Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
Author of 'The Naked Island', a memoir of his time as a Japanese prisoner of war on the Burma Railway.
Eight records
favourite piece of music because everyone at some time in his life should conduct a rip-roaring piece of music
The Holy CityFavourite
goes back to my prisoner of war background … a Welshman who used to come out of his cell … belt out this holy city … on my island it would make me feel better still. So I can sing and I can conduct.
The keepsakes
No book or luxury recorded for this episode.
In conversation
Presenter asks
After twenty five years, has your memory of those days [in the prison camps] softened?
Not softened, it's exactly the same. I still remember it as a time it would horrify me to think that the same thing could happen again to another generation. It would more than horrify, I couldn't stand it. … But on the other hand, I have softened to the extent that I know that everything the Japanese did to us, which at the time seemed bestial and criminal, they did honorably. … They really did kill us and allow us to die with the honorable conviction that this was our lot. And it is a comfort to know this.
Presenter asks
You have indeed been back to Changi camp since the war. How did that feel?
Yes, I've been back four times, and each time I get back I'm assailed with nostalgia. For a community that worked. It was a highly civilized life that we made for ourselves. And also assailed with the conviction that I better get down and start working, otherwise I'll get a hiding.
Presenter asks
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 2
This is the
Speaker 1
B B C
Speaker 1
Hello, I'm Kirsty Young and this is a podcast from the Desert Island Discs Archive. This is the only version we have of this edition and may be slightly different from what was actually broadcast. The recording didn't contain the guests' eight music choices, so we rebuilt the original show by using discs from the BBC Gramophone library. For Wrights' reasons, we've had to shorten the music.
Speaker 1
Full details can be found on the Castaways page on the Desert Island Discs website.
Speaker 1
The programme was originally broadcast in 1968 and the presenter was Roy Plumney.
Presenter
mister Braddon, what was your plan in choosing your aid records?
Russell Braddon
Uh my my plan was based on
Russell Braddon
very specific needs which I knew I would have because I've endured this kind of thing before. When was it? As a prisoner of war of the Japanese, we we lived in a community that had nothing. Whatever you you did acquire, you had to make for yourself.
Russell Braddon
and almost everything you wanted was missing.
Russell Braddon
particularly in the way of people. So I kn I knew
Russell Braddon
that I needed the sound of
Russell Braddon
women's voices because this is something you miss particularly. You not only miss it, you forget it. You forget what it's like. And I knew this I needed the sound of children.
Russell Braddon
I needed certain certain tunes that I couldn't remember properly, and they would drive me mad if I couldn't remember them, and so on.
Presenter
What's the first one you have?
Russell Braddon
The first one is I I've got is Liszt's Hungarian Rhapsody number two and I've got this purely and simply because everyone at some time in his life should conduct a rip-roaring piece of music.
Russell Braddon
The trouble is if you do, you're seen. And on Desert Island you won't be seen. And this is the Rip Roaringist, I want List Hungarian Rhapsody No. 2.
Russell Braddon
Second choice is Holy City.
Russell Braddon
A reason for it again, it goes back to my prisoner of war background. I I remember there was a Welshman who used to come out of his cell and stand in the middle of the cell block, all the sounds echoing round him, and he would belt out this holy city, Jerusalem, Jerusalem. And when he did, you could sing yourself at the top of your voice, and you couldn't hear any sound at all. All you could hear was him.
Russell Braddon
And this is perfect when you've got a a voice with a range of three notes and they're all flat.
Russell Braddon
And it made me feel better always. It made us all feel better. And I think on my island it would make me feel better still. So I can sing and I can conduct.
Speaker 2
Last night I lay asleep in, there came a dream so fair. I stood in old Jerusalem beside the temple girl. I heard the children singing, and ever as they sang, Methought the voice of angels from heaven in answer.
Presenter
Whereabouts in Australia were you born? Sydney, civilized bit?
Presenter
What were you going to be? What was your further ambition?
Russell Braddon
All my life, ever since I could remember, I was going to be a barrister. I didn't know what it meant. Well, my family were all barristers or members of parliament.
Russell Braddon
And so when people said to me, Russell, what are you going to be when you grow up? I would say a barrister.
Presenter
Yes. What went wrong?
Russell Braddon
The war in the first place I went to that to become a field marshal instead, but they didn't see what military talents I had. And anyway, I surrendered, so I never got higher than private.
Presenter
Where was that?
Russell Braddon
Malaya.
Presenter
Yes, you didn't have much of a chance in Malaya, did you?
Presenter
How long were you a prisoner of the Japanese?
Russell Braddon
Nearly four years.
Russell Braddon
So it seemed a long time.
Presenter
Some of the time on the Burma Railroad.
Russell Braddon
Yes, that's why it's such a bad railway line.
Presenter
You wrote a book, The Naked Island, describing life in the camps, describing the senseless and unbelievable cruelty. After twenty five years, has your memory of those days softened?
Russell Braddon
Not softened, it's exactly the same. I still remember it as as a time it it would horrify me to think that the same thing could happen again to another generation. It would more than horrify, I couldn't stand it.
Russell Braddon
But on the other hand, uh I have softened to the extent that I know that everything the Japanese did to us, which at the time seemed bestial and criminal,
Russell Braddon
They did honorably. This is a strange thing to realize. And in a way, it's a comfort.
Russell Braddon
They really did kill us and allow us to die with the honorable conviction that this was our lot. And it is a comfort to know this.
Russell Braddon
which perhaps the survivor of the German concentration camps doesn't have. He knows that he was a vict
Presenter
Hmm.
Presenter
You have indeed bang been back to Chang Yi camp since the war.
Russell Braddon
Yes, I've been back four times, and each time I get back.
Russell Braddon
I'm assailed with nostalgia.
Russell Braddon
For a community that worked. It was a a highly civilized life that we made for ourselves. And also assailed with the conviction that I better get down and start working, otherwise I'll get a hiding.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
You had some distinguished citizens among your fellow prisoners.
Russell Braddon
Yes, it was a good breeding ground. You know, you start off from there and life can't really go wrong again. There was Ronald Searle and and he his work has never looked back. There was Sidney Pittington, who did marvellously. There was another private called Alec Downer who used to say when he got out he's going to go into politics and become Prime Minister, an Australian.
Speaker 1
Uh
Russell Braddon
Complete fallacy, he didn't of course, he just became the present High Commissioner to London.
Presenter
Yes. Now certainly Pittington a a very familiar name. B between you you evolved a mind reading act.
Russell Braddon
Yeah.
Presenter
In the camps? Yes.
Presenter
What happened to you after the Japanese surrender?
Russell Braddon
Well, Pittington wanted to come over here straight away and start doing professionally what we'd done to occupy occupy our mines in Changee.
Russell Braddon
I didn't. I still wanted to be a barrister.
Presenter
Hmm.
Russell Braddon
He said, I didn't know what the law was, so I said no, and I went back to the university and started studying law, and hated it from the instant I took it up. I've never known a more disagreeable subject or a more terrible profession.
Russell Braddon
But it took me three years to become ill enough to be able to drop it and Sit Piddington meantime had met this girl and married her and trained her to take my part in the show and unbeknownst to me had come over to this country to try and break into the B B C.
Presenter
Yes.
Presenter
Why did you come to the United Kingdom?
Russell Braddon
Well, because I'd been in hospital for five months with every prisoner of war disease that there ever was, and when I came out they said, you know, I mustn't work for a year, my brain, otherwise I'd go insane.
Russell Braddon
which seemed a lovely verdict to me. I
Russell Braddon
Except that no one stopped work with me. I had nothing to do and so I thought, well, I must go home, as all Australians do, to England. To England. Here I came. You met Sidney?
Presenter
Peddington again.
Russell Braddon
Yes, he he was waiting for me when I got off the boat train. He I just felt a tap on the shoulder and I thought, Good God, I'm arrested already and it was Pittdington. He said that he had eight broadcasts to do for the BBC. I knew the show, would I write the scripts?
Russell Braddon
Because the BBC insists on, you see, on these scripts being written and he and his wife couldn't even write letters.
Presenter
You became not only scriptwriter for the Piddingtons, but also manager and part of the act.
Russell Braddon
Yes, yes I did. Um
Russell Braddon
It was a complicated business devising what should be done each week.
Presenter
We go.
Russell Braddon
We are
Presenter
How long we would
Presenter
Three years. They did some very mystifying stunts. Which one do you think was the most successful?
Russell Braddon
I think really the t the time when
Russell Braddon
Leslie w that was Mrs. Pittington was in the Tower of London and her husband was in the BBC's Piccadilly studio.
Russell Braddon
And I maybe I remember it for malicious reasons because when we put the proposal up to the BBC they said impossible. It would take nine years to get the tower going through regulation channels. And so Pittington and I went down to Piccadilly Tube with a handful of pennies and rang up everyone we knew and in the end were speaking to a gentleman who said that he was the governor of the tower. Of course we could have it. So we went back that day and told the BBC.
Speaker 2
Yeah.
Russell Braddon
And the Piddingtons did this broadcast and and Leslie told Sydney what was written up on the board in Piccadilly.
Presenter
Mm-hmm. And Leslie was in a dungeon.
Russell Braddon
And she was in a dungeon in the tower, and just at the moment when she she revealed the most stunning answer of all, a tug on the Thames hooted dismally.
Russell Braddon
and was heard.
Russell Braddon
And thousands of people wrote to the Peddington saying, that's how it's done, there's a tub on the temp.
Presenter
Cool to see.
Russell Braddon
That's the code.
Presenter
Digest the code because it was.
Russell Braddon
Good morning.
Presenter
A tree.
Russell Braddon
Very expensive.
Presenter
You were writing scripts for the Pittingtons. Did you do any other writing at this time?
Russell Braddon
Not not until some
Russell Braddon
Publishers suggested that the Peddingtons should write their autobiography. Well, you know, people who can't write letters or scripts certainly can't write autobiographies. So they looked at me hopefully and I didn't know what writing a book meant. I said, certainly.
Russell Braddon
And wrote? And I've been writing ever since?
Presenter
Well then came The Naked Island. Yes.
Presenter
And
Presenter
You've done a number of biographies. You had a great success with a biography of your fellow Australian Jan Sutherland.
Russell Braddon
Well, if I had a great success it was because she's a great woman and a very truthful one.
Presenter
Did you know it was such a good story when you started writing that?
Russell Braddon
No, I had no idea, but she did a marvellous interview with one of the newspapers and I thought a woman who can be as honest and as amusing and as candid and as
Russell Braddon
unassuming as that about herself, really must be quite a person, and I went to see her.
Speaker 1
And I went.
Russell Braddon
and asked her, Could I do it? And she said, Did you write The Naked Island? and I said yes and she said yes you can do it and I said you can't decide like that woman and she said yes I can my brother was a prisoner of war.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Who else, Lord Thompson?
Russell Braddon
Yes, Roy Thompson's biography. Very honest man.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
And as well as writing factual biographies, you've also written fiction, quite a lot of fiction, yes.
Presenter
All your books have very varied backgrounds.
Russell Braddon
Turn.
Russell Braddon
Well, yours would too if if you had to do as much research as one does nowadays. You you're up to your neck for about a year in getting all the train tables right and uh
Russell Braddon
distances, right? All these little things with an enormous amount of work
Presenter
Yeah.
Russell Braddon
If you've got to do an enormous amount of work, you might at least have the satisfaction each time of learning something different. How long did the Joan Sutherland book take you? Two years. Mind you, that was no effort. I heard about seven million pounds worth of marvellous music and first lights and everything else.
Presenter
How do you set about writing a biography? Do you like to do your own background research before you talk to your subject?
Russell Braddon
No, I l I like to talk to the subject and do the background research at the same time.
Russell Braddon
Um you asked them how it happened that they did
Russell Braddon
a desert island disc with you and they tell you and then I come to you and ask you how it happened and you tell me something quite different. It's not that you're both liars, although you may well be, but it's just that everybody remembers things differently and then you've got to find sort of points of cross reference and go from there.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Does the biography have any rights? Suppose um he claims that you've overemphasized one particular characteristic.
Russell Braddon
From the point of view of integrity, you should have no rights at all. If you believe genuinely that that mister Plumley is a liar about someone who appeared on his programme, then you must say so when your biography has been written.
Russell Braddon
But on the other hand, if you say to me that I have
Russell Braddon
Oh, you convince me that I have misrepresented something, then I must change it.
Russell Braddon
To give you an idea, Roy Thompson, when I wrote his biography, in which I said many harsh things about him, rang me up and said I'd like to see you about two of them.
Russell Braddon
I went in prepared to fight him tooth and nail.
Russell Braddon
And he said, Russ, you said that I was mean.
Presenter
Oh, he was thinking of the North American use of the word means.
Russell Braddon
He was thinking
Russell Braddon
Yeah, so I'm not mean, I'm stingy.
Russell Braddon
Didn't deny for a second that he didn't like giving away money, but he didn't want to be mean in in that North American sense. And he said, you said I was blind. There he is with glasses half an inch thick.
Presenter
Okay.
Russell Braddon
He said, I'm not blind, I'm myopic. These were the only two changes he wanted made.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
What have you been working on recently?
Russell Braddon
Three novels, one after the other. Mainly because I couldn't think of anyone to write a biography about that was wanted on both sides of the Atlantic.
Speaker 1
You've been listening to a podcast from the Desert Island Discs Archive. For more podcasts please visit bbc.co. uk slash radio four. This is the BBC
What happened to you after the Japanese surrender?
Well, Pidding[ton] wanted to come over here straight away and start doing professionally what we'd done to occupy our minds in Changi. I didn't. I still wanted to be a barrister. … I went back to the university and started studying law, and hated it from the instant I took it up. … It took me three years to become ill enough to be able to drop it and [Sid Piddington] meantime had met this girl and married her and trained her to take my part in the show.
Presenter asks
Why did you come to the United Kingdom?
Because I'd been in hospital for five months with every prisoner of war disease that there ever was, and when I came out they said, you know, I mustn't work for a year, my brain, otherwise I'd go insane. … I had nothing to do and so I thought, well, I must go home, as all Australians do, to England.
Presenter asks
Among the stunts the Piddingtons did, which one do you think was the most successful?
I think really the time when Leslie [Mrs. Piddington] was in the Tower of London and her husband was in the BBC's Piccadilly studio. … Pidding[ton] and I went down to Piccadilly Tube with a handful of pennies and rang up everyone we knew and in the end were speaking to a gentleman who said that he was the governor of the tower. Of course we could have it. … And Leslie told Sydney what was written up on the board in Piccadilly. … And thousands of people wrote to the Piddingtons saying, that's how it's done, there's a tug on the Thames.
Presenter asks
Did you know [the Joan Sutherland biography] was such a good story when you started writing it?
No, I had no idea, but she did a marvellous interview with one of the newspapers and I thought a woman who can be as honest and as amusing and as candid and as unassuming as that about herself, really must be quite a person, and I went to see her. … and asked her, Could I do it? And she said, Did you write The Naked Island? and I said yes and she said yes you can do it.
“I knew that I needed the sound of women's voices because this is something you miss particularly. You not only miss it, you forget it. You forget what it's like.”
“Everyone at some time in his life should conduct a rip-roaring piece of music. The trouble is if you do, you're seen. And on Desert Island you won't be seen.”
“I have softened to the extent that I know that everything the Japanese did to us, which at the time seemed bestial and criminal, they did honorably. … They really did kill us and allow us to die with the honorable conviction that this was our lot. And it is a comfort to know this.”
“I'm assailed with nostalgia. For a community that worked. It was a highly civilized life that we made for ourselves. And also assailed with the conviction that I better get down and start working, otherwise I'll get a hiding.”
“[Roy Thompson] rang me up and said I'd like to see you about two of them. … He said, Russ, you said that I was mean. … so I'm not mean, I'm stingy. … He said, you said I was blind. … I'm not blind, I'm myopic. These were the only two changes he wanted made.”