication of the day and
Presenter
To my utter amazement, Cyril Connolly published it.
Presenter
That was a very promising start.
Presenter
Very willing moment.
Presenter
Let's have your third record. What's that, John?
Presenter
Kind of the Russian Don Cossack choirs. I think this is a quite outstanding example of
Presenter
Discipline.
Presenter
Balance, poise, timing, singing, culling cat.
John Arlott
Somebody come on.
Speaker 1
Come on, come on.
John Arlott
Oh yeah.
Presenter
Kalinka by the Don Casseck Choir. It was your first writing that brought you into broadcasting, wasn't it? Yes, because I joined the staff as a poetry producer, which I remained for.
Presenter
Five years until I went and became general instructor in the training school. I was never a staff commentator, never in outside broadcasts.
John Arlott
Uh
Presenter
You were at the microphone yourself quite a lot, though. I remember you were compere of Country Magazine for Francis Dylan. Yes, I did that. I even did.
Presenter
20 questions when Governor Harding took one of his little holidays.
Presenter
When when did you start commentating on cricket?
Presenter
Quite by accident, and it was sheer accident, I was in the Eastern service broadcasting, that is, to India, Malaya, Southeast Asia, the Eastern Service to the PBC.
Presenter
And they decided to let India know that they realized an Indian cricket team had come here.
Presenter
They sent me off to do ten minutes a day on each of the first two matches, intending not to do any more. They sent me solely for the reason that
Presenter
Since I worked in that section, I was presumed to know how to pronounce the Indian names. That's the only reason I was set. That was the beginning of a very distinguished commentating career. When did you decide to join the ranks of the merry insecure freelancers?
Presenter
It must have been about 1952 or three, and I didn't decide it. The BBC decided it by informing me that my outside activities were an embarrassment to the administrators. Would I therefore please either give up writing for the papers or leave?
Presenter
Right, another record.
Presenter
Yes, this could be a Dylan Thomas, a Dylan Thomas reading.
Presenter
Fernhill. Yes. You worked with him a lot in your producing days. I did. According to an RN Taufin Davis, three-quarters of the broadcasting he ever did, he did for me. He had, of course, this unique and this wonderful voice. It was the voice of a man who wrote his poetry, almost engraved it, so that.
Presenter
Every word had to have its true value. It used to seem almost to sting it out, spit it out, its utter clarity of isolation of each word as well as each idea. Or let's listen to him reading the opening of his poem, Thern Hill.
Speaker 2
Now as I was young and easy Under the apple boughs about the lilting house And happy as the grass was green, The night above the dingle starry Time let me hail and climb Golden in the heydays of his eyes And honoured among wagons I was Prince of the apple towns And once below a time I lordly had the trees and leaves Trail with daisies and barley Down the rivers of the windfall light.
Presenter
Uh
Presenter
The voice of Dylan Thomas.
Presenter
Your cricket commentating must be almost a full-time job in the summer. A great deal of travelling, of course.
Presenter
Yes, it's a seven-day-a-week job and everyone forgets the travelling, but the travelling is at times extremely heavy. It's very hard on the players themselves, of course. There must be a great deal of background reading for you, too, to to keep up with it all.
Presenter
That's quite painless, of course. One doesn't notice it. I did that from childhood without any thoughts of being a commentator. If I'm interested in anything, I read it automatically. Yes.
Presenter
Are there sometimes days when you pray for rain?
Presenter
No, rain at a cricket match is a contradiction in terms and a cricket ground in the rain to my mind is the most depressing place on earth. Yes.
Presenter
You work mostly on commentate mostly on sound radio. You don't do so much on television. There is, of course, a great difference in approach.
Presenter
An immense difference, and such talent as I have.
Presenter
It's probably more suited to sound radio as a descriptive ability than to anything else.
Presenter
But one makes this conscious change. As soon as you go to television, you try, try to add to the picture, not to describe the picture.
Presenter
Through the years, what are the events that have ruffled your famous calm?
Presenter
Once I was doing Commentary at Southampton and there was a vertical ladder that went up, I suppose, about 35, 40 feet.
Presenter
I was sitting in the committee room, drinking pot.
Presenter
And I suddenly realized I was due on the air for the first broadcast after lunch, so I set out.
Presenter
I ran down and as I went round the back of the pavilion, the O B engineers were as usual uncomfortably housed in the coal hole. And as I went by I said, All right, I shall be there. Fade the mic up.
Speaker 1
I ran.
John Arlott
Right.
Speaker 1
Uh
Presenter
I shot up the ladder and I'd got almost to the top when I saw my then four-year-old son struggling up the vertical ladder behind me with my very heavy dispatch case in his hand. And I looked out and saw an old policeman friend of mine down on the seats and said, please look after that little boy and got in, put the earphones on and I just missed the announcement. And I heard the girl at Bristol say, all right, we'll go back to John Holliday in a minute. I think that's the only time I'll ever...
Presenter
Hail to be on the air. That was a frightening moment.
Presenter
There is, of course, a good deal of corrugated iron roof work in commentating cricket, isn't there? There is. It's not as bad as it used to be. There used to be a a green tarpaulin igloo at Leicester, which really was, might have been made to create drafts. It was colder and draftier in there than it was if one had had nothing.
Presenter
Let's have record number five. Well, that for me would be a Thomas Hardy poem to Lisby Brown, set to music by Finzi and sung by John Carroll Case. An important poem because it's supposed to indicate a lost love in Hardy's life. One of the things that he tried to conceal and he subsequently bart his correspondence.
John Arlott
Here is people.
John Arlott
Where are you now in sun, in rain?
John Arlott
What is your brow past joy past fade?
John Arlott
Sweet Lisby Brown, how you could smile, how you could sing.
Speaker 1
How you could smile, how you
Presenter
John Carroll Case singing part of To Lisby Brown, the Thomas Hardy poem set by Gerald Finzi.
Presenter
Now your other occupations, John, you are of course
Presenter
a wine and cricket correspondent for a newspaper.
Presenter
And you've written a lot of books.
Presenter
What have you written recently?
Presenter
Well three, one is a huge book, the heaviest book.
Presenter
I've ever written, ever shall write. Uh, in terms of physical weight, in fact, it's this big Oxford companion to sports and games.
Presenter
which is supposed to describe and give the history and the outstanding biographies of performers.
Presenter
In all the competitive sports of the world. That's a big one. How long's that taken? It was a very big one. Long enough, five years. Mm-hmm.
Presenter
And the others?
Presenter
Two books about wine, one about burgundy and the other one about champagne, yes.
Presenter
Still, uh Hampshire, of course, you've written for the Hampshire magazine for many years, essays. I've done the lead there for twelve years now, and in a way my
Presenter
My duty though. I always feel that one. Yes. And it must have been a great joy, John, when all those years after failing your school cert, you were given an honorary MA at Southampton University.
Presenter
That was very exciting, very embarrassing, but very exciting. We've got to record number six.
Presenter
Well, I think if I'm on a desert island I want a laugh. I'm sure the Yetis would infallibly give me one. And although I believe that the name in the first stanza should be Fairham, which is in Hampshire, and not Wareham, which is in Dorset, where they come from, I'll settle for their version of Buttercup Joe.
John Arlott
Now I be a truebred country chap. Me father comes from where'em. Me mother she's got some more like I, and well knows how to rear'em. Some folks calls I bacon face and others termit head. But I can prove I ain't no fool, though I be country bred, for I can plow and milk again.
Presenter
The Yetis. How resourceful would you be on this island? You could lock up some sort of shelter. I'm not very good at this. And when my
Presenter
Middle son Timothy left his junior school and had his valedictory report. Under handicrafts, the master wrote, cheerfully hopeless. And I'm afraid this does rather run in the family. Yes, it's a nice thing to have said about you, though. It's friendly.
Presenter
Um, would the frugal living worry you? You wouldn't have much luxury in the way of food or drink. Yes, it would. It would distress me very much indeed. I don't like food in large quantities, but having been spoilt by being the son of and the husband of good cooks, I like good food, not too much of it. Would you try to get away?
Presenter
No, I'd be content to wait until I was rescued, I didn't, as long as I didn't have to eat. Right. Record number seven.
Presenter
Well, since I'm hoping to be rescued, we might as well have a sea shanty, I suppose, and again, ain't there some splendid
Presenter
Discipline, he a voice discipline. This very macabre one called Go Down You Red Red Roses sung by Burl Ives.
Speaker 2
In eighteen hundred and fifty seven Come down, you bunch of roses, come down.
Presenter
Come down
John Arlott
Uh
Speaker 2
We say
John Arlott
Build up to the gates of heaven. Oh, you pinks and posies, come down, you red, red roses, come down. Saint Peter would not let us in. Come down, you bunch of roses, come down.
Presenter
Come down.
John Arlott
He sent us back to earth again.
Presenter
Burr Lives and a Sea Shanty, which brings us to your last disc.
Presenter
My last disc I think would be the boar's head carol sung by the Elizabethan singers.
John Arlott
Some of these don't
John Arlott
A ball's hand is out.
John Arlott
With paying some money for each
Speaker 2
Let's go!
John Arlott
Who's he deserved?
John Arlott
Just beat you all.
John Arlott
Which one?
Presenter
The Bawshead Carol by the Elizabethan singers. If you could take just one disc out of eight, which would it be?
Presenter
I'd take the Dylan Thomas reading of Fernhill.
Presenter
It moves me very deeply indeed.
Presenter
And one luxury to take with you.
Presenter
Perpetually renewed case of champagne. It was Alec Waugh, wasn't it? He said one of the compensations of cryole is that you're learning to appreciate champagne. This will be arranged and your very, very favorite vintage and brand.
Presenter
and one book apart from the Bible, Shakespeare, and big encyclopedias.
Presenter
Tristram Shandy, Lawrence Stones, Tristram Shandy.
Presenter
Handsomely bound. Handsomely bound. And the first edition. And a first edition, of which, of course, volumes 5, 7, and 9 were all signed by Stern himself. Yes, he didn't trust his publisher. So announced, they came at in twos, you see. They announced that the only genuine copies had been signed by him. A cautious author. Thank you, John Arland, for letting us hear your desert island discs.
Presenter
Very nice to have been with you. Thank you, Ryan. Goodbye, everyone.
Presenter asks
Are there sometimes days when you pray for rain?
No, rain at a cricket match is a contradiction in terms and a cricket ground in the rain to my mind is the most depressing place on earth.
Presenter asks
How resourceful would you be on this island?
I'm not very good at this. And when my middle son Timothy left his junior school and had his valedictory report. Under handicrafts, the master wrote, cheerfully hopeless. And I'm afraid this does rather run in the family.
“I think I wouldn't mind a desert island for a while. I couldn't endure it forever, but uh... Yes, I think time to contemplate one's toenails without interruption.”
“traffic noise, the noise above all of the juggernauts which really fill me with an illogical and for me fairly unusual hate. I just abominate the things that I've been doing.”
“It was the voice of a man who wrote his poetry, almost engraved it, so that every word had to have its true value. It used to seem almost to sting it out, spit it out, its utter clarity of isolation of each word as well as each idea.”
“Under handicrafts, the master wrote, cheerfully hopeless. And I'm afraid this does rather run in the family.”
“I'd take the Dylan Thomas reading of Fernhill. It moves me very deeply indeed.”