Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Lauren Laverne
A political philosopher and Harvard professor whose course on justice became one of the most popular in the university's history, watched by tens of millions wo
Eight records
And this was nineteen sixty three. Medgar Evers, a civil rights leader, had been murdered by a white supremacist. And Dylan writes and sings this amazing song that explores the complex relation between injustices of race and of class.
I always found it inspiring. But I began to be a bit more critical. About the American triumphalist belief that God is on our side.
Her voice is a voice of aching beauty. A dissonant song. Dissonance hardly describes the aching pain, but also the beauty of it.
I saw this musical in Broadway shortly after it came out. I was blown away by it, but then during the pandemic, they showed a version of it on television. This was shortly after I had written The Tyranny of Merit and what struck me listening to it just recently is that Alexander Hamilton is a celebration of the meritocracy that I criticize in The Tyranny of Merit.
It's a song of darkness but with hope, and it's also a song against the striving for perfection. He tells us there is a crack in everything. That's how the light gets in.
The Stars Will Sing to YouFavourite
A song that my wife Kiku Adato composed when our children were very young. It's a lullaby called The Stars Will Sing to You. It's a cosmic lullaby.
What's interesting about the song, and the reason I want to bring Ray Charles along, singing it. Is this line God shed His grace on thee? is sometimes read as a hope and a prayer, May we be worthy of grace. but is sometimes read as a fact God has already declared us worthy. That's a reading that I resist. that I disagree with because I think it leads to a kind of divine triumphalism. And yet Ray Charles, in his riff on the words, takes that second meaning, and it's certainly magnificent as he sings it with aching sorrow and redemptive joy.
The keepsakes
The book
The Collected Dialogues of Plato
Plato
They depend on an interlocutor, but I could sit on the desert island and read them and imagine my interlocutors, so that would enable me to subsist at least for a while.
The luxury
There is something that kind of relieves the insularity of the lockdown … to be able to keep track of the birds in the garden … I'd like to do the same on the island if I could and have a good pair of binoculars.
In conversation
Presenter asks
How do you manage the discomfort that philosophy brings?
Well, it's true. Philosophy estranges us from the familiar. It leads us to question familiar assumptions, the way we live. But it's a journey in a way. So whether it's in our public life or in our personal everyday lives, there's always new grist for philosophy, new occasion for trying to think through the assumptions by which we hope to live.
Presenter asks
Are you surprised by the level of fame that your work has brought you?
When we put the Justice Course online, we never dreamt I certainly didn't, that tens of millions of people would want to watch lectures about philosophy. A colleague of mine came back from Beijing and reported that he'd been riding in a taxi and the taxi driver in Beijing said, where are you from? And he said, Massachusetts. He didn't even say Harvard. And he said, you know, I've been taking a course about justice from Harvard and my wife and children have been watching too. And that's one of the greatest satisfactions, greatest rewards that this whole project, I think, brought me.
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Presenter
BBC Sounds, Music, Radio Podcasts. Hello, I'm Lauren Laverne, and this is the Desert Island Discs Podcast. Every week, I ask my guests to choose the eight tracks, book, and luxury they'd want to take with them if they were cast away to a desert island. And, for rights reasons, the music is shorter than the original broadcast. I hope you enjoy listening.
Presenter
My castaway this week is the political philosopher Michael Sandel. He's professor of government theory at Harvard University and a self-confessed political junkie who initially dreamed of being a journalist until, while covering the Watergate scandal as a young reporter, fate intervened and put him on a different course. He didn't leave politics behind though, far from it. It has been his life's work to ask questions about what makes a good life and a good society. His vision of an alternative politics, what he calls civic republicanism, has been credited with injecting philosophical debate with the adrenaline of the real world. He's been described as a philosopher with the global profile of a rock star and has taken his work to venues around the world including St Paul's Cathedral and Sydney Opera House and he's grappled with some of the biggest questions of our time from bioethics to assisted dying. His course on justice became one of the most popular in Harvard's history with thousands of students applying to attend classes in person and tens of millions watching online worldwide.
Presenter
And you might have heard him here on Radio 4 in his series The Public Philosopher and The Global Philosopher taking on questions such as should a banker be paid more than a nurse and more recently considering the ethics of mass vaccination. But it's not all adoring audiences and calm contemplation. He says philosophy can be debilitating. It demands a critical sensibility and to apply that to everything can be a disquieting thing. The disquiet is necessary, even if you're unmoored by it. Michael Sandell, welcome to Desert Island Discs.
Michael Sandel
It's a pleasure to be with you, Lauren.
Presenter
So, you have to get comfortable with discomfort in your line of work then, this disquiet. How do you manage it?
Michael Sandel
Well, it's true. Philosophy estranges us from the familiar. It leads us to question familiar assumptions, the way we live. But it's a journey in a way. So whether it's in our public life or in our personal everyday lives, there's always new grist for philosophy, new occasion for trying to think through the assumptions by which we hope to live.
Presenter
And are there ever moments where you have to put that critical sensibility on pause and change your mindset? I don't know. I know you're a baseball fan. I'm wondering if you in those moments you kind of say, okay, well, they're just my team because they're my team.
Michael Sandel
Ah, no, no. I don't think that the critical sensibility is ever put on hold. And I say this, taking up your analogy of baseball, which I love.
Michael Sandel
One loves the home team, but is unceasingly critical.
Michael Sandel
the move the manager made, or whether this hitter swung at a bad pitch. So the critical element goes along with the loyalty and the sense of belonging.
Speaker 2
La hair demo
Presenter
Michael, you'd be familiar with that description I used of you as a philosopher with the global profile of a rock star. Are you surprised by the level of fame that your work has brought you?
Michael Sandel
When we put the Justice Course online, we never dreamt I certainly didn't, that tens of millions of people would want to watch lectures about philosophy.
Michael Sandel
A colleague of mine came back from
Michael Sandel
Beijing and reported that he'd been riding in a taxi and the taxi driver in Beijing said, where are you from? And he said, Massachusetts. He didn't even say Harvard. And he said, you know, I've been taking a course about justice from Harvard and my wife and children have been watching too. And that's one of the greatest satisfactions, greatest rewards that this whole project, I think, brought me.
Presenter
It's time to hear your first disc then, Michael Sandell. What's it gonna be?
Michael Sandel
It's Feeling Good by Nina Simone.
Michael Sandel
This is such a powerful song about freedom.
Michael Sandel
And you can hear it in her voice.
Michael Sandel
It's freedom against the background of suffering, of oppression. It's almost cosmic.
Michael Sandel
Biblical even.
Speaker 2
The Shemisi, you know how I feel.
Speaker 2
River running free, you know how I feel.
Speaker 2
Blossom on the tree, you know how
Speaker 2
A new dawn, it's a new day, it's a new light.
Speaker 2
For me and I'm feeling good.
Presenter
Feeling good, Nina Simone. Michael Sandell, you once said choice flows from how I interpret my identity, and part of my identity is that I'm the son of my parents. So your father, Herbert, was a record distributor. What was he like?
Michael Sandel
He was reserved like traditional fathers of those years. He he would spend most of the day in the office.
Presenter
Does that mean it was hard to get close to him? You weren't you weren't too close?
Michael Sandel
I think that that's probably fair enough. You know, we spent times on weekends and so on. But my mother played much the greater role in raising the children. I was one of four, the oldest of four. She was a French and Spanish teacher, and by high school I was taking quite a demanding French class where we had to read Balzac's Le Perigoriot in French chapter by chapter each evening, which I found desperately difficult. And she sat, I'm afraid, and drilled me, got me through it, but I haven't turned back to Perigorio since. It was quite a traumatic experience.
Presenter
You mentioned that you're the eldest of four, so what about the family dynamics there? Were you in charge as the eldest?
Presenter
Mm-hmm.
Michael Sandel
Not really. I wasn't in charge, except I do remember when I was in elementary school, second, third grade, I would ask the teacher if I could have an extra supply of the worksheets that we were assigned.
Presenter
What's the
Michael Sandel
And I took them home.
Michael Sandel
and ran a kind of play school at home. The main attendee was my sister, my younger sister, who was next in age. And the result was that she knew my sister knew how to read by the time she reached kindergarten, so they put her ahead.
Michael Sandel
to the first grade. They skipped kindergarten. But she rebelled. She rebelled and once dashed out of the room and said, If you think I'm going to spend the rest of my weekends in school with you, you're mighty mistaken.
Presenter
So your first student was not not very easy to control. That probably stood you in good stead, Michael.
Michael Sandel
She has a point.
Michael Sandel
Right, I think I've lightened my touch since then.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
It's time to hear your second disc, Michael Santel. What is it and why have you chosen it?
Michael Sandel
Bob Dylan, only a pawn in their game. And this was nineteen sixty three. Medgar Evers, a civil rights leader, had been murdered by a white supremacist. And Dylan writes and sings.
Michael Sandel
This amazing song
Michael Sandel
that explores the complex relation between injustices of race and of class. And it was a biting critique.
Michael Sandel
Bitter but potent critique of institutional racism.
Speaker 2
Oh, better than them, you've been born with what scan they explain.
Speaker 2
And the negro's name
Speaker 2
Is used, it is plain, For the politician's gain As he rises to fame And the poor white remains On the caboose of the train But it ain't him to blame He's only a pawn
Presenter
Leah.
Presenter
Or nearly. Our game
Presenter
Only a Pawn in Their Game by Duluth's own Bob Dylan. So Michael Sandell, you grew up in Hopkins, a suburb of Minneapolis, and you've written a lot about civic responsibility and the value of community. How did that play out in your neighborhood when you were growing up?
Michael Sandel
Uh
Michael Sandel
There was not such a sharp
Michael Sandel
Separation between those who were more affluent and those who were less so. Everyone encountered neighbors shopping in the same places, the same downtown areas. There was also a confidence that politics could make things better. There was perhaps a naive faith and confidence in the possibilities of civic life that seem very, very distant today.
Presenter
So there's a big change that that happened in your life when you were thirteen. The family moved from Hopkins, Minneapolis, to Los Angeles following your father's job. That must have been a huge adjustment for you.
Michael Sandel
It was a huge change, but I didn't really find the adjustment difficult.
Michael Sandel
I loved the weather. It was possible to play baseball outside year round. It was right by the Pacific Ocean. It was possible to see the ocean.
Michael Sandel
From the high school quad, which tempted more than a few of my classmates to cut class and go surfing.
Michael Sandel
I was not a surfer, but over time I began to be struck by the individualism of Southern California.
Presenter
Okay, so you like the climate, but the culture
Presenter
That was a complex change.
Michael Sandel
Coach J.
Michael Sandel
Yeah, that was more complex.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Yeah, so you describe catching a glimpse of what you call the unencumbered self. Tell me more about that. What is it?
Michael Sandel
This is the image of the perfectly self-sufficient individual, independent of all moral ties, all community ties. And I saw that this was destructive and corrosive of family life, of a sense of community. So this struck me about Southern California. I hadn't quite theorized it in these fancy terms back then as a high school kid, but I think it made an impression on me.
Presenter
Time for some more music, Michael. What have you chosen, and why is it coming with you to the island to day?
Michael Sandel
The Battle Hymn of the Republic. I always found it inspiring.
Michael Sandel
But I began to be a bit more critical.
Michael Sandel
About the American triumphalist belief that God is on our side. And I began to hear in politics, in political rhetoric, this line: America is great because America is good. And I worry about this because I think it leads to a kind of self-certitude that can lead us to suspend critical judgment about, well, marching off to war, believing that as we march off, His truth is marching with us. See what you think.
Speaker 2
Mine eyes have seen the glory of the coming of the Lord. He is trampling out the vintage where the grapes of wrath are stored. He hath loosed the fateful lightning of his terrible swift sword. His truth is marching on.
Speaker 2
Glory, glory, hallelujah.
Speaker 2
Glory, glory, hallelujah.
Presenter
Odetta and the battle hymn of the Republic. Take me back to the beginning of your fascination with politics, Michael, because it is life long. I think you were just seven or eight when you first became interested. How did it happen?
Michael Sandel
I don't know how it happened, actually. The earliest memory I have, the earliest political memory, is of the election of John F. Kennedy.
Michael Sandel
Then I have the searing memory of hearing this, I was 10 years old when he was assassinated.
Michael Sandel
And this was just a shock. It was the first time that the world at large suddenly intruded into the consciousness of, you know, a 10-year-old growing up outside Minneapolis. And there were three networks in those days. This is before 24-hour cable. And I would try if I could to watch each of the three nightly newscasts. I was fascinated by politics.
Presenter
Years later, in nineteen seventy one, you were elected President of the student body at your high school in LA and you invited Ronald Reagan, who was then the governor of California, to take part in a school debate. It must have been quite a coup to persuade him. How did you manage it?
Michael Sandel
I sent an invitation to his office at the state capitol and got no reply. But then my mother read in a magazine article that he loved jelly beans and had them always to hand on his desk. So I went out and bought six pounds of jelly beans, put them in a box with a bow.
Michael Sandel
Wrote out the invitation and delivered it to his house, which was not far from the school. There were state troopers guarding the house. State troopers with German shepherd dogs. I'm afraid of dogs generally, much less German shepherd dogs in a guard house. They wanted to know what was in this box, and I said jelly beans.
Michael Sandel
They took it and looked rather skeptically at it and they felt their way through the jelly beans and decided it was innocent enough and let me deliver it to the front door. And a few days later he called the school and said he'd come.
Michael Sandel
And I was on the debating team at the time, and I thought I was a pretty good debater, and I thought I could make quick work of Ronald Reagan. He held all the views that we rejected. He was for the Vietnam War, we were against it. He was against giving 18-year-olds the right to vote, which was an issue of debate at the time.
Michael Sandel
I thought it would be relatively easy to defeat him in a debate, so I prepared, I sat up on the stage with him, point by point challenged him, and
Michael Sandel
I didn't really lay a glove on him. It was an object lesson in how a politician can, by listening and engaging, actually charm an audience that entirely disagrees with him.
Presenter
It's time for some more music, Michael Sundell. What are we going to hear next, and why?
Michael Sandel
It's Strange Fruit by Billy Holliday.
Michael Sandel
Her voice is a voice of aching beauty.
Michael Sandel
A dissonant song. Dissonance hardly describes the aching pain, but also the beauty of it.
Speaker 2
Southern Tree.
Speaker 2
Very strange rule.
Speaker 2
Blood on the leaves.
Speaker 2
And blood at the room.
Speaker 2
Black bird is swinging.
Speaker 2
In the silent breeze
Speaker 2
Strange fruit hanging from the poplar tree
Presenter
Billy Holiday and Strange Fruit.
Presenter
Michael Sandell, you majored in political science at university, and then in nineteen seventy four you landed a journalism internship at the Houston Chronicle's Washington Bureau. You described it as a dream come true. Was that in terms of the job itself, or in terms of the timing?
Michael Sandel
It was both. This was the summer.
Michael Sandel
When Congress was holding hearings on the impeachment of Richard Nixon for the Watergate scandal.
Michael Sandel
The bureau chief, my boss, recognized my love of politics and he allowed me to go and cover the hearings for the paper. So it was a summer where I lived and slept and dreamt about Watergate.
Speaker 2
Wow.
Michael Sandel
And about the new evidence coming out and the hearings being held, and chance to write about it was a dream come true.
Speaker 2
And a
Presenter
By the end of that summer Richard Nixon had resigned and knew Michael were back at college. Covering a story like that, you must have been tempted to follow a career in journalism.
Michael Sandel
I was tempted. In fact, just before I went back to college for my senior year, I was sitting with my boss, the bureau chief, who was musing. He was a man in his early fifties. He said, Maybe I should retire now. The story will never be this good again.
Michael Sandel
It's not the reason that I didn't wind up going into journalism, but it did stick with me that it would be hard to top that experience. The real reason I didn't is that I was seduced by philosophy when I began studying it as a graduate student.
Presenter
Yes, you got a Rhodes Scholarship to Oxford University with a view to reading PPE Politics, Philosophy, and Economics, but after taking philosophy for a term you changed track.
Michael Sandel
I was persuaded by a philosophy tutor, Alan Montefiore, that really I needed to spend a second term studying philosophy and to study the philosophy of Immanuel Kant. I said, Well, I find philosophy all rather abstract. What I'm interested in are questions of equality and inequality, questions of liberalism and democratic theory. He said, You must study Kant's critique of pure reason. So I went to the bookstore and I took it down from the shelf.
Michael Sandel
And I couldn't make any sense of it. But there was a six-week reading VAC coming up after the first term.
Michael Sandel
So I packed a handful of books, Kant's Critique of Pure Reason, John Rawls's book, A Theory of Justice, and sat in the south of Spain
Michael Sandel
and read them. And then soon I put economics aside.
Michael Sandel
and was, well, was drawn in by philosophy and was persuaded.
Michael Sandel
that in order to think clearly and deeply about contemporary questions of inequality and democracy, it's necessary to look for the deep philosophical background of these questions.
Presenter
It's time for some more music. Your fifth disc today, Michael Sandell. What have you chosen and why?
Michael Sandel
It's Alexander Hamilton from the musical Hamilton.
Michael Sandel
I saw this musical in Broadway shortly after it came out.
Michael Sandel
I was blown away by it, but then during the pandemic, they showed a version of it on television.
Michael Sandel
This was shortly after I had written The Tyranny of Merit and what struck me listening to it just recently.
Michael Sandel
is that Alexander Hamilton is a celebration of the meritocracy that I criticize in The Tyranny of Merit.
Michael Sandel
It portrays Alexander Hamilton not as the founder of financialization, but as an immigrant meritocrat, being a lot smarter, being a self starter. In New York you can be a new man.
Michael Sandel
And I came to hear this song, this celebration, with a more critical eye than when I first heard it.
Speaker 2
How does a bastard, orphan, son of a whore and a Scotsman, Dropped in the middle of a forgotten spot in the Caribbean by providence impoverished and squalor, grow up to be a hero and a scholar? The ten dollar, founded father without a father, got a lot farther by working a lot harder, by being a lot smarter, by being a self-starter by 14.
Speaker 2
They placed him in charge of a trading charter and the
Presenter
Alexander Hamilton from the musical Hamilton composed by Lynn Manuel Miranda and performed by the original Broadway cast.
Presenter
Michael Sandel, we'll come to the meritocracy in a moment. If you wouldn't mind first, let's talk about justice. After four years at Oxford, you returned to the States and started teaching a course called Justice at Harvard University. You designed it yourself. What were your ambitions in terms of its content?
Michael Sandel
When I had my first brush with political philosophy as a student, I found it remote, abstract, dull.
Michael Sandel
And what drew me to philosophy?
Michael Sandel
was seen the connection between philosophical accounts of justice and rights and liberty and the good life,
Michael Sandel
And the debates we have every day. To take one recent example, there are fraught debates going on now about mask wearing. Does government have the right to mandate the wearing of masks? And does government have the right, for that matter, to mandate?
Michael Sandel
Getting a jab with the COVID vaccine.
Michael Sandel
Now the ideal scenario to play out that discussion is not to begin with like minded people people who say, well, of course everyone should be required to wear a mask. It all depends on gathering people, whether in a classroom or in a public forum.
Michael Sandel
Who disagree?
Michael Sandel
Not just for the friseon of having clashing views. The disagreement is a starting point.
Michael Sandel
To see whether the participants can respond to the arguments, to the competing principles that are at stake in the debate.
Michael Sandel
That's the excitement of it.
Presenter
As we mentioned, you are, Michael, not afraid to take on conceptual sacred cows. And one current example is this notion of meritocracy. So politicians from all over the spectrum embrace that idea, you know, the idea that our own efforts dictate our latest success and that we should concentrate on giving people opportunities to excel. Now on the surface, we're used to hearing that. It doesn't sound like there's too much wrong with it, but you believe that there is a toxic side to meritocracy.
Michael Sandel
The problem arises.
Michael Sandel
When, as we've seen in recent decades, those who land on top come to believe that their success is their own doing, and that they therefore deserve the full bounty that the market bestows upon the successful,
Michael Sandel
Because this way of thinking about success also leads the successful to believe that those who struggle, those who are left behind, have no one to blame but themselves.
Presenter
What does thinking about all this mean for you in terms of placing your own story, I wonder, Michael?
Michael Sandel
Those who have succeeded thanks to the meritocracy need to remember our indebtedness to those people and those conditions that made our success possible family, neighborhood, community, country, the times in which we live.
Presenter
Michael, it's time for your next piece of music, your sixth choice. What is it and why have you chosen it?
Michael Sandel
It's a Leonard Cohen song called Anthem. It's a song of darkness but with hope, and it's also a song against the striving for perfection. He tells us there is a crack in everything.
Michael Sandel
That's how the light gets in.
Speaker 2
Ring the bell.
Speaker 2
Let's tell.
Speaker 2
Tonight
Speaker 2
Forgive your perfect offering.
Speaker 2
There is a crack, a crack, in everything That's how the light gets in
Presenter
Anthem by Leonard Cohen. Michael Sandell, you're married to the scholar and writer Kiku Odato. How did the two of you meet?
Michael Sandel
We met when we were both young junior professors at Harvard, when we were asked to join a panel of junior faculty members to speak to the governing board, the board of overseers, about the condition of the junior faculty and how they were treated. I wanted to ask her out, but I was not brave enough. So I said, is there anyone, there were about four or five of us, who would like to go for coffee. She wasn't able to, so I was, but there was some classics professor who took me up on it. So there I was, and I had to try again. And after several tries, she agreed to go out with me.
Speaker 2
So
Presenter
You have dedicated all of your recent books to her, and I quote whose intellectual and spiritual sensibilities improved this book and me. Is she your first reader?
Michael Sandel
Yes, and not a bashful reader about telling me when something needs to be fixed.
Presenter
But I'm I'm assuming you can take that.
Michael Sandel
Just barely. I am still working on it.
Presenter
The two of you have uh two grown-up sons.
Presenter
You've written that parenting is a school for humility. Was that a painful conclusion to come to at times?
Michael Sandel
Not painful, but challenging. And the humility that parenting teaches, I think, springs from the fact that however much we might try to shape our children, help our children, they are who they are, and it's not thanks to our doing only. And cultivating that distinctiveness, which exceeds our efforts to shape and control and to mold, simply beholding them and loving them for who they are, that's where the humility comes in. That kind of humility, I think, is part of love.
Presenter
It's time for your next disc. It'll be your seventh. What have you chosen and why?
Michael Sandel
A song that my wife Kiku Adato composed when our children were very young. It's a lullaby called The Stars Will Sing to You. It's a cosmic lullaby.
Speaker 2
When the moon is on the rise, Sleep my child, now don't you cry Sleep, my child, I'm by your side The stars will sing to you
Speaker 2
All the cares of the day slowly will begin to fade.
Presenter
The Stars Will Sing to You, performed by Lynn Sena and composed by your wife Kiku Adato. Michael Sandel, you've written a lot about the way that economic theory shapes the world we live in. You talk about market values. In your opinion, they don't always make the world a better place. What metric would you use to measure the value of your own work as a teacher?
Michael Sandel
If I'm in a lecture hall and I hear people coughing or shuffling their papers or their feet, I know that I've lost them.
Michael Sandel
So my metrics, if you want to call them metrics, are looking at the eyes and listening to the sound of the classroom. And if there's coughing and shifting and shuffling of feet, I need to shift. I need to do better.
Michael Sandel
The other is, and it's the most gratifying report that any teacher ever gets, is when years later someone from the course writes or calls to say what an impact it made on their thinking over the course of their lives. It matters more than any quantitative teaching evaluation could possibly do.
Presenter
I'm about to cast you away to your desert island, of course. You'll be facing the challenge of uh pursuing philosophy alone, without an audience to talk to. What are you looking forward to about the island? Is there anything?
Michael Sandel
I'm a bit worried about this island because what I do and what I care about depends on being with people.
Michael Sandel
And even if you gave me
Michael Sandel
A Zoom account and laptop, which I know you won't do when I'm cast away. Certainly not.
Michael Sandel
It still wouldn't be the same.
Presenter
Well, before you go, you have of course got one final music choice to share with us today. What's it going to be and why?
Michael Sandel
The incomparable electrifying Ray Charles singing America the Beautiful. What's interesting about the song, and the reason I want to bring Ray Charles along, singing it.
Michael Sandel
Is this line God shed His grace on thee?
Michael Sandel
is sometimes read as a hope and a prayer, May we be worthy of grace.
Michael Sandel
but is sometimes read as a fact God has already declared us worthy. That's a reading that I resist.
Michael Sandel
that I disagree with because I think it leads to a kind of divine triumphalism. And yet Ray Charles, in his riff on the words, takes that second meaning, and it's certainly magnificent as he sings it with aching sorrow and redemptive joy.
Speaker 2
America sweet
Speaker 2
I'm married
Speaker 2
You know.
Speaker 2
God done shed his grace on thee.
Speaker 2
He made me crow that good.
Speaker 2
Yes, it is!
Speaker 2
Heavy brotherhood
Speaker 2
From C to
Speaker 2
Shine and Sea.
Presenter
America the Beautiful, performed by Ray Charles. So, Michael Sandell, it's time. I'm going to cast you away to the island. I'm giving you the Bible and the complete works of Shakespeare. You can take one other book. What will it be?
Michael Sandel
the collected dialogues of Plato. They depend on an interlocutor, but I could sit on the desert island and read them and imagine my interlocutors, so that would enable me to subsist at least for a while.
Presenter
You can also have a luxury item, Michael, to make life more enjoyable on the island, or perhaps for sensory stimulation. What would you like?
Michael Sandel
A good pair of binoculars to do birding on the island. I'm not sure what the bird population of the island is, but I have a pair of binoculars on my desk at home. And during the pandemic, I set up a couple of bird feeders out in the garden.
Michael Sandel
There is something that kind of relieves the insularity of the lockdown.
Michael Sandel
to be able to keep track of the birds in the garden and how they're behaving with one another. And I'd like to do the same on the island if I could and have a good pair of binoculars.
Presenter
Absolutely, we'll even give you a case to keep the sand away from the lenses.
Presenter
And finally, which one of the eight tracks that you've shared with us today would you rush to save from the waves if you had to?
Michael Sandel
I have to save The Stars Will Sing to You by Kiku Adado. This is my family's song. It's her creation that will be able to keep me in touch with Kiku and our two boys.
Presenter
Michael Sandell, thank you very much for letting us hear your Desert Island discs.
Michael Sandel
Thank you, Lauren. Thanks so much.
Presenter
I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Michael. We'll leave him in peace now, birdwatching on the island. We've cast many philosophers away, including John Gray, Mary Midgley, and Sir Isaiah Berlin. You can find their episodes in our Desert Island Discs programme archive and through BBC Sounds. Next time, my guest will be the former footballer Peter Schmeichel. I do hope you'll join us.
Speaker 3
Thanks for listening to the podcast.
Speaker 3
I'm here to tell you about Dead House.
Speaker 3
Dead House is a trilogy of immersive audio horror shorts by Darkfield and BBC Radio 4.
Speaker 3
Each of the three episodes, Bethlehem, Salem and Xanadu.
Speaker 3
takes a different look at the separation between mind and body.
Speaker 3
placing you in the center of disconcerting environments that feel unnervingly real.
Speaker 3
So
Speaker 3
If you like original horror.
Speaker 3
Put your headphones on.
Speaker 3
Close your eyes.
Speaker 3
And meet yourself.
Speaker 3
In the Dead House.
Speaker 3
Subscribe now on BBC Sounds.
Presenter asks
You describe catching a glimpse of what you call the unencumbered self. Tell me more about that. What is it?
This is the image of the perfectly self-sufficient individual, independent of all moral ties, all community ties. And I saw that this was destructive and corrosive of family life, of a sense of community. So this struck me about Southern California. I hadn't quite theorized it in these fancy terms back then as a high school kid, but I think it made an impression on me.
Presenter asks
You invited Ronald Reagan to a school debate. How did you manage to persuade him?
I sent an invitation to his office at the state capitol and got no reply. But then my mother read in a magazine article that he loved jelly beans and had them always to hand on his desk. So I went out and bought six pounds of jelly beans, put them in a box with a bow. Wrote out the invitation and delivered it to his house, which was not far from the school. There were state troopers guarding the house. State troopers with German shepherd dogs. I'm afraid of dogs generally, much less German shepherd dogs in a guard house. They wanted to know what was in this box, and I said jelly beans. They took it and looked rather skeptically at it and they felt their way through the jelly beans and decided it was innocent enough and let me deliver it to the front door. And a few days later he called the school and said he'd come. And I was on the debating team at the time, and I thought I was a pretty good debater, and I thought I could make quick work of Ronald Reagan. He held all the views that we rejected. He was for the Vietnam War, we were against it. He was against giving 18-year-olds the right to vote, which was an issue of debate at the time. I thought it would be relatively easy to defeat him in a debate, so I prepared, I sat up on the stage with him, point by point challenged him, and I didn't really lay a glove on him. It was an object lesson in how a politician can, by listening and engaging, actually charm an audience that entirely disagrees with him.
Presenter asks
What were your ambitions for the Justice course you designed at Harvard?
When I had my first brush with political philosophy as a student, I found it remote, abstract, dull. And what drew me to philosophy? was seen the connection between philosophical accounts of justice and rights and liberty and the good life, And the debates we have every day. To take one recent example, there are fraught debates going on now about mask wearing. Does government have the right to mandate the wearing of masks? And does government have the right, for that matter, to mandate? Getting a jab with the COVID vaccine. Now the ideal scenario to play out that discussion is not to begin with like minded people people who say, well, of course everyone should be required to wear a mask. It all depends on gathering people, whether in a classroom or in a public forum. Who disagree? Not just for the friseon of having clashing views. The disagreement is a starting point. To see whether the participants can respond to the arguments, to the competing principles that are at stake in the debate. That's the excitement of it.
Presenter asks
What metric would you use to measure the value of your own work as a teacher?
If I'm in a lecture hall and I hear people coughing or shuffling their papers or their feet, I know that I've lost them. So my metrics, if you want to call them metrics, are looking at the eyes and listening to the sound of the classroom. And if there's coughing and shifting and shuffling of feet, I need to shift. I need to do better. The other is, and it's the most gratifying report that any teacher ever gets, is when years later someone from the course writes or calls to say what an impact it made on their thinking over the course of their lives. It matters more than any quantitative teaching evaluation could possibly do.
“Philosophy estranges us from the familiar. It leads us to question familiar assumptions, the way we live. But it's a journey in a way.”
“When we put the Justice Course online, we never dreamt I certainly didn't, that tens of millions of people would want to watch lectures about philosophy.”
“I didn't really lay a glove on him. It was an object lesson in how a politician can, by listening and engaging, actually charm an audience that entirely disagrees with him.”
“Because this way of thinking about success also leads the successful to believe that those who struggle, those who are left behind, have no one to blame but themselves.”
“The humility that parenting teaches, I think, springs from the fact that however much we might try to shape our children, help our children, they are who they are, and it's not thanks to our doing only. And cultivating that distinctiveness, which exceeds our efforts to shape and control and to mold, simply beholding them and loving them for who they are, that's where the humility comes in. That kind of humility, I think, is part of love.”