Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Sue Lawley
A classical pianist and conductor, regarded as one of the finest exponents of classical music, a music director of the first rank, and a BBC Reith lecturer.
Eight records
Piano Concerto No. 2 in F minor, Op. 21: I. Maestoso
Arthur Rubinstein, Philharmonia Orchestra and Carlo Maria Giulini
He knew my parents when my mother was pregnant with me, so he re literally knew me before I was I was born and was always a source of great encouragement throughout my life.
Symphony No. 4 in D minor, Op. 120: IV. Langsam - Lebhaft
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra and Wilhelm Furtwängler
Furtwengler to me symbolizes somebody who really articulated very profoundly the n very nature of music making.
Piano Sonata No. 17 in D major, D. 850: IV. Rondo. Moderato con delicatezza
There was something so lively and do you say felicious? Can you say that? Felicitous. Felicitous in his sound. And this has always been one of my favorite records.
Cello Concerto in E minor, Op. 85: I. Adagio - Moderato
Jacqueline du Pré, BBC Symphony Orchestra and Sir John Barbirolli
I was so struck by the quality of the performance. And it was a tour that took place in January 1967, very shortly after we met.
Violin Concerto in E minor, Op. 64: I. Allegro molto appassionato
Nathan Milstein, New York Philharmonic and Bruno Walter
Milstein for me somehow managed to put two qualities together in a way that made the violin the most sensuous and the most expressive instrument.
a work of great uh sonic imagination and it is not only deeply thought and or deeply felt, but a real kaleidoscopic pleasure for the ear.
The Well-Tempered Clavier, Book II: Prelude No. 3 in C-sharp major, BWV 872
he became an example for me because he was the main propagator, if you want, if it can be expressed in this way, of the art of playing and conducting simultaneously.
The Well-Tempered Clavier, Book I: Fugue No. 5 in D major, BWV 850
that shows you that it can be stylistically very free and very grand and has the ability to have so much more color than most harpsichord players manage to get today
The keepsakes
The book
Baruch Spinoza
the book that I have looked at most in the last fifty years of my life ... is the Ethics of Spinoza.
The luxury
The piano is not a luxury. But give me a piano and a mattress that I can put on it to sleep.
In conversation
Presenter asks
Would you go as far as to say [music] was the first language you ever knew?
I don't know, because in a way I don't think of it only as a language, because language creates very precise associations, whereas music uh creates associations that very often are not precise. And having said all of that, I think I must have been conscious of music uh very, very early on
Presenter asks
Why [did so many big names in music come to Buenos Aires when you were a boy]?
Because Buenos Aires was a very, very important opera theater in the world. And as the Second World War developed and parts of Europe were closed to the Jews and other parts of Europe were closed to the Nazis, Argentina seems to have been open to everybody.
Presenter asks
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 3
Hello, I'm Kirsty Young, and this is a podcast from the Desert Island Discs archive. For rights reasons we've had to shorten the music. The programme was originally broadcast in two thousand and six, and the presenter was Sue Lawley.
Presenter
My Costaway this week is a musician. He is one of the finest exponents of classical music alive in the world today, a brilliant pianist and conductor, and a music director of the first rank.
Presenter
For the past five weeks he's been delivering his vision of music in the BBC's Wreath Lectures here on Radio Four. Today we've come to his house in Jerusalem, overlooking the walls of the Old City, to hear what pieces of music matter most to him and how they relate to a life vivid with achievement and incident. I've had my share of suffering in life, he said, and very often in those bad moments music comes into my brain and the unhappiness will give way to something more pleasant and easier to live with. He is of course Daniel Barrenbohm. Daniel, music is and always has been your life, I know that, ever since you were born in Argentina. Would you go as far as to say it was the first language you ever knew?
Daniel Barenboim
I don't know, because in a way I don't think of it only as a language, because language creates very precise associations, whereas music uh creates associations that very often are not precise. And having said all of that, I think I must have been conscious of music uh very, very early on, because my parents and I lived in a rather small flat in Buenos Aires. Both my parents taught piano, so that whenever the doorbell rang, it was somebody coming for a piano lesson. I must have thought as a baby and as a child that the whole world played piano,'cause this is the only kind of people I met. So it was always very natural.
Presenter
You started playing the violin first and so
Daniel Barenboim
I I wanted to start studying the violin, but they couldn't find a violin small enough. I needed a quarter violin. And then I realized that the piano was actually a much more comfortable instrument. It had three legs, it stood on its own, it didn't have to hold it, it was an independent beast and it had the notes. You know, I could put my thumb on the one of those black keys and it makes a sound. Well, you can't do that on the violin.
Presenter
I was
Daniel Barenboim
I was what the Americans would call a very smart kid at that age.
Presenter
Could you play instinctively? Did you just sit down at it and and and and play by ear or, you know, was it uh uphill in the beginning?
Daniel Barenboim
Uphill in the beginning. I don't know about the talent, I won't comment on that, but uh my parents were not ambitious in the silly way that I was.
Presenter
They weren't pro
Presenter
But on the other hand, you played your first concert, I think, on a platform in public at the age of seven. I mean, that that's going some.
Daniel Barenboim
I mean that that
Daniel Barenboim
From that point of view I was a child prodigy, and there you see here I am today, the prodigy is gone and the child has remained.
Presenter
But what did you play? Do you remember what you played when you were seven?
Daniel Barenboim
I played a whole lot of things. I played everything I knew. There were some Schumann pieces and I played some Prokofiev pieces and played Bach and I played Haydn. I played a mixed, very mixed And you knew all that itself?
Presenter
You knew all that at seven.
Daniel Barenboim
I knew all that. And then I played seven uncles, if you please. And they kept applauding. And then, you know, I went on stage and I stopped the applause. And I said to the audience, I'm sorry, I played everything I know. I don't know any more. And that was it.
Daniel Barenboim
So you see I was talking too much already then.
Presenter
No, no, it's perfect.
Presenter
But we're sending you to a desert island anyway, so you'll have time not to talk at all when we get when you get there. But tell me about the first record you want to play there. You get eight, you know this, don't you?
Daniel Barenboim
Yes, yes, I know the programme, yes. The first record I chose uh is part of the beginning of the Schopen second piano concerto in F minor, played by Arthur Rubinstein for many reasons. He knew my parents when my mother was pregnant with me, so he re literally knew me before I was I was born and was always a source of great encouragement throughout my life. And of all the pianists, he was the first one that wanted to play with me as a conductor when I started conducting. And I chose this particular record because it is one of the few records of Rubinstein playing live.
Presenter
Part of the opening movement of Chopin's piano concerto number two in F minor, played by Otto Rubinstein with the Philharmonia Orchestra conducted by Carlo Maria Giulini, and that was recorded at the Royal Festival Hall in 1961. You mention quite often, Daniel, so many big names in music, and you've just talked about Rubinstein, but Fritz Busch, Toscanini, Richard Strauss, Stockowski, von Carrion. They all came to Buenos Aires when you were a boy. Why?
Daniel Barenboim
Because Buenos Aires was a very, very important opera theater in the world. And as the Second World War developed and parts of Europe were closed to the Jews and other parts of Europe were closed to the Nazis, Argentina seems to have been open to everybody.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Speaker 1
Mm-hmm.
Daniel Barenboim
you got the best of the German emigris, some of them not Jewish, like Erich Kleiber and Fritz Busch, who left Germany because they felt they could not make music in that stifling political climate.
Presenter
It was Fritz Bush, was it not, who persuaded your parents to let you do that? No, it was his.
Daniel Barenboim
No, it was his brother, Adolf Busch. Was it? His brother Adolf Busch, who was a a wonderful uh violinist. And he said to my father, You must make this boy play in public so that he has a normal contact with the public.
Presenter
Was it?
Daniel Barenboim
Does that
Daniel Barenboim
Only when I talk to you, so.
Presenter
Come on. Tell me some more about your father teaching you, because you've written that he always said to you you shouldn't do any scales, that this was to play mechanically, and as we know, your Wreath lectures have been a lot about that, that you should not play without thinking, without engaging your mind with that which you're playing. So are you advising any child learning the piano to say to their teacher, Do not run up and down the scales?
Daniel Barenboim
I wish it were as simple as that. It's not enough to say you don't have to play scales. You have to say what which he did. You don't have to play scales because you can find scales in any good piece of music. I remember the great uh Italian cellist Enrico Mainardi, he had great need to play scales scales in arpeggio on the cello, and he used to do that reading the newspaper.
Speaker 1
Hmm.
Presenter
It's just a finger exercise then, but it's not it's not making me.
Daniel Barenboim
Yeah.
Daniel Barenboim
But I'm fundamentally against that because I believe that if you do that, it will creep into your playing at the moment of a chorus concert and you won't be able to control it. And this is why I'm against against this type of practicing and of practicing longer than you are able to concentrate on.
Presenter
Record number two.
Daniel Barenboim
Record number two is the introduction to the last movement of Schumann's Fourth Symphony, a wonderful recording by the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra with Wilhelm Furtwengler. And I chose this record because Furtwengler to me symbolizes somebody who really articulated very profoundly the n very nature of music making.
Presenter
The introduction to the finale of Schumann's fourth symphony played by the Berlin Philharmonic conducted by Wilhelm Furtwengler in 1951, that recording of a live performance again. Uh but he's also I mean a very important name in your professional life Furtwengler because you played for him didn't you Daniel in Salzburg in nineteen fifty four you were eleven years old.
Daniel Barenboim
Yes.
Presenter
And it changed your life.
Daniel Barenboim
What helped me tremendously was he very kindly invited me to play with the Berlin Philharmonic after hearing me play in 1954, and my father thought that was too soon after the war for a Jewish boy to go to Berlin. It was the fact of going to Germany for a Jewish boy whose family had moved to Israel because this was supposed to be the homeland of the Jewish people, and to go only nine years after the end of the war to the very center of the Nazi empire really was something that was abhorrent to my parents and to me too as time went on.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Presenter
Uh
Presenter
But an incredible compliment to invite an eleven-year-old boy to play with a purple
Daniel Barenboim
Not only that, but my father explained to him the reasons why he could not accept uh the invitation and Footrenger was very understanding and gave me unsolicited or gave my parents a letter where he spoke in very positive terms about me.
Presenter
Well, he said Barren Bohm is a phenomenon.
Daniel Barenboim
Yeah, well anyway, and and that letter of course opened many doors. So, you are right, it did change my life.
Presenter
Do you still have the letter?
Daniel Barenboim
Yes.
Presenter
So yeah.
Presenter
Quite a valuable little document.
Daniel Barenboim
Yeah.
Presenter
Hmm.
Daniel Barenboim
Uh
Presenter
Yeah.
Daniel Barenboim
Record number three.
Presenter
Yeah.
Daniel Barenboim
Record number three is uh Clifford Curzon playing the last movement of uh Schubert's D major piano sonata.
Daniel Barenboim
There was something so lively and do you say felicious? Can you say that? Felicitous. Felicitous in his sound. And this has always been one of my favorite records.
Presenter
Clifford Curzon playing the beginning of the last movement of Schubert's D major sonata, originally recorded in the Snake Maltings in Alborough in nineteen sixty four. Um I gather that he had quite a uh an alarming temper, apparently, didn't like noise and got very fussed about.
Daniel Barenboim
Oh, he was yeah, he was a very fussy character. On one occasion we played in Manchester. I had been there for three weeks and he came to play my last concert.
Presenter
You were conducting.
Daniel Barenboim
You were conducting him? Yes. We found out to much our happiness that we were booked on the same train.
Daniel Barenboim
back to London the next day. And you can imagine my surprise. I who had been there for three weeks had one suitcase, but he who came for one afternoon had five.
Daniel Barenboim
including a silent keyboard. And off we took, and after about twenty minutes out of Manchester, there was an announcement on the train. And the announcement said with all passengers, please get off the train as soon as we stop at the next station. There's been a bomb alarm.
Daniel Barenboim
And there was a terrific rush of everybody panicking getting off the train. Not Clifford, who pulled down the windows and cried
Daniel Barenboim
Porter
Daniel Barenboim
Porter in this situation, he was trying to to get a porter to carry his bags, you know.
Daniel Barenboim
That was really Clifford Curzon in a nutshell outside of the music.
Presenter
We hear your impersonation of a very English accent there. I mean, your ear is such that not only do you speak many languages, but you can impersonate lots of regional accents. You've spent a lot of time with the Halle. You've got to give me a bit of Lancashire.
Daniel Barenboim
Oh no Right, I've lost it. I'll bring you a bunch of flowers. Janet Baker always used to say that. After concerts, we used to play concerts together and then, you know, she was in the half always trying to get out of the concert. He says, Where's my bunch of flowers?
Presenter
I'll
Daniel Barenboim
Janet, I hope you are listening to this.
Presenter
Record number four.
Daniel Barenboim
Record number four is a live performance of the Elgarcello concerto played by Jacqueline Dupre with Sir John Barbrolli live in Prague. I got it only about a year ago.
Daniel Barenboim
It was sent to me with a request from Lady Barbaroli whether I would agree to release it as a as a record. And my first reaction was no, why? And then I of course I listened to the recording and I was so struck by the quality of the performance. And it was a tour that took place in January 1967, very shortly after we met. And I remembered that she had told me what a wonderful performance it had been in Prague and how inspired she felt that Sir John had been and that she had been herself. And so of course I am very glad that the record was released.
Presenter
Jacqueline Dupre in a live performance in Prague in nineteen sixty seven playing the opening of Elgar's Cello Concerto with the BBC Symphony Orchestra conducted by Sir John Barbaroli.
Presenter
Jacqueline, to whom you were married actually here in Jerusalem, weren't you? In 1967.
Daniel Barenboim
But you can sit down.
Presenter
You'd met, as you say, at a party. Had you heard her play before you met her, or vice versa?
Daniel Barenboim
I had never heard her play live, no, I had heard recorded, but never heard her play right.
Presenter
So so you fell in love with the woman, not the musician, and it was in that order, was it?
Daniel Barenboim
No, because we played. We've we played before we talked.
Presenter
Oh, you di you made music before you talked?
Daniel Barenboim
Yes. It was at a friend's house, uh, we'd gone there to play chamber music. Hm. To eat as well. But probably to play chambered music and we played chamber music together and so this is how
Presenter
Hmm.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Daniel Barenboim
We got to know each other if you were to the music.
Presenter
And but did you you recognise her talent in that moment?
Daniel Barenboim
Oh yes, but uh you didn't have to be very bright to do that. The whole world recognized there was something completely unique about uh her being at one with the instrument and with the music. You never felt that uh you know she thought or she felt maybe it should the music should go this or that way. It simply was that.
Speaker 1
Mm.
Presenter
And your coming together made you a golden couple, didn't you? Didn't it? I mean, you were. It must have been.
Daniel Barenboim
Well she had the blonde hair.
Daniel Barenboim
I do
Presenter
I do. What color was yours then then? Brown.
Daniel Barenboim
Brown. What do you mean then?
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Well, yes. It's radio it's radio, so it doesn't matter, does it?
Speaker 1
It's radio it's radio, so it doesn't matter.
Presenter
But it is true you were girl. I mean, you were feted wherever you were. You were photographed with the Beatles. I mean, it was it must have been
Presenter
HEADY TIMES
Daniel Barenboim
Yes, but we I don't know, somehow we managed to live a very really simple life. But uh yes, of course, the public perception, you know, of this young couple, both talented and etcetera and it was not the case of uh playing together because one was very famous and sort of managed to convince everybody to engage the other one. It was something that uh we wanted and everybody wanted.
Presenter
And then a few years on multiple sclerosis set in. I mean, do what were the first signs? Do you remember what happened, how it happened, how it began to happen?
Daniel Barenboim
But she she was taken to a hospital a year and a half after we were married for some very minor surgery. And when she came out of the anesthesia, she had lost uh sensation in her hands and in her legs and that was the beginning.
Presenter
But you wouldn't have known at that point what it was.
Daniel Barenboim
Oh no, it took it took the well the cruelty about the illness is not only what it does, but that it took in her case, it took four and a half years to diagnose.
Presenter
But she was gradually getting worse and less able to. I mean, how soon did she stop have to stop playing?
Daniel Barenboim
Yeah.
Daniel Barenboim
She stopped playing for a year and then she started she played a little bit and then she stopped again and she played a last bunch of concerts in January, February of nineteen seventy three.
Presenter
So did you both
Daniel Barenboim
So she stopped playing before it was diagnosed.
Presenter
Really?
Daniel Barenboim
Oh yes. She was unable because she had lost all sense of uh of touch and therefore when she would pick up the bow she didn't know whether it weighed five kilos or five milligrams.
Presenter
I have
Presenter
So she couldn't feel it on the strings.
Daniel Barenboim
She couldn't feel it and she had the diff it was the first difficulties with with eating also.
Presenter
But if you didn't know what it was, I mean, she must have been in in turmoil. That's a that's
Daniel Barenboim
Best
Daniel Barenboim
Yep.
Presenter
She died after the
Daniel Barenboim
She died in eighty-seven, yes.
Presenter
Mm. Mm. And during that time you you cared for her, didn't you? And you
Presenter
looked after her financially and so on. But you began to live apart. You'd gone you'd taken the job the job with the Paris
Daniel Barenboim
Yeah.
Daniel Barenboim
Well, I was conductor of the Paris Orchestra and I was flying home to London uh at the beginning nearly every week, nearly every week.
Presenter
Straight up.
Presenter
Neither.
Presenter
But eventually you set up a another life in Paris, didn't you, with Jelena, who is now your wife, Bashkirova, who's sitting across the room from us. That's right.
Daniel Barenboim
Yes.
Speaker 3
That's right.
Presenter
It seems to me, reading about it, I mean, there was a kind of, for all of the best and most understandable and right reasons, there was a kind of press amnesty about that.
Daniel Barenboim
Yes, there was. There was. I not only f fell in love and started living with Elena, but we had two children to
Daniel Barenboim
We didn't hide them as it were, you know. But uh it was never mentioned in the press until after Jack is dead and so uh I'm I will always be very grateful for that.
Speaker 1
To the bike.
Presenter
Yeah.
Daniel Barenboim
Record number five.
Daniel Barenboim
The record number five is yet another live performance. And this one is of uh the Mendelssohn violin concerto played by Nathan Milstein and there was something very passionate and at the same time very elegant about his playings, not qualities that always go hand in hand. And Milstein for me somehow managed to put two qualities together in a way that made the violin the most sensuous and the most expressive instrument.
Presenter
Nathan Milstein playing the opening of Mendelssohn's violin concerto with the New York Philharmonic conducted by Bruno Walter and that was recorded in New York City in nineteen forty one.
Presenter
M
Presenter
You personally, and Pierre Boulez has pointed this out, unlike many classical musicians, have expanded rather than contracted in in your musical tastes over the years, and you began to very
Presenter
narrow, closed, conventional classical base, really, didn't you? But you've gone on to champion the likes, particularly in Chicago, of Bert Whistle and Elliott Carter and and Boulez himself. I wonder if you do that
Presenter
Because you feel but for an intellectual reason rather than uh a reason of taste.
Daniel Barenboim
No, curiosity, I was thinking is more the more correct word. And in fact, I think uh we have to thank Pierre Boulez that he made this music uh accessible, first of all by playing it, and secondly, by playing it with such a degree of clarity and transparency. And that opened a whole new vista for me. And it gave
Presenter
But did you easily move into it? I mean, it is so different. It's so alienating, really, to the conventionally trained ear.
Daniel Barenboim
The music that interests me today is the music written by composers who first of all hear what they write and are not only using it as an intellectual exercise. And also composers that you feel that they have a knowledge of what has come before them. And remember, you know, that it only needed one Christopher Columbus to discover America and that many people behave since then as if they have done so, but it was already done. And this is the difference between Boulet's and Eliot Carter's music and so many other composers today. Record number six.
Daniel Barenboim
The next record is an excerpt of uh Suran Sis by Pierre Boulez, a work of great uh sonic imagination and it is not only deeply thought and or deeply felt, but a real kaleidoscopic pleasure for the ear.
Presenter
An extract from Pierre Boulet's Surancise for three pianos, three harps and three percussion instruments. Daniel, you've become a very controversial figure here in Israel, the right wing here.
Presenter
um disapprove deeply.
Presenter
of your championship of the Palestinian cause as they see it. You've talked about this situation and this place.
Presenter
preoccupying you. I mean you've you've said that kind of thing in connection with the orchestra that you've set up, the West Eastern Divan Orchestra, which you set up with the uh the late Palestinian intellectual Edward Saeed, uh an orchestra made up of both Israelis and um young Israelis and and and and young Palestinians and other Arabs.
Presenter
I mean, are you seeking there by that to set an example? Are you saying to the politicians, look at this, be this is what can be done?
Daniel Barenboim
Well, first of all, this is not a political project. And I perceive that you must be aware that when I say people sli smile benevolently.
Presenter
I know, and you always see that.
Presenter
But isn't it disingenuous to say it's not political? Because it is setting an example, isn't it?
Daniel Barenboim
No.
Daniel Barenboim
If you call that political, yes, I refrain from calling it political because we don't want political approval, we don't have no contacts with any governments, none whatsoever. But it is a project which recognizes what to us, to Edward Said and to me, are inevitable conclusions. The first one being that the destinies of the Israelis and the Palestinians are inextricably linked, whether we like it or not. And secondly, that there is no military solution to the conflict. It gives us the weapons to fight what we consider one of the worst elements in this conflict, and that is ignorance.
Speaker 1
Mm-hmm.
Presenter
Mechanical number seven.
Daniel Barenboim
Uh record number seven is um Edwin Fischer playing the C-sharp major prelude from book two of Bach's Well-Tempered Clavier. Uh he became an example for me because he was the main propagator, if you want, if it can be expressed in this way, of the art of playing and conducting simultaneously. He was both a pianist and a conductor and he played and conducted Mozart concertos when I was a child and that's where I got the example.
Presenter
Edwin Fisher playing the C sharp major prelude from Bach's well tempered clavier Book Two, and that was recorded in the mid thirties and is considered, I think, to be the earliest complete performance on record.
Daniel Barenboim
Very well possible, yeah.
Presenter
You've recorded it yourself, of course, book one and book two, and you've performed that recently in Paris and in London.
Presenter
You're giving up Chicago, as I said, this summer. You're 64 later this year. I mean, does this mean you're going to return to the piano much more? You're going to stop the commuting.
Presenter
Get off the podium more often.
Presenter
and get them sit down at the piano.
Daniel Barenboim
I would like to play more. You know, when I took on directorship of the State Opera in Berlin, I was already music director in Chicago. And I knew that I could only do that for a certain amount of time,'cause otherwise I would have to stop playing the piano'cause I didn't didn't have enough time to practice and to to keep the manual aspect of of playing
Speaker 1
Mm.
Presenter
How much do you worry about that? I mean, I think that
Daniel Barenboim
I don't worry about that, but I knew that I could only do that for a certain amount of time and I said ten years.
Presenter
But tell me about the fingers. When they're nearly 64 years old, do they get stiff? Do you worry that they'll get stiff? Is there any arthritis in there?
Daniel Barenboim
Absolutely not.
Presenter
They're as supple as ever, I think.
Daniel Barenboim
Absolutely not. But you know the muscles at uh sik I'm sixty-three only, you can't see.
Presenter
Sixty four at the end of this year.
Daniel Barenboim
But it's at the end of the year. We're all in April, you know, I mean, really. But obviously the muscles at sixty three I can't speak about sixty four because I'm not there yet. It it's far too far away for me to even envisage what that might feel like. But at sixty three the muscles obviously don't work like when at thirty, let alone at fifteen or twenty, you know. And um I find that I need more time to get myself in shape.
Speaker 1
I'm not there yet.
Speaker 1
Um
Presenter
Hmm.
Daniel Barenboim
to play the piano, especially after I haven't played for a while.
Presenter
And what about your health in general? Because there have been reports in the newspapers earlier this year that you had to cancel a couple of concerts and you weren't very well. Do you
Presenter
worry I mean, you you are a man who leads life, you know, to the full. I mean, I've seen you smoking the cigars.
Presenter
I mean, do you worry about that? Do you
Daniel Barenboim
No. No, I don't worry about it. And my health is absolutely perfect. I had um committed, if you want the the stupidity not to have a medical checkup for fifteen years, which you shouldn't do uh at my age, sixty three.
Presenter
Definitely. Three I'll remember that.
Daniel Barenboim
And you know and I found myself with a very high uh blood pressure and was taken to the hospital with that. But I feel now for over two weeks absolutely in perfect.
Presenter
So you're not going to slow down at all, are you? I mean
Daniel Barenboim
Yes, I might do less interviews.
Presenter
Tell me about the last piece of music then and we'll get this one over. Come on.
Daniel Barenboim
Well, the last record is the D major fugue from book one of the Well-Tempered Clavier, played on the harpsichord by Vanderlandowska, because that shows you that it can be stylistically very free and very grand and has the ability to have so much more color than most harpsichord players manage to get today, even if it is stylistically not according to the rules that we imagine existed in Bach's time.
Daniel Barenboim
As you can see, this harpsichord playing has nothing to do with this wonderfully witty description of the harpsichord sound ascribed to Sir Thomas Beacham, who is claimed to have said that he hated the harpsichord because it reminded him of the sound of two cats copulating on a tin roof.
Presenter
Well, there it was, the harpsichord, and that was Vanderlandowska playing it. She's playing the
Presenter
The D major few from book one of the Park's Well Tempered Clavier. That was recorded in 1954. You might like to know that. I have three more questions for you. One is if you could only take one of those eight records to this desert island, which one would it be?
Daniel Barenboim
But I have to be very honest with you, uh Sue, I wouldn't take any records of the desert island. I would take scores that I can read there, but I wouldn't take any of these records. I only did this out of politeness to you, because this is what the program is about. But basically, I enjoy more reading the scores than listening to records.
Presenter
All right. We
Presenter
We give you the complete works of Shakespeare. I don't know if you want those either. We give you the Bible, but we also allow you one book of your own choice. Which would that be?
Presenter
A book to read.
Daniel Barenboim
This is a very difficult one, you know, because if I go by statistics, the book that I have looked at most in the last fifty years of my life, and I'm only sixty three,
Daniel Barenboim
Is the e ethics of Spinoza?
Presenter
Okay. And last question. We give you one luxury, which should be of no practical value. You can't have a boat to escape or anything like that. Just
Presenter
Well, it's your piano, isn't it? It's your piano?
Daniel Barenboim
The piano is not a luxury. But give me a piano and a mattress that I can put on it to sleep.
Daniel Barenboim
Why not?
Presenter
Daniel Barrenbohm, thank you very much indeed for letting us hear your desert island iscs.
Daniel Barenboim
Thank you.
Speaker 3
You've been listening to a podcast from the Desert Island Discs archive. For more podcasts, please visit bbc.co.uk slash radio four.
Are you advising any child learning the piano to say to their teacher, Do not run up and down the scales?
I wish it were as simple as that. It's not enough to say you don't have to play scales. You have to say what which he did. You don't have to play scales because you can find scales in any good piece of music. ... I'm fundamentally against that because I believe that if you do that, it will creep into your playing at the moment of a chorus concert and you won't be able to control it.
Presenter asks
Had you heard [Jacqueline du Pré] play before you met her, or vice versa?
I had never heard her play live, no, I had heard recorded, but never heard her play right.
Presenter asks
Are you seeking there by [the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra] to set an example? Are you saying to the politicians, look at this, this is what can be done?
Well, first of all, this is not a political project. ... it is a project which recognizes what to us, to Edward Said and to me, are inevitable conclusions. The first one being that the destinies of the Israelis and the Palestinians are inextricably linked, whether we like it or not. And secondly, that there is no military solution to the conflict. It gives us the weapons to fight what we consider one of the worst elements in this conflict, and that is ignorance.
Presenter asks
Do you worry that [your fingers] will get stiff? Is there any arthritis in there?
Absolutely not. ... But obviously the muscles at sixty three I can't speak about sixty four because I'm not there yet. ... I find that I need more time to get myself in shape ... to play the piano, especially after I haven't played for a while.
“I was a child prodigy, and there you see here I am today, the prodigy is gone and the child has remained.”
“I believe that if you do [mechanical practice], it will creep into your playing at the moment of a chorus concert and you won't be able to control it. And this is why I'm against against this type of practicing and of practicing longer than you are able to concentrate on.”
“I wouldn't take any records of the desert island. I would take scores that I can read there, but I wouldn't take any of these records. I only did this out of politeness to you, because this is what the program is about. But basically, I enjoy more reading the scores than listening to records.”