Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
Famous singer, began career in 1890s, widow of conductor Sir Hamilton Harty.
Eight records
Overture to The Marriage of Figaro
The overture to The Marriage of Figaro
The snippet from Swan Lake
"Mi chiamano Mimì" from La bohème
Nellie Melba's farewell at Covent Garden when she sang Mimi for the last time
It's my husband's work. It's a second movement out of his Irish Symphony. And I just adore it.
Nimrod (from Enigma Variations)
Orchestra conducted by Sir Thomas Beecham
Partly because I'm very fond of it, but also because I did a great deal of work with Sir Edward.
Winterstürme wichen dem Wonnemond (Spring Song) from Die Walküre
The spring song from Die Walküre, sung by Walter Hyde, in English.
Hallelujah Chorus from Messiah
Huddersfield Choral Society, Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Sir Malcolm Sargent
Because Messiah was one of the first oratorios I ever heard. It was in Gloucester Cathedral at the musical festival. But I was so impressed by that chorus. I never forgot it.
The keepsakes
The book
a big dictionary, one of the old-fashioned dictionaries
I want a big dictionary, one of the old-fashioned dictionaries. You see, I'll never be short of reading then. Never. Because you know you never can stop when you once look at it.
The luxury
In conversation
Presenter asks
You said you started your career as a violinist. What made you decide in the first place that music was your vocation?
I think uh from the fact that my parents were very intent amateur musicians and they had always had a great deal of music in their home. And it was the days when you made parlour tricks yourself. There were no concerts much to go to, perhaps one now and again, no pictures, nor anything of that sort, so you had to make music if you wanted to eat in your own home. And that was how I began. I started uh when I was five with a fiddle. A little quota fiddle. and progressed with that. Well then gradually I began singing one doesn't use your in it you know, just do it. And then I sang in a choral class in my boarding school. And that was really how it began.
Presenter asks
What was your first professional engagement? Do you remember?
Yes, I do indeed. It was at a chapel or a church rather? On an Easter Sunday with a great full service and there was also an orchestra and the organ and we did the mess solonelle and I had to sing all the tenor parts because the tenor couldn't get the high notes.
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Presenter
This is the
Speaker 1
B B C
Speaker 1
Hello, I'm Kirstie Young, and this is a download from the Desert Island Discs archive. This edition may be slightly different from what was actually broadcast, but it is the only version we have. The recording didn't contain the guests' eight music choices, so we've rebuilt the original show by using discs from the BBC Gramophone library. For Wrights' reasons, we've had to shorten the music.
Speaker 1
Full details can be found on the Castaways page on the Desert Island Disc's website.
Speaker 1
The programme was originally broadcast in nineteen fifty eight.
Presenter
Desert Island Dens.
Presenter
Each week, a well-known person is asked the question, if you were to be cast away alone on a desert island, which eight gramophone records would you choose to have with you, assuming, of course, that you also had a gramophone?
Presenter
As usual, the week's castaway is introduced by Roy Plumley.
Presenter
How do you do, ladies and gentlemen?
Presenter
Our Castaway this week has a unique store of memories of the musical scene.
Presenter
A famous singer, she began her career back in the eighteen nineties.
Presenter
She's the widow of a distinguished and well-remembered conductor and composer and pianist Sir Hamilton Harty. Here is Miss Agnes Nicholls, Lady Hartie.
Presenter
Well, Lady Harty, how do you feel about a spell on a desert island? Does the thought fill you with horror?
Agnes Nicholls
No, I don't think so. Not at all.
Presenter
It's quite a nice island.
Agnes Nicholls
Yes, and I'm full of uh very adventures, really.
Presenter
But how have you gone about choosing your eight records to take with you?
Agnes Nicholls
Well, I chose them in various ways. The first one, because I
Agnes Nicholls
I played in the orchestra as a girl. I was a fiddle, not a singer originally. And I played in this orchestra.
Agnes Nicholls
at about, I suppose, 13.
Agnes Nicholls
And I thought it was very wonderful, but I was wondering how on earth I should get to the end of the thing properly, because it was so quick, and I was only very young.
Presenter
What was the beat?
Agnes Nicholls
The manager See Gero.
Agnes Nicholls
The overture to the marriage of Egypt,
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Yeah.
Agnes Nicholls
And then another thing that interests me was because it was the first Mozart opera I ever played in. I played the Countess in it. And so it's always had for me a very great feeling of affection and...
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, so such lovely things altogether
Presenter
Some lovely memories for you.
Agnes Nicholls
Yes, lovely. It's funny that the two things sort of
Agnes Nicholls
coincided with the beginning of my um sort of work in music and my first
Agnes Nicholls
Is saying Mozart opera.
Presenter
Let's listen to it.
Presenter
The opening of the overture to the marriage of Figura.
Presenter
With Rafael Kubilik conducting the Philharmonia Orchestra. What comes next?
Agnes Nicholls
The signets, I think that's the correct pronunciation, which comes from the ballet The Swan Lake.
Presenter
Yes, why do you choose this?
Agnes Nicholls
Because I it was the first ballet I ever saw.
Agnes Nicholls
And it made a great impression on me. It was so very beautiful.
Agnes Nicholls
And I was especially attracted by the four little dancers who did this particular thing so extraordinarily well.
Agnes Nicholls
And it was so beautiful to listen to.
Presenter
Anna Tolphus Tullauri conducting the London Symphony Orchestra in that excerpt from Swan Lake.
Presenter
Lady Harty, you said you started your career as a violinist. What made you decide in the first place that music was your vocation?
Agnes Nicholls
I think uh from the fact that my parents were very
Agnes Nicholls
very intent amateur musicians and they had always had a great deal of music in their home.
Agnes Nicholls
And it was the days when you made parlour tricks yourself.
Agnes Nicholls
There were no concerts much to go to, perhaps one now and again, no pictures, nor anything of that sort, so you had to make music if you wanted to eat in your own home.
Speaker 4
Yeah.
Agnes Nicholls
And that was how I began. I started
Agnes Nicholls
uh when I was five with a fiddle.
Agnes Nicholls
A little quota fiddle.
Speaker 4
Yeah.
Agnes Nicholls
and progressed with that. Well then gradually I began singing one doesn't use your in it you know, just do it. And then I sang in a choral class in my boarding school. And that was really how it began.
Presenter
And then you went to the you you took a scholarship, didn't you, at the Royal College of Music.
Agnes Nicholls
Yes. I did. My father died and I went in for the scholarship. I saw it was advertised and I went and said I was going to try for it. My mother thought I was quite mad. However, I got it.
Presenter
Add the sync.
Agnes Nicholls
As a singer. I wasn't allowed to play the fiddle either.
Presenter
What was your first professional engagement? Do you remember?
Agnes Nicholls
Yes, I do indeed. It was at a chapel or a church rather?
Agnes Nicholls
On an Easter Sunday with a great full service and there was also an orchestra and the organ and we did the mess solonelle and I had to sing all the tenor parts because the tenor couldn't get the high notes. Couldn't get those high notes.
Presenter
When did you make your operatic debut?
Agnes Nicholls
102, I think.
Agnes Nicholls
The Dew Fairy in Hanson and Gretel.
Presenter
At Gottengotten
Agnes Nicholls
Magic golf and card.
Presenter
And you sang at Common Con for a good many years, didn't you?
Agnes Nicholls
On and off until nineteen fourteen.
Presenter
And yeah.
Agnes Nicholls
Yeah.
Agnes Nicholls
Every kind of
Presenter
Yeah.
Agnes Nicholls
Big and little.
Presenter
And apart from that, lots of travels pretty well all over the world.
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, lots of travels. Went up to South Africa to Australia.
Agnes Nicholls
Domeric.
Agnes Nicholls
and also on the continent.
Presenter
You sang several times before Queen Victoria, didn't you?
Agnes Nicholls
I did indeed.
Agnes Nicholls
The first time was at her own diamond jubilee.
Agnes Nicholls
when they gave a performance of the hymn of praise at St George's Chapel, Windsor, under Sir Walter Parrott. Madame Albany was the first soprano, Edward Lloyd the tenor, and I sang the second soprano part. I thought I was the earth.
Presenter
Well, you certainly have some wonderful memories.
Agnes Nicholls
Happens.
Presenter
What's your third record going to be?
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, may I have a nail of farewell, please?
Presenter
Melbourne's farewell at Cobbin Garden when she sang Mimi for the last time.
Agnes Nicholls
Please.
Presenter
The voice of Melbeth.
Presenter
You worked, of course, with all the great singers of what we now know as the golden age of opera, didn't you?
Agnes Nicholls
I did indeed.
Agnes Nicholls
I sang with Caruso.
Agnes Nicholls
And also people like Better Stuni and Scotty.
Agnes Nicholls
And uh Destin and others have that celebrated
Presenter
How bad.
Agnes Nicholls
Time?
Presenter
What was your own favourite role?
Agnes Nicholls
Add blood.
Presenter
Hadn't worked.
Agnes Nicholls
Not
Presenter
Well, let's put it this way, what was your least favorite row?
Agnes Nicholls
Pamina, I didn't like playing her at all.
Presenter
What?
Agnes Nicholls
She had lovely music to sing, but I felt I was utterly unsuited to being a little girl and
Agnes Nicholls
I was enormous and I didn't like playing with a little mother who was about three inches high, the queen of the night.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Where did you first meet your husband?
Agnes Nicholls
I met him in London. Here he was engaged to play for me at a concert.
Presenter
As your accompanist.
Agnes Nicholls
As my company, so I didn't know it all.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
You did a great deal of work together.
Agnes Nicholls
We did an enormous lot lot of work there. He helped me, of course, enormously with all the great roles that I did. And he taught me many things about
Agnes Nicholls
orchestral scores so that I should know where things were especially heavy. and where to reserve myself and such things, because I played roles which in many ways I expect were too big for me, like Risold and things like that. But he helped me all over those things.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
But watch your fourth record.
Agnes Nicholls
On a fair day.
Agnes Nicholls
It's my husband's work. It comes, it's a second movement out of his Irish Symphony.
Agnes Nicholls
And I just adore it and I wanted something in this program that I was doing with his.
Presenter
Sir Hamilton Harty conducting the Halley Orchestra in the schazzo from his own Irish Symphony.
Presenter
Lady Harty, since your retirement you've retained all your enthusiasms for music, haven't you? You hear all you can.
Agnes Nicholls
Indeed I have. I go to everything I possibly can. I don't want to get behind.
Presenter
Do you think the standard of singing is as good now as it was when you started your career?
Agnes Nicholls
Honestly, no.
Agnes Nicholls
I think that is still excellent singing in some ways.
Agnes Nicholls
But what I would call the rank and file is so much more odd.
Presenter
Ordinary than it used to be. Yes. Can you think of any reason for that?
Agnes Nicholls
Yes, I do think that it's possible they all have to work too hard.
Agnes Nicholls
They have to learn quickly, they have to do everything for themselves, they have to cook and housekeep and travel and nothing is very easy today.
Speaker 4
Hmm.
Agnes Nicholls
And I really think that has a great deal to do with it.
Agnes Nicholls
I may be wrong, but there it is.
Presenter
And what about the productions?
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, I think you mean the the theatrical production?
Presenter
Cheers.
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, I think some are magnificent.
Presenter
compared with the ones that you wear.
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, many of them are infinitely better.
Agnes Nicholls
I mean take a thing like the Trojans which they did lately at a Cotton Garden Magnificent Show.
Speaker 4
Uh
Presenter
Mm-hmm.
Agnes Nicholls
And the new AI that they've done there is excellent too.
Presenter
Well, let's have another record. What's number five?
Agnes Nicholls
Nimrod, please. Nimrog from Sir Edward Elgar's and Nigra Vedication.
Presenter
And why do you choose it?
Agnes Nicholls
Partly because I'm silky.
Agnes Nicholls
Very fond of it, but also because I did a great deal of work with Sir Edward. But the work I have done with him is not really suitable to break up and put on a record.
Agnes Nicholls
on a thing like this. Because they're mostly things that are torius, like the kingdom.
Speaker 4
Yeah.
Agnes Nicholls
So I thought if we could have the Nimrod, which is so entirely characteristic of him, and so very lovely, it would be nice.
Presenter
Nimrod from the
Presenter
Enigma Variations conducted by Sir Thomas Beacham. Now what?
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, the spring song from the Valkyra, please.
Presenter
Yeah.
Agnes Nicholls
Sung by Walter Hyde.
Agnes Nicholls
In English.
Presenter
Yes. You all sang in the ring during its first production in English, didn't you?
Agnes Nicholls
The first production in English I sang in. So did he. He was also a fellow student of mine at the Royal College of Music. It's a lovely voice.
Agnes Nicholls
And when he left the college he went to work at once and he went mostly, I think, on the light opera stage. I remember that at the time of the English ring he was playing My Lady Molly.
Agnes Nicholls
And uh mister Percy Pitt, who was arranging all the parts with Doctor Hans Richter, asked me if I thought he would be able to do the segment. I said, There's no one better.
Agnes Nicholls
And they got him to come down and sing. They were just delighted with him.
Agnes Nicholls
And so then he came and sang and of course he was famous in the night.
Agnes Nicholls
And that's why I would love to have a spring song. It sounds beautiful today.
Speaker 4
Winter storms have waned in the moon of May, with a firm of radiant battles fling on a farmy free that light and lovely, waving wonders on the floor.
Speaker 4
O wood and bed, Opsy breathing, widely open and of the door.
Speaker 4
Yeah.
Speaker 4
What I should swing up by the mouth
Presenter
Lady Hartie, have you any qualifications, do you think, as a castaway? How how would you manage on this island?
Agnes Nicholls
Where?
Agnes Nicholls
I'm a very practical person, which is surprising, I suppose. Being a singer, they always say that if you're an artist, you're not a practical person.
Presenter
They always
Agnes Nicholls
But I think I was, and am, still.
Agnes Nicholls
And I think I'd do all right in most ways.
Presenter
Build a shelter?
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, well I'd try and find rocks to do that.
Agnes Nicholls
So I could get under rocks and draw leaves round for a shelter.
Presenter
Mm. What would you eat?
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, that's another matter. I dunno. It's difficult. But I think there'll be lots of fruit, wouldn't there?
Presenter
Oh, I think so. Ever done any fishing?
Agnes Nicholls
Dumbness
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, I've done lots of fishing in my day. We used to go to Sutherland to fish always every year.
Agnes Nicholls
Once I was nearly pulled out of a boat by a salmon, I may tell you.
Agnes Nicholls
Saved by the Ghilly.
Presenter
Are you a good cook?
Agnes Nicholls
Yes, quite good.
Presenter
You're going to be all right on this island. Let's leave that subject and get back to records.
Agnes Nicholls
Leave that side.
Agnes Nicholls
Oh
Presenter
What next?
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, I want the funeral march from Gitter Demero.
Presenter
Yes. Why?
Agnes Nicholls
Just cause I adore.
Agnes Nicholls
I don't think there's any other reasons. I think it's ma
Presenter
But of Siegfried's funeral march.
Presenter
Conducted once again by Sir Thomas Beacham. And now we come to your last record.
Agnes Nicholls
The hallelujah chorus, please, from Handel's Messiah.
Presenter
Uh What?
Agnes Nicholls
Because Messiah was one of the first oratorios I ever heard.
Agnes Nicholls
It was in Gloucester Cathedral at the musical festival. I don't remember the year, but I was quite young.
Agnes Nicholls
But I was so impressed.
Agnes Nicholls
Bye that chorus. I never forgot it.
Agnes Nicholls
Years later I heard it again sung by the Sheffield.
Agnes Nicholls
Musical Festival Chorus.
Agnes Nicholls
And again, the impact was something colossal.
Presenter
Well, I'm afraid we can't give you either of those performances that you heard, but here's a recording by the Huddersfield Choral Society with the Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra, and it's conducted by Sir Malcolm Sargent.
Agnes Nicholls
That'll be glorious.
Speaker 4
Oh love and brave man.
Agnes Nicholls
Well, you know, I don't think I should do too badly on my island with all those lovely records, do you?
Presenter
Lovely records indeed. And as well as those records, you're allowed, of course, one luxury. What are you choosing to take with you?
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, I want a big dictionary, one of the old-fashioned dictionaries. You see, I'll never be short of reading then.
Agnes Nicholls
Never. Because you know you never can stop when you once look at it.
Presenter
No shit.
Presenter
You mean one word takes you on to another?
Agnes Nicholls
Yes, all the drawings of all the animals and things.
Presenter
Yes.
Agnes Nicholls
All the wonderful things, those old dictionaries.
Presenter
All right, you shall have the biggest and most illustrated one we can find, but
Presenter
Choose something else. If if anyone chooses a book, we usually say something else as well.
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, well, I know what I want.
Agnes Nicholls
A lovely peak.
Presenter
Backup
Agnes Nicholls
A French perfume.
Presenter
All right, the biggest bottle in London.
Presenter
And thank you very much, Lady Hearty, for letting us know your choice of Desert Island discs.
Agnes Nicholls
Oh, thank you, mister Pramley, for my delightful
Agnes Nicholls
afternoon of talking with you about all the things I loved in my youth.
Presenter
Goodbye.
Agnes Nicholls
And still do.
Presenter
Good.
Agnes Nicholls
Goodbye.
Speaker 1
You've been listening to a podcast from the Desert Island Discs Archive. For more podcasts please visit bbc.co.uk slash radio four. This is the BBC
Presenter asks
You sang several times before Queen Victoria, didn't you?
I did indeed. The first time [I sang before Queen Victoria] was at her own diamond jubilee, when they gave a performance of the hymn of praise at St George's Chapel, Windsor, under Sir Walter Parrott. Madame Albany was the first soprano, Edward Lloyd the tenor, and I sang the second soprano part. I thought I was the earth.
Presenter asks
Where did you first meet your husband?
I met him in London. Here he was engaged to play for me at a concert. As my accompanist. … He helped me, of course, enormously with all the great roles that I did. And he taught me many things about orchestral scores so that I should know where things were especially heavy and where to reserve myself and such things, because I played roles which in many ways I expect were too big for me, like Isolde and things like that.
Presenter asks
Do you think the standard of singing is as good now as it was when you started your career?
Honestly, no. I think there is still excellent singing in some ways. But what I would call the rank and file is so much more odd. … I do think that it's possible they all have to work too hard. They have to learn quickly, they have to do everything for themselves, they have to cook and housekeep and travel and nothing is very easy today. And I really think that has a great deal to do with it.
Presenter asks
And what about the [stage] productions [today compared with the ones you saw]?
Oh, I think some are magnificent. … Many of them are infinitely better. I mean take a thing like the Trojans which they did lately at Covent Garden – magnificent show. And the new AI that they've done there is excellent too.
“I think uh from the fact that my parents were very intent amateur musicians and they had always had a great deal of music in their home. And it was the days when you made parlour tricks yourself. There were no concerts much to go to, perhaps one now and again, no pictures, nor anything of that sort, so you had to make music if you wanted to eat in your own home.”
“The first time [I sang before Queen Victoria] was at her own diamond jubilee, when they gave a performance of the hymn of praise at St George's Chapel, Windsor, under Sir Walter Parrott. Madame Albany was the first soprano, Edward Lloyd the tenor, and I sang the second soprano part. I thought I was the earth.”
“Pamina, I didn't like playing her at all. She had lovely music to sing, but I felt I was utterly unsuited to being a little girl and I was enormous and I didn't like playing with a little mother who was about three inches high, the queen of the night.”
“He helped me, of course, enormously with all the great roles that I did. And he taught me many things about orchestral scores so that I should know where things were especially heavy and where to reserve myself and such things, because I played roles which in many ways I expect were too big for me, like Isolde and things like that.”
“I do think that it's possible [today's singers] all have to work too hard. They have to learn quickly, they have to do everything for themselves, they have to cook and housekeep and travel and nothing is very easy today. And I really think that has a great deal to do with it.”