Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Sue Lawley
A literary critic and professor of English at London and Cambridge, one of the most influential critics and teachers of his age.
Eight records
L'Allegro, il Penseroso ed il Moderato
Michael Ginn, English Baroque Soloists, conducted by John Eliot Gardiner
I first heard it sixty years ago in the Isle of Man ... Michael Ginn or Ginn is a boy soprano, and I was a boy soprano. And so altogether it seemed to me a suitable way to start the list.
Impromptu in A-flat major, D. 899 No. 4
The next record, like some of the others that I'd chosen, has to stand as a symbol of a great deal of other music, the whole of Schubert's piano music in fact. But all I could choose was one short piece. And I've always particularly admired the way Clifford Curzon played this impromptu.
Edita Gruberová, Robert Holl, Wiener Symphoniker, conducted by Nikolaus Harnoncourt
what they don't know because it's very often omitted, I think, in amateur performances, is the wonderful duet between Adam and Eve towards the end of the oratorio, which is sort of the finest, sort of most radiant celebration of unspoilt married love that you could possibly find in music, I think.
Lella Cuberli, Cecilia Bartoli, John Tomlinson, Berlin Philharmonic, conducted by Daniel Barenboim
A representative again of Mozart's operas which are truly important to me and I think Cosifantute is possibly the most beautiful opera ever written. So it's very difficult to pick a piece of it that will have to stand for all the rest. However, this wonderful little trio from the first act will have to serve.
Charlotte Margiono, Barbara Bonney
I I didn't know what to choose from Figaro. The obvious choice would be Susannah's wonderful ara in the last act, but this little letter song sung by the Countess and Susanna in Act Three will remind me of all the rest.
Gottes Zeit ist die allerbeste Zeit, BWV 106 (Actus Tragicus)Favourite
Teresa Stich-Randall, Vienna State Opera Orchestra and Chorus, conducted by Felix Prohaska
the actus tragicus is a wonderful uh uh cantata about death. Uh I've sung in it and loved it for a great many years, but I th the it has of course many times been recorded, but the recording that we're going to use here seems to be the most beautiful of them, partly because of the exquisite singing of Teresa Stitch Randall.
Piano Sonata No. 32 in C minor, Op. 111
Really, I suppose I chose it again as a representative, but also because it is the last part of Beethoven's last sonata, the sort of general idea of lastness creeping in here.
Elisabeth Schumann, Maria Olczewska, Vienna Philharmonic, conducted by Robert Heger
this is a lovely moment, I think, from De Rose and Cavalier, the presentation of the Silver Rose. And just for old time's sake, I've asked you to do the recording by Elizabeth Schumann, made in 1933, which was the first one I ever heard.
The keepsakes
The book
The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire
Edward Gibbon
I thought it had to be a very long book. Um, probably a book that I ought to have read by now and haven't, like Gibbon's Decline and Fall. So I just I voted for Gibbon.
The luxury
Moonlit Landscape with Sheep by Samuel Palmer
I imagine what I would like is something very beautiful. ... I decided to ask you to persuade the trustees of the Tate Gallery to part with a painting by Samuel Palmer called Moonlit Landscape with Sheep. I'll settle for that.
In conversation
Presenter asks
Do you suggest in your autobiographical writings that you've been rather blown about through life, like tumbleweed?
Well, that is true. I have sort of drifted about uh mostly within the university system in this country and in the United States. I've never stayed longer than eight years in any job, and that's very unusual in an academic profession. And I can't really explain it, a kind of natural a quickness to be bored with whatever one's got.
Presenter asks
Did you then decide that you wouldn't be a writer?
Well, I knew I wasn't uh any more than I was a singer or a violinist or anything else, so I I fell back on criticism, I suppose you want to say.
Presenter asks
In the war you learned to deal with the madness of captains. Can you explain that?
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 3
Hello, I'm Kirsty Young, and this is a podcast from the Desert Island Discs Archive. For rights reasons we've had to shorten the music. The programme was originally broadcast in nineteen ninety seven, and the presenter was Sue Lawley.
Presenter
My Castaway this week is a critic. He was born in 1919 on the Isle of Man, and grew up a clever, introverted boy in that remote and insular part of the United Kingdom. After university and wartime service in the Navy, he went into academic life, becoming one of the most influential critics and teachers of his age, and serving as professor of English at both London and Cambridge universities. Anyone who's studied English literature, however briefly, has probably heard of him. But he remains disenchanted by his eminence. Looking the part, while not being quite equal to it, seems to be something I do rather well, he says. He is Sir Frank Kermode.
Presenter
Professor Commode, I I suspect most um men and women of achievement feel like that, that they're not quite all they're cracked up to being. Isn't that all you're saying, really? Or is it something more than that?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, no, I think I would certainly agree that uh that puts the case for me. I wouldn't like to judge it for other people. I dare say it would be very pleasant to be convinced that one was uh exceedingly bright and worthy of all the attention one got.
Presenter
But you you you suggest in your autobiographical writings that that that you've been rather blown about through life, that you're rather like tumbleweed, you fetched up in these places, although they've been very eminent. They are a very eminent places.
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, that is true. I have sort of drifted about uh
Sir Frank Kermode
mostly within the university system in this country and in the United States. I've never stayed longer than eight years in any job, and that's very unusual in an academic profession. And I can't really explain it, a kind of natural a quickness to be bored with whatever one's got. That's usually the explanation. Other explanations, of course, are quarrelling with people. But what else might you
Presenter
But what else might you have been?
Sir Frank Kermode
And my ma
Presenter
Uh
Sir Frank Kermode
Yeah.
Sir Frank Kermode
I don't know. I I used to think I might have been a musician. Uh there was no evidence that I could ever have been a musician. I was extremely untalented uh at everything musical that I tried.
Presenter
You tried the violin, I think.
Sir Frank Kermode
Tried violin, tried the clarinet.
Sir Frank Kermode
And uh I had no particular gift. In fact, I had an the obverse of a gift to the clarinet.
Presenter
But I mean, to be clear, we're not just talking about your your professional career here. I mean, again, you've talked about when you've written about your life as a sailor in the war and as a husband and as a father, and if I can quote you to yourself, you talk about failures and half failures as a husband and father, academic mistakes, and much time and spirit wasted in epochs of unease.
Sir Frank Kermode
I think when you write about yourself, you know, you uh if you are a writer, you tend to uh let the book write you in a sense. There's an example. That sentence is obviously chiseled out as a very good sentence. That may have more weight than its actual content.
Presenter
Oh really? So it was you were writing rather than telling the truth?
Sir Frank Kermode
And I think that must be so. I think what what what's difficult to understand about autobiographies is that w what you're writing is about now. You're not writing about the past at all. You're really writing about the moment at which you're writing.
Presenter
And your perception of the poem.
Sir Frank Kermode
Yes, and and and it's how you feel at that moment somehow. I mean if you feel like producing a good sentence, you do.
Presenter
We shall explore. But but tell me about your first piece of music, because as you've indicated, music is uh has played a not inconsiderable part in your life.
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, I chose this part of Handel's L'Alegro et Il Penzaroso, partly because, strangely enough, I first heard it sixty years ago in the Isle of Man, which you might not, from your opening remarks, have thought to be a place where you would hear unusual music played. But in fact, I did hear it and I remembered it ever since. It's now become very celebrated because of the Colosseum performances recently. I also chose this bit of it because Michael Ginn or Ginn is a boy soprano, and I was a boy soprano. And so altogether it seemed to me a suitable way to start the list.
Speaker 4
If I give thee honour due, both I'd be tree of thy crew.
Speaker 4
Oh, thou beat me all thy crew.
Speaker 4
O Lord be me of the King, thus admit me.
Presenter
Michael Ginn singing part of Handel's L'Alegro edil Pensoroso with the English Baroque Soloists conducted by John Elliott Gardner.
Presenter
So, Frank Kermod, you sang in the choir as a boy. Was there music in the house? Did you have a gramophone or radio?
Sir Frank Kermode
Yes, we had we had a gramophone of the kind with the big horn on it. Uh
Sir Frank Kermode
And radio, I think my father built one of the first radios in the Isle of Man, in fact, yeah, in the very, very early days. And there again we had to listen through a horn, you had to put your ear in the horn.
Presenter
And what did it play to you, do you remember?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, it played. That's where I first heard uh um promenade concerts, for example, which were very important to me in my youth. They weren't interesting to my family, but they were to me.
Presenter
But you weren't apparently the um the son that your father wanted you to be, or you felt you were.
Sir Frank Kermode
I think he was baffled by me really because I couldn't do anything. Even th all the things that he thought boys and men should be able to do, I was quite unable to tackle.
Presenter
What sport?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, I did play well, not very well. Well, of course, he didn't like me for not being able to play very well because he could.
Sir Frank Kermode
He no, he just thought I was sort of so hopelessly impractical, which indeed I was and am. It's not going to be very good on the island now.
Presenter
And what about books in the family? Were what any books that they have?
Sir Frank Kermode
Very few, very few. Some my mother was interested in s poetry and particularly in the the local poet T E Brown, the first poet I ever read or was or had read to me. Nobody bothers about him any more either.
Presenter
And did you then have a a a feeling and again it's something you've written about that this this sense of of not belonging then, of being in the wrong place?
Sir Frank Kermode
Yeah, well I I think I've always had that. Uh and of course there was a good deal about my life as a child that wasn't miserable. Uh on the other hand, there was a good deal that was. And there was always I always had a sense, I think, that I would have to leave.
Sir Frank Kermode
Uh home.
Sir Frank Kermode
And I always had that sense. That's why I've moved about so much actually.
Presenter
But but England was a foreign country.
Sir Frank Kermode
England was a foreign country, uh I mean uh w we the the best uh the only visits we ever paid were day trips to Liverpool.
Presenter
Tell me about your next record.
Sir Frank Kermode
The next record, like some of the others that I'd chosen, has to stand as a symbol of a great deal of other music, the whole of Schubert's piano music in fact. But all I could choose was one short piece. And I've always particularly admired the way Clifford Curzon played this impromptu.
Presenter
The house
Presenter
Clifford Curzon playing part of Schubert's impromptu in A Flat Major.
Presenter
By the sound of it then you emerged, as it were, blinking into the world when you arrived in Liverpool. Humming City, was it?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, it was a lively place, and the university was a lively place. Quite lively enough for me.
Presenter
Hmm.
Sir Frank Kermode
Yeah.
Presenter
Certainly livelier than anything you've known.
Sir Frank Kermode
Yeah.
Presenter
And and the Philemonic Hall, I think.
Sir Frank Kermode
That was important, yes. I sold tickets there. Not I mean, I showed people to their seats or sold programmes there, and therefore got in for nothing.
Presenter
But what about people? I mean, they must have been so everything must have been a revelation to you after this rather cloistered
Sir Frank Kermode
It was. Even even the trains looked enormous. It was uh it was uh a very strange transformation. Of course it did me good and I I think uh I flourished as an undergraduate.
Presenter
Did you did you then, for one small moment, feel you were in the right place?
Sir Frank Kermode
Yes, I think I did. I did understand, however, that all these other people were far more sophisticated, smarter than I was.
Presenter
But at some point during this time, anyway, a few years on into Liverpool, you wrote your first book, didn't you? A study of a man called Aaron Hill. Had you tried by this stage writing a novel or a publication?
Sir Frank Kermode
Yes, I had. I was uh very busy. I wrote plays and novels that are all no good. And so of course I gave gave up doing it.
Presenter
Did people tell you they were no good?
Sir Frank Kermode
No, I didn't give them a chance.
Presenter
Did you then decide that you wouldn't be a writer? That you
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, I knew I wasn't uh any more than I was a singer or a violinist or anything else, so I I fell back on criticism, I suppose you want to say.
Presenter
But have you perhaps thought since then that that was the wrong decision?
Sir Frank Kermode
I had I mean wr writing that the book you've been quoting from was fun because it was uh not constricted by the usual uh conditions of writing, academic criticism or reviews, which I do a great deal of, you know. And so it was that was more fun to write than anything else I've ever written, I suppose. You're also good. And so perhaps I should have done more of it.
Presenter
You're also
Presenter
But not just for that reason, but because it's actually the the writing itself, apart from the content, has been much praised by distinguished writers themselves, you know, David Lodge, John Updike. Perhaps you were too hard on yourself.
Sir Frank Kermode
But
Sir Frank Kermode
I think I should have I should have let go a little earlier, yes.
Presenter
Do you know, but do you really feel it?
Sir Frank Kermode
I do think that, uh, yes.
Presenter
That you could have done some creative writing.
Sir Frank Kermode
I think I might, yes. I don't think I'd ever be a good novelist'cause I'm not very good at noticing things. Uh or indeed getting on with people, uh knowing people is a difficult thing.
Presenter
But you don't have to get on with people or know people to write creatively. I mean, you you just have to be imaginative.
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, you have to have a certain amount of know-how about how human beings behave and interact, and I don't think I have much of that.
Presenter
Record number three.
Sir Frank Kermode
Record number three is from the creation, which I think is a lovely work and everybody knows a lot of it, I think. But what they don't know because it's very often omitted, I think, in amateur performances, is the wonderful duet between Adam and Eve towards the end of the oratorio, which is sort of the finest, sort of most radiant celebration of unspoilt married love that you could possibly find in music, I think. Of course it didn't last very long. I think it was all over about a day later, wasn't it?
Speaker 4
Alright.
Speaker 4
Uh
Presenter
Editor Gruberova as Eve and Robert Hull as Adam, singing part of Haydn's creation with the Vienna Symphonic conducted by Nicolas Anancour.
Presenter
You've um written, Professor Kermod, that in the war you learned to deal with the madness of captains. Can you explain that?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, I had a rather strange war. I think it's quite I I never met anybody else who had uh a similar experience, but I did find myself acting as secretary to people who were crazy and drunk a lot of the time. And uh
Sir Frank Kermode
I think I learned a lot from this.
Presenter
You were the kind of ship scribe when
Sir Frank Kermode
Yes, I was the I was the captain's secretary and uh f for the longest time when we were anchored in a fjord in Iceland I had to deal with this maniac uh who turned out to be uh actually a rather selfish maniac as he was accumulating stores for sale on the black market when he got home.
Presenter
But they weren't just mad, these captains. I mean, they they did ridiculous things like shooting themselves. I mean, a lot of them died or fell down.
Sir Frank Kermode
Another fell down a flight of stairs. Their antics were unbelievable and but not so surprising to more seasoned seafarers than I. I mean, they rather expected a lot of this from captains.
Presenter
And you spent, it seems, um, a good part of the war, two and a half years, I think, trying to put a boom across a an Icelandic
Sir Frank Kermode
Nice.
Sir Frank Kermode
Yes, for two years we tried to lay a boom across a fjord in in Iceland.
Presenter
Yeah, as we
Sir Frank Kermode
I think it was in fact an impossible task.
Presenter
And you failed.
Sir Frank Kermode
And we failed, and
Presenter
Mm.
Sir Frank Kermode
And having wasted vast quantities of material, all sunk at the bottom of the field.
Presenter
It does sound quite incredibly absurd.
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, it's all part of the d you know the the element of sheer craziness in in war is well i i it's forgotten. I mean we know it's terrible and that millions of people get killed, but the silliness is quite extraordinary too. But I do think my experience was a bit freakish. I've been talking of late to some uh American friends who were fighter pilots in the Pacific and they really, you know, flying from carriers, they had a totally different kind of war. They were really mixed up in uh world-changing battles and so on. Not messing about on the fringes that me.
Presenter
But when you signed up, you were full of expectation, weren't you? You you thought you were going to change the world.
Sir Frank Kermode
I'm not so sure about that. You know, the summer of nineteen fourteen was such a peculiar time when it is perfectly possible that by autumn we would have been occupied by Germany. So in fact nothing seemed very serious at the time. You thought what you might do in the circumstances. And one of the things I mean she in a way going to sea seemed rather a good idea.
Presenter
Record number four.
Sir Frank Kermode
Record number four.
Sir Frank Kermode
Uh is
Sir Frank Kermode
A representative again of Mozart's operas which are truly important to me and I think Cosifantute is possibly the most beautiful opera ever written. So it's very difficult to pick a piece of it that will have to stand for all the rest. However, this wonderful little trio from the first act will have to serve.
Speaker 4
God's wait.
Speaker 4
So
Speaker 4
I wish we could.
Presenter
Part of Suave Si Ilvento from Mozart's Cousifan Tute, sung by Leila Kubelli, Cecilia Bartoli, and John Tomlinson with the Berlin Philharmonic conducted by Daniel Barenboim.
Presenter
So too um academia, Frank Kermode. Um you've written about looking up from reading a poem in a lecture theatre and seeing faces gleaming with the experience of poetry. How often did that happen?
Sir Frank Kermode
Not very often, I don't think. I I I think that as I
Presenter
Yeah.
Sir Frank Kermode
In fact, in my retirement, I've been teaching a good deal and doing it very differently from the way I used to do it, because I think now what one does is get a group of people together round a table and bury them in some poems. And the hell with all this nonsense about the intellectual background and so on. We just read poems together. And this is when it's taken me a long time to find this out, you'll agree. This is when something actually there's a transaction of some importance between the teacher and the taught, which you don't get in the rather stiff situation of the of the university lecture system which has been so dominant in our academic tradition.
Presenter
So it it's that moment of something understood is
Sir Frank Kermode
That's right, that's right. And o also I I believe people uh are interested and surprised sometimes to find that there is quite a heavy technical aspect to good poetry, which they've tended not to be told about in the past.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
But but what has happened to the teaching of English in our universities over the past twenty five years, as you just indicated, is that that something different occurred, that something that some would say legislated against that something understood, because the and I I get into deep water here, but so you'll have to help me, but the the new literary theory which you helped in many ways introduce
Presenter
Um
Presenter
Did, as I say, well, define it for me, if you will, first of all.
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, this was really this kind of uh major change came over the theoretical aspects of of literary criticism in the 1960s. I I won't specify them, it would be very boring to do so, but mostly they originated in Paris. And they seemed to me at that time extremely interesting, uh but of course what's happened to them is what what happened in the past to other uh nostrums for for literary criticism and philological what's happened is that it they it has taken attention away from the texts themselves, so that people are now much more interested in refining theoretical positions which are totally out of touch with literary texts.
Presenter
So that the study of the linguistics or the social conditions in which the piece was written.
Presenter
Become so analyzed and so studied that the value is in that analysis itself and ceases to be in the literature, as it were.
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, that's right. That's right. I mean, even that degree of contact with the text is sometimes uh given up altogether. I I've had very good students who've said they're really only taking courses in literature in order to get out of it and and study what they now call theory. Theory in with a capital T, which is not literary theory anymore. It's theory of everything. And fine, as long as we can still have some people who are susceptible to the effect of good literature, particularly of poetry.
Speaker 4
Given up
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
You must, or or perhaps you don't. Do you feel a little guilty that you helped bring all of this in, as it were, because you had a ringside seat. You were very active.
Sir Frank Kermode
I did. I I did, I suppose. Well, I was that was when I was in London. No, since then I've really become I've I've uh in politics I've never taken the the track from left to right which is supposed to happen, but I have in this respect, and and I'll spend a good deal of time giving lectures denouncing this this business.
Presenter
Uh
Presenter
Next record.
Sir Frank Kermode
I I didn't know what to choose from Figaro. The obvious choice would be Susannah's wonderful ara in the last act, but this little letter song sung by the Countess and Susanna in Act Three will remind me of all the rest.
Speaker 4
Sungly gifts from the sketch.
Speaker 4
Somebody who scared me.
Presenter
Charlotte Margiono and Barbara Bonnie, singing part of the duet from Act Three of Mozart's Marriage of Figaro. Um there have been various moments in your career, Frank Hermode, when you've found yourself hitting the headlines, and on each occasion I suspect you'd rather not have done. Um the most recent was last autumn when you moved house in Cambridge and boxes of your books were taken away and pulped by refuse collectors. What what exactly, first of all, did you lose?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, I lost uh a lot of irreplaceable uh things, um some manuscripts, uh not my own manuscripts, for example I lost uh a manuscript which had been given me some years ago by Stephen Spender, uh which is a valuable manuscript, that was destroyed. But a great many books, about two thousand books in fact, were destroyed, and this this takes the heart out of a library. Uh unfortunately the boxes that were destroyed all came from the room where I kept my best books. And anyway, it's a sad tale. But how did it happen? But it's a typical piece of these idiocies invade my life. It happened a confusion between removal men and and uh garbage collectors.
Presenter
But how did it happen?
Sir Frank Kermode
I I still go to the my shelves for a book and know and then discover that it isn't there. And of course I now learnt that the the the dam the area which is most devastated, you know, I know not to look. And I and I'm trying slowly to replace the
Presenter
It's one of those.
Presenter
Another headline hitting moment was back in the sixties when you co-edited the magazine Encounter and and were m misled about the magazine's CIA connections. You were you were duped, really, weren't you?
Sir Frank Kermode
Yeah, so
Presenter
Top and the bottom of it.
Sir Frank Kermode
Even
Presenter
You've admitted as much.
Presenter
You seem to be quite du dupable, if I
Presenter
If there is such a word, and if I can make that observation, do you feel you are?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, I don't know. I think in in a a rather long life by now one learns to suss out some of the more obvious attempts to swindle. But uh I I think circumstances have been such and perhaps my basic naivete is such that you're right in what you say. I won't deny it.
Presenter
That that that you
Presenter
Usually tend to believe people when they say something. If they appear to be decent and amiable, you believe what they say.
Sir Frank Kermode
Exactly.
Sir Frank Kermode
Yeah.
Sir Frank Kermode
Yes, I want to please them, and I please them by pretending I believe them, or actually believe them.
Presenter
Blackwood number six.
Sir Frank Kermode
Well reckon number six is uh the actus tragicus is a wonderful uh uh cantata about death. Uh I've sung in it and loved it for a great many years, but I th the it has of course many times been recorded, but the recording that we're going to use here seems to be the most beautiful of them, partly because of the exquisite singing of Teresa Stitch Randall.
Speaker 4
Your maze of the music is a little bit more.
Speaker 4
He's over.
Speaker 4
And babies are for me.
Speaker 4
Finger.
Speaker 4
Let's see which part.
Presenter
Part of the Actus Tragicus from Bach's cantata BWV one oh six sung by Theresa Stitch Randall with the Vienna State Opera Orchestra and Chorus conducted by Felix Proasca.
Presenter
Um and so to Cambridge you went in nineteen seventy three, which was to be your last full-time post. You became King Edward the Seventh Professor of English Literature.
Presenter
But you didn't have a secretary, and you didn't have an office, and you were forbidden to give tutorials. I mean did did nobody tell you this was how it was going to be?
Sir Frank Kermode
Uh well I did people did in fact. I remember Lord Annan telling me that uh I should rapidly rethink the position before I took it up.
Sir Frank Kermode
But I did go, and I should have found out more about you. I don't think people were positively unkind. Cambridge is k i where I live and which I like very much, can also be a very chilly place, uh, moral and socially, and I guess perhaps morally too, I'm not sure about that.
Presenter
But worse than that, wasn't it? I mean, again, let me quote yourself to yourself A cauldron of unholy hates hissed about me.
Sir Frank Kermode
Tissed about me.
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, that's meant to be a joke based on Saint Augustine's remark that when you got to Carthage a cauldron of unholy loves rates all about him. That was a very odd time that first year at Cambridge because they'd set up everything for the f for the following year. They'd given I had no place in any of the plans. And of course I'd been used to something quite different, having been head of department for something like fifteen years before I went there. I thought I would actually have something to say in the way things were done, but I had none at all. And so I was a little bit f to find that one hasn't an an office even, that was very surprising, let alone a secretary. All the time I was at Cambridge I wrote all my own letters, either typed them or wrote them by hand.
Presenter
It uh it all finally came to a head nearly a a a decade later, really, didn't it, when you championed a young Don called Colin McCabe, said then to be a a structuralist, someone who who who believed in this new theory.
Sir Frank Kermode
Said then.
Sir Frank Kermode
But he
Presenter
whom the faculty wouldn't give a job and and the result was in the end you went, you resigned, but effectively you were finally forced out, weren't you?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, I I simply got so fed up with it all. I was also not very well. I had very
Sir Frank Kermode
bad eye troubles at the time and there were all sorts of reasons why it seemed a very cosy thing just to to pack it in so I did.
Presenter
But it was all, wasn't it, campus politics at their most ruthless or
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, they were they were, in fact. Yes, that that is quite true. And I'm you you you have to give your heart and mind to that kind of thing to succeed, I think. I'm never willing to do that.
Presenter
Record number seven.
Sir Frank Kermode
A record number seven is the the
Sir Frank Kermode
Really, I suppose I chose it again as a representative, but also because it is the last part of Beethoven's last sonata, the sort of general idea of lastness creeping in here.
Presenter
Alfred Brendel playing part of the Arietta from Beethoven's Piano Sonata, number thirty two.
Presenter
So you still live in Cambridge, although you haven't taught in the faculty since you resigned?
Speaker 4
Yeah.
Presenter
You you live alone now and again, you've written like Tristram Shandy, you sleep diagonally in your bed. Yeah.
Sir Frank Kermode
Yeah, that's
Presenter
Do you enjoy your solitary state?
Sir Frank Kermode
For the most part, yes. Uh um it's it's softened by um friends and um people come to stay sometimes. No, I I'd rather I mean I've very I'd rather be like uh Adam and Eve in the creation, but I'm not. I'm Adam before uh his rib was removed.
Presenter
But do you feel now at last that maybe you're you're you're at the right table as opposed to the wrong one? That that is to say your own table by yourself? Is that?
Sir Frank Kermode
Yes, it's a it's a wonderfully um free life. Uh all I have to occupy me is work, really. And so then it it's as if work had taken the place of pleasure.
Sir Frank Kermode
No, and company. So I do work hard, not because I feel any need to, but because there's nothing else to do, really.
Presenter
But what conclusion then do you come to ab about yourself if we're following this theme about your having been always in slightly the wrong place? I mean, perhaps, you know, that was your role. Perhaps you are you are an outsider, is that what you're meant to be?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, in a sense I am, yes, I think. Uh although it seems silly to say so when I've had so many allegiances and associations, but um on the whole I think I'm really better off now than I've ever been before.
Presenter
Tell me about your last record.
Sir Frank Kermode
The last records as far as I venture into the 20th century. I'd have chosen many more, but this is a lovely moment, I think, from De Rose and Cavalier, the presentation of the Silver Rose. And just for old time's sake, I've asked you to do the recording by Elizabeth Schumann, made in 1933, which was the first one I ever heard.
Speaker 4
Oh, I didn't mean
Presenter
Elizabeth Schumann as Sophia, and Maria Olsevska as Octavian, singing the duet The Presentation of the Rose from the second act of Der Rosencavalier by Richard Strauss, with the Vienna Philharmonic conducted by Robert Hager, and that was recorded in september nineteen forty three.
Presenter
Now, if you could only take one of those eight records.
Sir Frank Kermode
Oh, it would have to be the uh Bach, I think, the actus tragicus.
Presenter
And what about a book as well as the Bible and Shakespeare?
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, book I thought about this. I thought it had to be a very long book. Um, probably a book that I ought to have read by now and haven't, like Gibbon's Decline and Fall. So I just I voted for Gibbon.
Presenter
And your luxury.
Sir Frank Kermode
But there again, I gave this a lot of thought. I imagine what I would like is something very beautiful.
Sir Frank Kermode
It represents a climate and an environment quite un unlike the one that I'm in on the desert island. So I decided to ask you to persuade the trustees of the Tate Gallery to part with a painting by Samuel Palmer called Moonlit Landscape with Sheep. I'll settle for that.
Presenter
I'm sure they'll deliver it. Direct. Sir Frank Kermo, thank you very much indeed for letting us hear your desert island is.
Sir Frank Kermode
Well, thank you.
Speaker 3
You've been listening to a podcast from the Desert Island Discs archive. For more podcasts, please visit bbc.co. uk slash radio four.
Well, I had a rather strange war. I think it's quite I I never met anybody else who had uh a similar experience, but I did find myself acting as secretary to people who were crazy and drunk a lot of the time. And uh I think I learned a lot from this.
Presenter asks
Do you feel a little guilty that you helped bring [literary theory] in, because you had a ringside seat?
I did. I I did, I suppose. Well, I was that was when I was in London. No, since then I've really become I've I've uh in politics I've never taken the the track from left to right which is supposed to happen, but I have in this respect, and and I'll spend a good deal of time giving lectures denouncing this this business.
Presenter asks
Do you enjoy your solitary state?
For the most part, yes. Uh um it's it's softened by um friends and um people come to stay sometimes. No, I I'd rather I mean I've very I'd rather be like uh Adam and Eve in the creation, but I'm not. I'm Adam before uh his rib was removed.
“I think what what what's difficult to understand about autobiographies is that w what you're writing is about now. You're not writing about the past at all. You're really writing about the moment at which you're writing.”
“the element of sheer craziness in in war is well i i it's forgotten. I mean we know it's terrible and that millions of people get killed, but the silliness is quite extraordinary too.”
“I've had very good students who've said they're really only taking courses in literature in order to get out of it and and study what they now call theory. Theory in with a capital T, which is not literary theory anymore. It's theory of everything. And fine, as long as we can still have some people who are susceptible to the effect of good literature, particularly of poetry.”