Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
Former chorister at St Paul's Cathedral who became a chorus master and accompanist for the BBC, and worked with Toscanini.
Eight records
I think I should like to remember that by hearing Hedel Nash sing the dream song.
Symphony No.9 in D minor, Op.125: IV. Presto – Allegro assai (Ode to Joy)
It really illustrates what I mean. It's part of Beethoven's Chorus Symphony. The last movement. Where the Bay's service comes in with his great restitive and says let's not have any more of this humming and haring, let's get on with the song of joy.
Polly Garter's Song (from Under Milk Wood)
I should like to recall Wales. I remember when I announced at the breakfast table that we were going to Liverpool. My two daughters, who were about 12 and 10 then, wept into their porridge because they loved living in South Wales so much. So I'd like to hear Polly Garter song of Manda Milkwood.
Winterstürme wichen dem Wonnemond (Spring Song)Favourite
I think Wagner is one of the greatest composers. And if I were on that island I'd like to have something to remind me of the grand sweep and scope of his music. And I think I would take the Spring song, which is sung by Siegmund in the first act of Die Vauquira.
Quatuor pour la fin du temps: V. Louange à l'Éternité de Jésus
Well, I've chosen this because it's by a not dead composer, Messiar. A piece which he wrote when he was a prisoner of war in Poland. It shows what amazing tranquility can be achieved by a great composer, under difficult circumstances, It's the fifth movement of his quartet The End of Time. in which the cello and piano are heard alone.
Ein Heldenleben: closing section
I have the most Carti. Admiration and loving memories of Sir Thomas Beacham. I'd like to take. Something that he'd recorded with me. After a lot of thought, I've chosen the very end of Strauss's tone poem, Einhildendeben, A Hero's Life.
The keepsakes
No book or luxury recorded for this episode.
In conversation
Presenter asks
Do you come from a musical family?
Not really. I think somewhere way back there was a famous singer. Ada Crossley in our family. But my mother was a nice singer of ballads. Yes, played the piano nicely, but uh not really musical.
Presenter asks
Was Toscanini a difficult man?
I think he was a difficult man in that he was very fiery. Because he couldn't understand English, was apt to think that if anybody said anything they were being rude to him.
Presenter asks
How did he compare with Beecham?
He used to call Beecham Arlachino or Pagliaccio. And Beecham used to refer to him either as poor old Toscanini or a military bandmaster. So I think they they were both fire and brimstone people, but beecham had more charm.
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 1
BBC Sounds, Music, Radio, Podcasts. Hello, I'm Lauren Laverne, and this is the Desert Island Discs podcast. This is the only extract the BBC has of this episode, and for rights reasons, the music is shorter than on the original broadcast. The presenter is Roy Plumley. I hope you enjoy listening.
Presenter
Charles, what part of the country do you come from? I'm a Cottony.
Presenter
You come from a musical family?
Presenter
Not really. I think somewhere way back there was a famous singer.
Presenter
Ada Crossley in our family. But my mother was a nice singer of ballads. Yes, played the piano nicely, but uh not really musical.
Presenter
And you began your musical career as a conister.
Presenter
I did, yes, in St Paul's Cathedral. Mhm. Where did you progress from there? I went to school at Southern Valence in Kent, and then directly to the Royal College of Music. And you were a great concert goer as a boy. Enormous, yes. I I had my first season to get at the Proms as a present.
Presenter
And the first year, I was 12, I think. In the first season, I went to 41 out of the 42 concerts that year. I'd heard a lot of music. You certainly did.
Presenter
And at the Royal College, what savvies did you take?
Presenter
Well principally organ and piano. First of all organ as as principal study and piano as second study.
Presenter
Then after a time I changed round the other way round. Yes. Are those years that the the mid thirties were exciting years at the Royal College were they? They were wonderful because Sir Hugh Allen was a great director.
Presenter
It gives a great stimulus. He invited Sir Thomas Beacham to come two years running to conduct operas, Mance Hugh the Drover by Vaughan Williams.
Speaker 1
Once you
Presenter
And the Village Romeo and Juliet by Delius. These were great days. Were you mixed up with the opera class? I wasn't very much, no. I a lot of my friends were. It took me a rather long time to get from the ecclesiastical to the uh worldly. Yes. Your sights were set on what? Being an accompanist? Being an accompanist, yes, really.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Presenter
And what happened when you left college?
Presenter
Well, I applied for an audition to the BBC as an accomplist. I didn't get the job, but they gave me a lot of ad hoc work, and I got involved very much with the BBC.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
You worked with that legendary figure Toscanini.
Presenter
I did, yes, I played some of the rehearsals for his.
Presenter
Coral pieces
Presenter
in the London music festivals of thirty-six and thirty-seven here.
Presenter
Was he a difficult man?
Presenter
I think he was a difficult man in that he was very fiery.
Presenter
Uh
Presenter
Because he couldn't understand English, was apt to think that if anybody said anything
Presenter
They were being rude to him.
Presenter
How did he compare with Beecher?
Presenter
He used to call Beecham Arlachino or Pagliaccio. And Beecham used to refer to him either as poor old Toscanini or a military bandmaster. So I think they they were both.
Presenter
fire and brimstone people, but beecham had more charm.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
And then you moved on to the BBC stuff? I did, yes. I was chorus master for the BBC Theatre Chorus. In 1938, they formed the music productions unit, which was to do studio opera. And the first production, which was conducted by Stanford Robinson, was Manon by Massenet, with a supercast, Maggie Tate's Manon, Hedel Nash's Degrieur.
Presenter
Dennis Noble, Norman Allen.
Presenter
Roy Henderson. It was a fantastic card. It really was magnificent.
Presenter
And um
Presenter
I think I should like to remember that by hearing Hedel Nash sing the dream song.
Charles Groves
But one thing, one thing only still is one.
Charles Groves
Ah
Charles Groves
Yeah.
Charles Groves
Dream complete.
Charles Groves
To God we too shall live together if you come.
Presenter
Edelmer singing the dream song from Massenet's Mano.
Presenter
Now this was 1938. The war wasn't far off of course.
Presenter
And he went up to Evesham. He was sent there with 12 singers, I guess.
Speaker 1
That's right.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
We used to rehearse in an old pub called the Cider Mill, which was very nice. If you remember, the
Presenter
Autumn of 1939 was a golden Indian summer.
Charles Groves
Yeah.
Presenter
And the war hadn't really started.
Presenter
These wonderful countryside
Presenter
Rehearsing
Presenter
In the morning, going downstairs for a pint of cider in the break and something. It was quite extraordinary at the time, really.
Speaker 1
Done.
Presenter
And then you were put in charge of that rather oddly named orchestra, the Review Orchestra. Yes.
Presenter
This really had been the old BBC television orchestra. And I had it for a year. I did some quite interesting things. I remember conducting for Gertrude Lawrence's Lady in the Dark.
Presenter
by Brexton Court Vile is
Presenter
And
Presenter
We used to do little concerts and from that I was
Presenter
spotted, I suppose, as as being a possible conductor.
Presenter
In the future.
Presenter
Yes. And then you took over the BBC Northern Orchestra, that's right. Was that hard work? It was terrifically hard work because I suppose we did five broadcasts a week and I used to conduct them all in those days. We didn't have any guest conductors.
Presenter
and good for learning the repertoire. Indeed. I believe you met your wife at that time. Yes, she used to uh be in charge of the musical balance of some of our concerts. And I always was attracted to her.
Presenter
Because I thought she left the knobs alone, as I said. She used to leave the dynamics to me for it.
Presenter
You had an exchange visit to Australia at that time? Yes, in 1950.
Presenter
I spent four and a half months there and I enjoy it very much. How long did you stay with the corporation altogether? Thirteen years. Wasn't it arranged to leave?
Presenter
It was really, although
Presenter
It's been marvellous really because I've always worked for the BBC ever since in one way or another and I feel I have great links with the BBC.
Presenter
Let's have your third record now.
Presenter
Well, it really illustrates what I mean. It's it's part of Beethoven's Chorus Symphony.
Presenter
The last movement.
Presenter
Where the
Presenter
Bay's service comes in with his great restitive.
Presenter
and says let's not have any more of this
Presenter
Humming and haring, let's get on with the song of joy.
Presenter
Here it is.
Charles Groves
Sonden.
Presenter
An excerpt from Beethoven's choral symphony, the Viana Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Hans Schmidt Isserstead.
Presenter
When you left the corporation, you went to the Bournemouth Municipal Orchestra and thrived. At a time when it was faced with rather a serious financial crisis.
Presenter
Yes, it was not long after I went there that the corporation decided they couldn't afford
Presenter
the orchestra, although the rates of the musicians in those days were pitiably low.
Presenter
But um
Presenter
When we got the sack, we all got together and decided we couldn't let the orchestra finish, so we.
Presenter
Formed a new orchestra called the Bowman Symphony Orchestra.
Presenter
I'm pleased to say it's flourishing. Yes, and you had a great deal to do with putting it on its feet and sorting it out. You linked up with the Welsh National Opera Company. Yes.
Presenter
And this was a very fortunate thing for us at the time and it was also good for the Welsh National because it meant that they had a ready-made professional orchestra.
Presenter
For their office. Yes, you used to conduct beard for them. Yes.
Presenter
How many concerts a year did you do with the Bournemouth Orchestra? Well, when I first went there, I would think in...
Speaker 1
Uh
Presenter
Bournemouth alone.
Presenter
Mm-hmm.
Presenter
It's a lot, it's a lot, yeah. And you brought it to the proms for the first time? Yeah.
Presenter
How long were you with them?
Presenter
10 years and from there I became the first resident music director of the Welsh National Opera Company.
Presenter
Because Bill Smith, who was then head of the opera there, he decided that.
Presenter
If the worst national was going to mean anything, it's got to be a national company.
Presenter
And he had his eye on a possible professionalization of the company. And so he asked me to come in and help him do that.
Presenter
And then you move to the Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra. How are things in Liverpool? Oh, they're fine because we have our own beautiful hall.
Presenter
Where we rehearse and where we have our offices and that sort of thing. We're very fortunate indeed.
Presenter
You're also Associate Conductor of the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, and of course you have a few months in the year to to travel and and conduct overseas. You have a regular engagement with the Munich Philharmonic. Well I I have been there every season for the past four years and I'm going again at Christmas when I'm conducting the Ninth Symphony on New Year's Eve, which will be very nice. Lovely.
Presenter
Let's have your fifth record.
Presenter
Well, I should like to recall.
Presenter
Wales. I remember when I announced at the breakfast table that
Presenter
We were going to Liverpool. My two daughters, who were about 12 and 10 then, wept into their porridge because they loved living in South Wales so much. So I'd like to hear.
Presenter
Polly Garter song of Manda Milkwood.
Presenter
The music of which was written by a very old friend of mine, Dan Jones.
Speaker 2
The Reverend Eli Jenkins, busy on his morning calls, stops outside the welfare hall to hear Polly Garter as she scrubs the floors for the Mothers' Union dance tonight.
Charles Groves
I loved a man whose name was Tom, He was strong as a bear and two yards long. I loved a man whose name was Dick. He was big as a barrel and two feet thick. And I loved a man whose name was Harry, Six feet tall and sweet as a cherry, But the one I loved best, awake or asleep.
Charles Groves
Was little Willy Wee, And he six feet deep.
Presenter
Diana Maddox's Polygarter in Dylan Thomas's Under Milkwood, and also a few words by Richard Burton.
Presenter
Let's go straight on to your next record.
Presenter
Well
Presenter
I think Wagner is one of the greatest
Presenter
composers. And if I were on that island I'd like to have something to remind me of the grand sweep and scope of his music.
Presenter
And I think I would take the
Presenter
Spring song, which is sung by Siegmund in the first act of Die Vauquira.
Presenter
where the door in Hunding's hut is suddenly blown wide open and there's the spring moonlight outside and he sings this beautiful music.
Charles Groves
In test and they form our wounds, in ill delight at lands of Lin and Lu.
Charles Groves
Can you eye stupidly?
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Presenter
John Vickers singing Siegmunds
Presenter
Spring song from Wagner's De Valkura, which you conducted at Saddler's Wells last year. Yes, I did.
Speaker 1
Yeah, yeah.
Presenter
Yes, and and on tour incentive, which is very thrilling.
Presenter
How do you fancy yourself as a castaway in the practical sense? Do you think you would be good?
Presenter
I think in in time I would. I'm not
Presenter
particularly practical. I'm rather bad with my m with my hands. My fingers are all thumbs. And I have a
Presenter
Platform
Presenter
Being a lovely person, I've got to be a practical wife.
Presenter
Is good living important to you? Could you survive on basic reasons? Oh, yes, absolutely absolutely.
Speaker 1
Oh yes I have
Presenter
Quite easily live on
Presenter
Really basic thing.
Presenter
Would you try to escape? Do you know anything about Small Boat? No, nothing at all. Right. Let's have record number seven. Well, I've chosen this because it's by a not dead composer, Messiar.
Presenter
A piece which he wrote when he was a prisoner of war in Poland.
Presenter
And
Presenter
It shows what amazing tranquility can be achieved.
Charles Groves
Uh
Presenter
by a great composer, under difficult circumstances,
Presenter
It's the fifth movement of his quartet The End of Time.
Presenter
in which the cello and piano are heard alone.
Presenter
The opening of the fifth movement in praise of the eternity of Jesus from Messier's Quartet for the End of Time.
Presenter
Now we come to your last record. What's that to be?
Presenter
Well
Presenter
I
Presenter
have the most
Presenter
Carti.
Presenter
Admiration and loving memories of Sir Thomas Beacham. I'd like to take.
Presenter
Something that he'd recorded with me.
Presenter
After a lot of thought, I've chosen the very end of Strauss's tone poem, Einhildendeben, A Hero's Life.
Presenter
I remember.
Presenter
Beecham coming with the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra.
Presenter
Manchester, playing at Bellevue.
Presenter
And
Presenter
Seeing
Presenter
old Tommy, with the tears streaming down his face as he conducted this last couple of pages of this score.
Presenter
V8 two chairs and which would it be?
Presenter
I'd take the vagra, I think.
Presenter asks
Was it hard work when you took over the BBC Northern Orchestra?
It was terrifically hard work because I suppose we did five broadcasts a week and I used to conduct them all in those days. We didn't have any guest conductors.
Presenter asks
How do you fancy yourself as a castaway in the practical sense? Do you think you would be good?
I think in in time I would. I'm not particularly practical. I'm rather bad with my m with my hands. My fingers are all thumbs. And I have a platform being a lovely person, I've got to be a practical wife.
Presenter asks
Is good living important to you? Could you survive on basic reasons?
Oh, yes, absolutely absolutely. Quite easily live on really basic thing.
“I had my first season to get at the Proms as a present. And the first year, I was 12, I think. In the first season, I went to 41 out of the 42 concerts that year.”
“I think I should like to remember that by hearing Hedel Nash sing the dream song.”
“When we got the sack, we all got together and decided we couldn't let the orchestra finish, so we formed a new orchestra called the Bowman Symphony Orchestra.”
“I think Wagner is one of the greatest composers. And if I were on that island I'd like to have something to remind me of the grand sweep and scope of his music.”
“It shows what amazing tranquility can be achieved by a great composer, under difficult circumstances.”
“I remember old Tommy, with the tears streaming down his face as he conducted this last couple of pages of this score.”