Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
Composer, tenor, pianist, and accompanist to many great singers and instrumentalists worldwide.
Eight records
Piano Concerto No. 2 in C minor, Op. 18
GUEST: 'the Allegro Scherzando from the third movement'
GUEST: 'You were accompanist to Mischa Elman for a long time, weren’t you? Yes, for seven years.'
The keepsakes
The book
Not recorded.
The luxury
a tape recorder with a big supply of batteries
I would like to take a tape recorder with a big supply of batteries. I want to uh sing some melodies which I can record and compose music to them when I return if I can get safely off the island and also I want to listen to the birds' beautiful voices.
In conversation
Presenter asks
How did your career start? What decided you to become a musician?
I think because my parents were both very musical. And wanted all the boys and girls to learn music.
Presenter asks
You accompanied Caruso very often. Was he a pleasant man to work with?
[I] enjoyed working with him immensely. At the Knickerbocker Hotel, I went and sang some of my songs to him … and he was very, very pleased with an Ave Maria which I had set to music. And he said, 'Oh, I'll make a record of that if you can write an obbligato for Mischa [Elman] and we'll record it next week.'
Presenter asks
How are you going to look after yourself on this island?
Well, first of all, I should be very lonely and I think I could manage that all right. … I once gave Sandow, the strong man, some singing lessons and he in return taught me some of his famous exercises and I think I should be able to climb a tree and get some coconuts. I'm still very agile at seventy-seven.
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Percy Kahn
Hello, I'm Kirsty Young, and this is a download from the Desert Island Discs archive.
Percy Kahn
For rights reasons, we've had to shorten the music. The programme was originally broadcast in 1958.
Percy Kahn
This is a recording as it was being broadcast rather than the studio recording, and for that reason you may hear some interference and some degradation in the sound quality.
Speaker 2
Desert island disc.
Presenter
Each week, a well-known person is asked the question.
Presenter
If you were to be cast away alone on a desert island, which eight gramophone records would you choose to have with you, assuming of course that you also had a gramophone?
Presenter
As usual, the week's castaway is introduced by Roy Plumley. How do you do, ladies and gentlemen?
Presenter
There can be few men with a richer store of musical memories than our castaway this week.
Presenter
Composer, tenor, pianist, and accompanist to many great singers and instrumentalists all over the world, here is Percy Carr.
Presenter
Welcome ashore, mister Cant.
Presenter
Have you kept many souvenirs of your career in the form of gramophone records? That were a big collection? Oh yes, I have many. As a matter of fact, I've made hundreds, many in New York. Yeah. With Nisha Elman and other artists, and also a great number here.
Presenter
Well how do you feel about the prospect of of leaving that collection and and going off alone to this desert island?
Percy Kahn
And how do you
Presenter
Well, I hate it.
Presenter
I hate loneliness. I like the cheerful company and I'm afraid it's going to be very difficult. Well, we'll hope it's just a short exile. You waved goodbye to your family and you're off to this desert island with just eight records tucked under your arm. What's the first one? The first one I've chosen is the Rachmaninoff Concerto number two in C minor, which is played by the composer, who I consider one of the greatest pianists in the world. Yes. And also Stokovsky, the conductor.
Presenter
I studied with him at the Royal College of Music when he was an organist there and I was an organ scholar. You knew Rat Maninoff too, didn't you? Yes, he came to the Knickerbocker Hotel in New York when I was rehearsing with Misha Elman several times accompanied by Pavlova and sat and listened to our practicing. Very distinguished audience.
Percy Kahn
You knew
Presenter
It was certainly. Well, I'm afraid you can't take the whole of this concerto. Which part would you like? Oh, I'd like to hear the Allegro Scherzando from the third movement. That comes right at the end of the movie. Right at the end, yes.
Percy Kahn
The water.
Presenter
The closing minutes of Rach Maninoff's second piano concerto played by the composer. What's your second choice, Mr. Carr? Well, I would very much like to hear Tetritzini singing the bell song from Lachme. You played for her very often, didn't you? Very often. She was a great coloratura singer.
Presenter
And I feel I must tell you this story, which happened at the Albert Hall in 1920.
Presenter
Um when she sang this aria.
Presenter
She has to trill on the top.
Presenter
B at the end
Presenter
And
Presenter
Mount to the top E in out.
Presenter
Well, she'd been away some time uh abroad.
Presenter
And when she returned, she was received with such wonderful enthusiasm, and she was so overcome by this reception,
Presenter
That
Presenter
She trilled on the stop B.
Presenter
And not a sound came out for the last top E. So I walked off the platform.
Presenter
and practically off the platform when she ran after me.
Presenter
and brought me back promptly on the piano stool,
Presenter
And asked me for the cord. I gave her the cord and she
Presenter
Trilled on this top E magnificently. She had a most marvellous trill, as you will hear, and sang the top E with the most wonderful sound.
Presenter
And the audience went wild.
Presenter
Well let's hear the record.
Presenter
The Voice of Luisa Tetruszini.
Presenter
Mr Cohen, how did your career start? What decided you to become a musician?
Presenter
I think because my parents were both very musical.
Presenter
And wanted all the boys and girls to learn music. How many of you were there?
Presenter
There were five of us all together. And how many became musicians? Three of us. That's a very good average.
Presenter
How old were you when you started learning music? I was seven.
Percy Kahn
I'm a
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
What did you learn the piano? Yes, I learnt the piano. And uh a Reverend Charles Everett heard me sing and play and was so impressed that he uh
Presenter
It took me to the Royal College.
Presenter
About music?
Presenter
and uh where I sang and played for Sir George Grove and Doctor Parrott. They were both very much impressed and uh Sir George found me a teacher.
Presenter
For the piano.
Presenter
And uh Doctor Parrott wanted me to sing in his choir at Windsor.
Speaker 2
Peter?
Presenter
No, my tutor
Presenter
Charles Everett. I was singing his choir and uh I couldn't
Presenter
Except at Sir Walter's offer. You couldn't let him down. I couldn't let him down. No.
Percy Kahn
No.
Presenter
So yeah.
Presenter
I had this new teacher and I made great progress.
Presenter
And in the meantime, Mr. Arthur Pepin took over the teaching of me.
Presenter
Uh the piano and he taught me the organ.
Speaker 3
Uh
Presenter
Uh
Presenter
And uh eventually
Presenter
I won at a free open scholarship at the Royal College of Music for organ and studied with Sir Walter Parrott. You were at the Royal College for what, four years? For four years. In the meantime I was running up and down the country singing, you see, soprano. I had a wonderful voice, they say.
Percy Kahn
Yeah, what the hell?
Speaker 2
Yeah.
Presenter
And I sang at the pantomime in Liverpool Shakespeare Theatre and also at the Palace Theatre in London Shaftesbury Avenue for which I got £20 a week, both for the pantomime and the Palace Theatre. It was a lot of money in those days. Yes, it was. And when you had finished your years at the Royal College, what happened to you then? Sir Walter wanted me to go to Sydney Cathedral as organist.
Percy Kahn
And when
Presenter
But I didn't want to bury myself there as an organist. I wanted to see the world.
Percy Kahn
Yeah.
Presenter
And so I started accompanying. Yes. Well, having got you started in the the main part of your career as an accompanist, I think we might break off and have the third record. What's that going to be?
Presenter
The third record is going to be Le Faba Day.
Presenter
By Misha Elbatten, played by Misha Ellman and myself. Yes, you were in companies to Mischa Ellman for a long time, weren't you? Yes, for seven years.
Presenter
Well let's hear you're both together playing Les Fafa de.
Speaker 2
Uh
Speaker 3
Uh
Speaker 3
Um
Presenter
Misha Ellman playing Les Fafa Day with you accompanying him. Mr. Carne, let's hear about some more of the famous artists that you've accompanied in the past. Well, I have accompanied Caruso very often and he was the greatest of all tenors, greatest of all singers.
Presenter
Is he uh a pleasant man to work with?
Percy Kahn
Has he uh
Presenter
Pleasant Veddy
Presenter
I I enjoyed working with him immensely. At the Knickerbocker Hotel, I went and sang some of my songs to him, some of my compositions, and uh he was very, very pleased with an arv maria which I had uh uh set.
Presenter
Uh to music.
Speaker 3
Uh
Presenter
And he said, Oh, I'll make a record of that if you can write an obligato for Misha and we'll record it next week. So we did.
Presenter
We met in a special room rigged up for him in Thirty Second Street and uh
Presenter
We began the recording.
Presenter
Caruso wasn't pleased with his singing.
Presenter
Michelle
Presenter
Wasn't pleased with his uh uh playing the second time, you see, we had to repeat it.
Percy Kahn
Yeah.
Presenter
The third time
Presenter
Well none of us were very pleased.
Presenter
So we had to repeat it a fourth time.
Presenter
And it was so wonderful.
Presenter
and so beautifully done that I jumped from my my piano stool, clapped my hands together wildly and said, That was perfectly splendid.
Presenter
And so I spoilt the record. The recording had still gone on, naturally, in those days, you see.
Presenter
Caruso took it all in good part and laughed heartily and went over to a screen there, knocked his head against the screen and regardless of fatigue, of course we had to do it a fifth time.
Presenter
And this is the one you're going to hear now, the Arvina Rio record, with Mishaoma playing the violin obligato and myself at the piano.
Speaker 3
Somebody
Presenter
Well that's a record that's been taken to this desert island before.
Presenter
What are we going to hear now, mister Carne?
Presenter
Well, I would like you to put on Paras's aria.
Presenter
From Solojincy's Fair by Mrs. Gay
Percy Kahn
Zog
Presenter
Sung by Odas Lobot Skya. Yes, why'd you choose this?
Presenter
Well, I choose it because
Presenter
I was the first to play for her when she came from America, when she sang under the name of Ode Carreno.
Presenter
She sank first in England at the Hippodrome Brighton.
Presenter
and then at the Palladium.
Speaker 3
Uh
Presenter
and I was her accompanist there.
Presenter
And uh Lionel Powell, the impresario, heard her sing.
Presenter
and was so delighted that he gave her an international celebrity concert.
Presenter
when she assumed her own name Odyslavodskaya.
Presenter
I toured with her naturally.
Presenter
Many times.
Presenter
And
Presenter
I think this record is a very wonderful one.
Presenter
I think I should enjoy hearing her sing it.
Presenter
because uh it's so cheerful at the end that I almost got up and danced when uh she sang it.
Speaker 3
So much keep me with me.
Speaker 3
Oh, make sure to take a look at me!
Speaker 3
Why did you find it more?
Presenter
Yes, that's a very gay song.
Presenter
So now we've come to disc number six.
Presenter
Disc number six, I would like you to put on Neumannwagen by this.
Presenter
Played by Simon Barrea.
Presenter
who I consider possess the greatest technique, piano technique, in the world.
Presenter
He assisted on one of uh Richard Tauber's
Presenter
Tours with me.
Presenter
And he played this piece. It was so marvellous.
Presenter
And
Presenter
When on tour with Tetratsini on her farewell tour,
Presenter
In thirty-three
Presenter
Um Piati Gorski, the famous cellist who was assisting at this concert, told me that Hodovitz had told him
Presenter
That uh
Presenter
Barair could do more with four fingers than he himself could do with his ten.
Presenter
That's a very fine recommendation. Let's listen now to Siemen Barra.
Presenter
Playing Norman Reagan.
Presenter
That's certainly a dazzling performance.
Presenter
Now there's a very important question that always crops up in this program, Mr. Khan. How are you going to look after yourself on this island?
Presenter
Well, first of all, I should be very lonely and uh I think I could manage that all right.
Presenter
I once gave Sandow, the strong man, some singing lessons and he in return taught me some of his famous exercises and I think I should be able to climb a tree and get some coconuts.
Presenter
I'm still very agile at seventy-seven. Splendid. Um are you a fisherman? You live by the sea. Do you ever go fishing? No. Uh the only time I fished was uh on Picted Sound.
Presenter
with uh the mayor
Presenter
Uh on his launch.
Presenter
And the first time I had a wonderful catch. Well, let's have that your fisherman's luck continues. Well, you've got some coconuts and some fish. Could you cook them?
Presenter
Yes, I could. My wife says I'm quite a good cook. I can c scramble an egg and I should be able to make a fire with a f a flint or something. Yes, oh you're going to be all right. Let let's get back to music. Let's get to record number seven. Well number seven is I strage me miner.
Presenter
I keep
Presenter
You in my heart.
Presenter
By Richard Strauss.
Presenter
Sung by Richard Tauba. Yes. You were Richard Tauba's accompanist and coach right up to the time of his death, weren't you? Yes, I spent 15 thrilling and happy years with him.
Presenter
and during that time travelled the five continents of the world.
Presenter
He was a great uh artist, a great singer.
Presenter
great musician and a great conductor.
Presenter
And you could have made a living at any of those callings.
Presenter
His father was the director of the Chemnitz Opera House, so he was brought up on music as it were.
Presenter
Well as the souvenir of that fifteen years, let's listen to you both in this recording of the song.
Speaker 3
Yeah.
Speaker 3
Roger mine ameen of all of whom in my house are no deems in the meeting.
Percy Kahn
I mean the horn of all
Percy Kahn
De Maharno deems in only
Speaker 3
Uh oh
Speaker 3
Lost glory to me, God
Speaker 3
Oh yeah.
Speaker 3
Shimirdashi do
Presenter
And after that record by Richard Tauber, we come to your last one.
Presenter
Number eight. What's that?
Presenter
Well, I would love to hear the nightingale and the rose.
Percy Kahn
Uh Uh
Presenter
By Muzovsky, sung by Rosa Poncell.
Presenter
She was uh a wonderful artist, a wonderful singer, and she sang with Caruso in the last opera he ever appeared in at the Metropolitan La Jouève.
Presenter
But this song is simply wonderful. The tone is so beautiful and so perfect. She's such a great artist. By the way, it's my wife's favorite record.
Presenter
You've certainly chosen some lovely records to take with you on this island, Mr. Cant. You've still got one more choice to make. Every castaway has one luxury. What are you going to take with you?
Presenter
Well, it's very difficult to say.
Presenter
Because I should be very, very lonely there.
Percy Kahn
Lonely
Presenter
And I think I would like to take a tape recorder with a big supply of batteries. And what you're going to put on it.
Percy Kahn
With a big
Presenter
I want to
Presenter
Uh sing some melodies.
Presenter
which I can record.
Presenter
and compose music to them when I return if if I can get safely off the island and also I want to listen to the birds' beautiful voices.
Presenter
So we can look forward to some more songs that you've composed when you get back from the island.
Presenter
That would be a pleasure. Well, thank you so much, Percy Count, for letting us hear your choice of Desert Island Disc. Not at all. I enjoyed it.
Percy Kahn
Well, thank you so much.
Presenter
Our little talk together. Goodbye, everyone.
Speaker 2
The guest in today's recorded programme was Percy Kahn, the interviewer Roy Plumley, and the producer Monica Chapman.
Percy Kahn
You've been listening to a download from the Desert Island Discs archive.
Percy Kahn
For more downloads, please visit the Radio4 website.
Presenter asks
You were Richard Tauber's accompanist and coach right up to the time of his death, weren't you?
Yes, I spent 15 thrilling and happy years with him, and during that time travelled the five continents of the world. He was a great artist, a great singer, great musician and a great conductor.
Presenter asks
What are you going to take with you as a luxury?
Well, it's very difficult to say. Because I should be very, very lonely there. And I think I would like to take a tape recorder with a big supply of batteries. … I want to sing some melodies which I can record, and compose music to them when I return if I can get safely off the island and also I want to listen to the birds' beautiful voices.
“I hate loneliness. I like the cheerful company and I'm afraid it's going to be very difficult.”
“He [Rachmaninoff] came to the Knickerbocker Hotel in New York when I was rehearsing with Misha Elman several times accompanied by Pavlova and sat and listened to our practicing. Very distinguished audience.”
“She [Tetrazzini] trilled on the stop B. And not a sound came out for the last top E. So I walked off the platform … and practically off the platform when she ran after me and brought me back promptly on the piano stool, And asked me for the cord. I gave her the cord and she trilled on this top E magnificently.”
“I jumped from my piano stool, clapped my hands together wildly and said, 'That was perfectly splendid.' And so I spoilt the record. … Caruso took it all in good part and laughed heartily … regardless of fatigue, of course we had to do it a fifth time.”
“Piatigorski, the famous cellist … told me that Horowitz had told him that Barere could do more with four fingers than he himself could do with his ten.”