Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
Singer and recording artist known for musical comedy, operetta, and grand opera.
Eight records
Prelude and Fugue in C minor, BWV 847 – Fugue
The fugue from Bach's Prelude and Fugue in C minor, played by Harold Samuel.
The Dream of Gerontius, Op. 38 (excerpt)Favourite
Gladys Ripley, Heddle Nash, Sir Malcolm Sargent
An excerpt from Elgar's The Dream of Gerontius. The excerpt I have chosen from this work is leading up to that enormous and wonderful climax, 'Praise to the Holiest in the Height'.
Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune
London Symphony Orchestra, Pierre Monteux
The opening of Debussy's Prelude à l'après-midi d'un faune.
A little tiny little French song taken from Véronique, sung by Dame Maggie Teyte.
Dichterliebe, Op. 48 – No. 7 'Ich grolle nicht'
Ich grolle nicht from the Dichterliebe, sung by Fischer-Dieskau.
Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg – Overture
Sir John Barbirolli, Hallé Orchestra
The overture to Die Meistersinger. This is a glorious piece of music about civic pride.
A song by Liza Lehmann called 'O Tell Me Nightingale', sung by my wife.
Carmen – Act II opening (excerpt)
Victoria de los Ángeles, Sir Thomas Beecham
Something from Carmen – the opening song from Act Two. This is from the set of records made and conducted by the late Sir Thomas Beecham. Now there was a man who really loved music.
The keepsakes
The book
an omnibus edition of Charles Dickens (as many Dickens novels as can be packed into one volume)
Charles Dickens
my favourite author, the one who wears best for my taste, is Charles Dickens. You can't have an omnibus edition of Charles Dickens. It's the size of a wagonet. So I would say, well, the greatest number of Dickens books you can pack into one volume.
The luxury
Paper and pens (self-writing pens)
I think I'd want paper and pens so that I scribble my thoughts, such as they may be.
In conversation
Presenter asks
You mentioned hearing that [The Dream of Gerontius] for the first time in Liverpool, George. Is that where you were born?
I was born in Birkenhead.
Presenter asks
How early in life did you start taking an interest in music?
I should think about seven years of age when I tried to play the violin, not very successfully. And my father then tried me at the flute, but that wasn't much better. And he thought, oh well, he'd better try the piano. I took to it like a duck to water and from thence onwards I didn't seem to have much trouble.
Presenter asks
How did [you] start recording in 1909 while you were still a student?
I went to the [Petitfer] place because I thought I would like to get some work, and made a test. Nothing happened. I never heard anything from them for about twelve months. And then I was sent for. They heard me sing again, and they gave me a contract there and then.
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 1
Hello, I'm Kirstie Young, and this is a recording of Desert Island Discs as it was being broadcast, rather than the studio recording.
Speaker 1
and for that reason you may hear some interference, and some degradation in the sound quality.
Speaker 1
For rights reasons, we've had to shorten the music. The programme was originally broadcast in 1965.
George Baker
Each week a well-known person is asked the question, if you were to be cast away alone on a desert island, which aid gramophone records would you choose to have with you?
George Baker
As usual, the castaway is introduced by Roy Plumley.
George Baker
How do you do, ladies and gentlemen? Our castaway this week is the singer and recording artist George Bay
Presenter
Maker.
Presenter
George, how well could you resign yourself to a castaway's existence? Oh, I think pretty well, Roy, because I have a philosophical turn of mind and uh
Presenter
I just knuckle down to the situation.
Presenter
As consolation, is there any one thing you would be happy to have got away from?
Presenter
Yes, perhaps the noise and bustle of modern traffic. Did you have any plan in choosing these eight records you're taking with you? Oh, yes, indeed. First of all, it's music I like, or the type of music I like. Secondly, some of the items form for me landmarks in my musical life. And thirdly, it embraces people whom I've known well and whose art I've admired. What's the first one?
Presenter
First one is by Harold Samuel.
Presenter
one of the greatest Bach players this country ever produced. You know, he knew the whole of Bach's keyboard music from memory.
Presenter
And then again in Harold playing this fugue of Bach's he reminds me of my early piano forty days, when in the two part and three part inventions of Bach and eventually the forty eight pillars and fugues, of which this is one that I could give a reasonable performance. And then another thing is, Harold Samuel was not only a good friend of mine, but he proposed me for the Savage Club fifty years ago.
Presenter
The fugue from Bach's Prelude and Fugue in C minor, played by Harold Samuel. What's your second choice?
Presenter
An excerpt from The Dream of Gerantris by Belgar.
Presenter
Now, I've chosen this particular music because I first heard it fifty-nine years ago in Liverpool.
Presenter
And the impression it made then has stayed with me all those years. The excerpt I have chosen from this work is leading up to that enormous and wonderful climax, Praise to the Holiest in the Height.
Presenter
An excerpt from Elgar's The Dream of Gerontius, Gladys Ripley and Hedel Nash as soloists, Sir Malcolm Sartent conducting.
Presenter
You mentioned hearing that for the first time in Liverpool, George. Is that where you were born? No, I was born in Buckham Head.
Presenter
You come from a musical family.
Presenter
Not specially musical, but my father was a very good amateur bass singer, and he was also the founder and conductor of the Burton Headley and Madrigal Society. How early in life did you start taking an interest in music? Oh, I should think about seven years of age when I tried to play the violin, not very successfully.
Presenter
And my father then tried me at the flute, but that wasn't much better.
Presenter
And he thought, Oh, well, he'd better try the piano.
Presenter
I took to it like a duck to water and uh from thence onwards I didn't seem to have much trouble. Yes. When you left school, did you start studying music right away? No. I was uh
Presenter
a clerk in one or two offices, but eventually I finished up in the uh
Presenter
Office of the Borough Treasurer in the Town Hall of Birkham Head. But your evenings were devoted to music? Oh, yes, entirely. In fact, I was an accompanist at a very early age, because I had spoken about my father being a singer. Well, he trotted me round to play for him.
Presenter
And then after a time I studied the organ and in fact I played my first church service at the age of fifteen.
Presenter
And then, at the age of sixteen, I became the organist and choirmaster of Woodchurch parish church, which is just beyond the borders of Birkenhead.
Presenter
and I continued at the organ for at two other churches, subsequently making a period of seven years in all, as a
Speaker 1
You know?
Presenter
Organist. Yes. And after that?
Presenter
I won a scholarship at the Royal College of Music, one of these open scholarships. Then I not only gave up playing the organ, but I resigned from the Town Hall of Buckingham and gladly resigned, because I didn't really like the job very much. Your scholarship was for singing, wasn't it? Oh, yes, entirely. In your early days as a singer, did you find it fairly easy to get engagements when you left the college? Well, yes, it was easy in in my case. You see, I started making gramophone records at the end of 1909.
Presenter
Well, when they came on the market I began to be known.
Presenter
fairly quickly, and therefore didn't.
Presenter
Have a great deal of trouble. But this was while you were still a student, wasn't it? Indeed. Whilst I was still at the college. Yes.
Presenter
Well, you served in the army in the First World War. Then for a number of years you appeared in musical comedy and operetta. Yes, I was in musical comedy and review for
Presenter
seven consecutive years and enjoyed it very much indeed.
Presenter
And then you switched to Grand Opera? Yes, eventually I went and was a guest performer with the one time British National Opera Company. I played only two parts for them. One was Papageno and the Magic Flute, and quite a number of performances.
Presenter
of Eskimo in common. And you played with the Carl Rosa? Yes, indeed. I played two parts for them. A few performances of Sharpless from Madame Butterfly, and oh, a lot of performances as Mephistopheles in Guno's Faus. In fact, the last operatic performance I ever gave was actually on my sixtieth birthday.
Presenter
In Hanley.
Presenter
You've done some valuable administrative work in in the musical field, with the Royal Philharmonic Society, for instance. Yes, I've been the honorary treasurer of the Royal Philharmonic Society for over thirty years. And you were with the B B C Music Staff. Yes, I was for a little over three years.
George Baker
The
George Baker
Here's how
Presenter
I was first of all Assistant Overseas Music Director, and uh in three months' time uh I was the Overseas Music Director. Well, we've talked about some of the highlights of your career. Let's break off for your next record.
Presenter
Well, the next one is is by De Bussy. I'd like the whole of Pellias in Melisan, but that's impossible. So to have uh a memory of Debussy and a flavor we'll have la premidie d'une form.
Presenter
conducted but by Monteur.
George Baker
The opening of Debussy's Prelude à la Prui Midden Thorne.
George Baker
The love
Presenter
London Symphony Orchestra conducted by Monteau. Now, George, you started recording in 1909 while you were still a student. How did this happen?
Presenter
Well, I went to the Petifre place because I
Presenter
Thought I would like to get some work.
Presenter
and made a test. Nothing happened. I never heard anything from them for about twelve months.
Presenter
And then I was sent for. They heard me sing again, and they gave me a contract there and then.
Presenter
Well, I've got a good idea. It's uh it's not less than three thousand. Under all sorts of names. Under all sorts of names. In the old days, you see, there were not many people who made successful records, you know, on the acoustical recording.
Presenter
And uh therefore the greatest use was made of uh the few people who did make the records, and in order to vary their catalogue they gave us different names for different types of music.
Presenter
You did a lot of musical comedy records.
Presenter
Oh, a lot, a tremendous lot, s sometimes under my own name, and sometimes under
Presenter
Victor Conway, Leslie Milton, George Barnes, oh, heaps of names. There was a one of a duet, it's called Howard and Harrison, another set of duets, it's called
Presenter
Courtland and Jeffreys I was Walter Jeffreys, and all sorts of things went on at that time, as indeed they did go on at that time, even in the British Broadcasting Corporation.
Presenter
You also made a lot of children's records.
Presenter
Oh, well, yes. The children's records I've done the um
Presenter
The first two books of When We Were Very Young,
Presenter
the Humzu Pooh, and also the Alice in Wonderland records. And they took my name or rather the words and music took my name all round the world.
Presenter
Well, perhaps your your greatest success as as a recording artist has been in in Gilbert and Sullivan. You've recorded the whole G and S repertoire, haven't you?
Presenter
I've recorded the whole of the DNS repertoire once round on the acoustical method.
Presenter
Once round on electrical recording.
Presenter
And
Presenter
two thirds round on the on present day recording. In fact, the last uh opera we made was made only just over two years ago, and that was Ruddy Gore, in which I sang the part of Robin O'Cuddle.
Presenter
But you've never sung these roles on the stage with the Doily Cart Company. Not with the Doily Cart Company, no. When did you start broadcasting?
Presenter
Oh, nineteen twenty four
Presenter
None of Savoy Hill. Yes. And once again, everything.
Presenter
Opera Busical Comedy Auditorio.
Presenter
Well, everything under the sun is most extraordinary. Scenes from Shakespeare and
Presenter
one or two attempts at imitations and uh I I don't know what, really. I've done I've done opera, of course I've done musical comedy. With my wife, Olive Groves, we were two of the first in the songs of the shows, and that went on for some years, you know.
Speaker 1
Uh
Presenter
drifted along, as it were, with the tide of broadcasting. And television, of course, when it came. Yes, in the in the early days of television at Alexander Palace I did quite a lot there. But usually
Presenter
not in singing, in nearly all as an actor.
Presenter
Let's have record number four. What next?
Presenter
Well oh, this is a very nice one by Messager. Now, he was one of the
Presenter
Best composers of light music, Sullivan excepted, and uh this is a little tiny little French song taken from Veronique, and is sung by that immaculate artist, delightful singer, Dame Maggie Tict.
Presenter
Maggie Tote singing a song from Veronique.
Presenter
Now, George, you can look back on the musical world as it was at the the beginning of the century.
Presenter
A very different world from to day's.
Presenter
Are there more opportunities now or not?
Presenter
I should have said there were more opportunities to day. You see, in the old days there were more choral societies than there are today. Therefore a serious singer would have more opportunities to exhibit his art than he has to day in that direction. But there was no wireless and there was no television.
Presenter
All they had as an adjunct to the ordinary concert world, or the opera world, or musical comedy,
Presenter
was making grammar phone records. And as I said previously, only very few people made them. Very few people's voices were suited to this. Well they were not suitable for the way records were taken on the acoustical recording. They wanted voices that impinged on the wax or would cause the needle to cut into the wax.
Speaker 1
Yep.
Speaker 1
Uh
Presenter
And there were not a great number of them about. Hence, as I said before, they ch chose so many names for these individuals.
Presenter
Would you say musical standards are higher today?
Presenter
Musical standards
Presenter
Uh orchestrally.
Presenter
A far higher.
Presenter
Musical standards, as far as musical appreciation is concerned,
Presenter
is far more widely spread than it was.
Presenter
The general standard of music is higher than it was.
Presenter
The individual standard of music
Presenter
is not so high as it was. In other words, there are fewer
Presenter
Outstanding Personalities
Presenter
Today the outstanding personality in the musical world is the orchestral conductor.
Presenter
Yes.
Presenter
You're doing a lot of writing these days.
Presenter
Well, I I write about people because I like people, and uh I write regularly for two monthly magazines.
Presenter
And then I've done a good deal of musical journalism, and I've actually
Presenter
written two books on singing. They're technical books, of course.
Presenter
Let's have your next record now. Number five we've got to
Presenter
Well, that's Icht Krollenicht, uh from the Dichteliebe, sung by Fischer Dischkow, one of the best leader singers we've ever known.
Presenter
From the benders help
George Baker
All of the mercy.
George Baker
Is the Lord's Leap is the Lord?
Speaker 1
Oh that I lost health.
Presenter
Uh
Presenter
Schumann's is Krollenicht, sung by Dietrich Fischer Diskow. What's your next record, George?
Presenter
Oh, I think I'd like to hear some of the
Presenter
Overtured to Demeister Singer, conducted by my dear friend John Barbaroli.
Presenter
You know, being on a desert island is all very well, but as I said earlier on, I'm a townsman, and this is a glorious piece of music about civic pride.
George Baker
So Don Barbaroli and the Halley Orchestra, the closing passage of the Overture 2.
Presenter
to the Meister Singer.
Presenter
George, apart from music, what are your hobbies?
Presenter
Now, what are they? Well, I I'm a bit of a Shakespearean
Presenter
Semi-scholar. It's well known that I'm a cricket fanatic. Indeed. And uh
Presenter
That and taking coloured photographs, I think, is about the lot.
Presenter
Could you look after yourself on a desert island if you've got any hobbies that'll help you that way?
Presenter
My hobbies wouldn't help me on a desert island. Um I'm not a handyman in any way.
Presenter
If I can get anyone else to do the job for me, that is to say, looking after me, I I delighted. If I'm forced to look after myself, I've got a strong bump of self-preservation, and I've no doubt I would survive. Yes. Do you think that bump of self-preservation could guide you to making some kind of raft or craft? Oh, no. Oh, not at all. I'm not at all handyman. I don't put on washers on taps or anything like that. I'm absolutely useless at it. I've been useless all my life with my hands, and I've got out of an enormous lot of work.
Speaker 1
Oh no
Presenter
Splendid.
Presenter
Let's have another record.
Presenter
Well now this is um
Presenter
Rather an affectionate thing that I want to put in, not only to please myself, but to please my wife. It is a song.
Presenter
by Lisa Lehman called O Tell Me Nightingale, and it is sung by Olive Groves, who is my wife, and, if I may say so, I think she sings it beautifully. After all, said and done, she is an artist in her own right.
George Baker
Oh, Timmy Nightingale and sweet mud.
Presenter
Therefore thy voice Uh Meanwhile.
Speaker 1
Why
Speaker 2
Yeah.
Speaker 1
What's the
Speaker 2
I'm not sure if I can do it.
Presenter
Uh Uh Uh
Speaker 2
Yeah.
Speaker 2
Uh
Presenter
We the life in love you're the dream.
George Baker
Yeah.
Presenter
Philip Grove singing Oh tell me a nightingale
Presenter
And now your last record.
Presenter
Well, for the last record I'd like something from Carmen. I've mentioned that I'd played Escamillo in Carmen and this opening song it is the opening song from Act Two that I've chosen.
Presenter
It is from the set of records made and conducted by the late Sir Thomas Beacham.
Presenter
Now there was a man who really loved music, and his sense of paranache was absolutely marvellous.
Presenter
Yeah.
Speaker 1
La den son chance sur maria, la den son chance sur marie, la mond et lesis etimides, li sid, des breville, ce la mo.
Presenter
That goes f
Presenter
An excerpt from the Second Act of Carmen, conducted by Sir Thomas Beacham.
George Baker
Wait.
Presenter
With Victoria Dlove. So Uncle Liz. As well. One of the soloists. Uh
George Baker
Uh
Presenter
Uh Three or eight record. If you could have only one of that eight, which would it be?
Presenter
Well, the temptation, of course, is that I would like the record made by my wife. But, you know
Presenter
On second thoughts
Presenter
To be reminded of the absence of my wife would only cause me intense pain.
Presenter
Therefore I think I better set that aside and face reality. And to do so I would say that out of all the records I have chosen for this programme the one that would stay with me longest
Presenter
And remind me
Presenter
By faith
Presenter
is The Dream of Gerantius by Elgar.
Presenter
and one luxury to take with you.
Presenter
Oh, um
Presenter
Paper and pens you know, these self writing pens. I think I'd want paper and pens so that I scribble my thoughts, such as they may be.
Presenter
And one book, apart from the Bible and Shakespeare? Oh, that's very difficult. You see, my favourite author, the one who wears best for my taste, is Charles Dickens. You can't have an omnibus edition of Charles Dickens. It's the size of a wagonet. So I would say, well, the greatest number of Dickens books you can pack into one volume. Right. And thank you, George Baker, for letting us hear your choice of Desert Island Discs. Well, thank you, Roy, for inviting me.
Presenter
And goodbye to you. Goodbye, everyone.
Speaker 2
The guest in today's recorded programme was George Baker. The interviewer was Roy Plumley and the producer Monica Chapman. On Saturday at 1.40, the castaway will be the horticulturist Dr. W.E. Schull Cooper. And next Monday at 10.1, we have our 750th programme in the series when our castaway will be Dame Margot Fontaine.
Speaker 1
You've been listening to a podcast from the Desert Islandists Archive. For more podcasts, please visit bbc.co.uk slash radio four.
Presenter asks
Perhaps your greatest success as a recording artist has been in Gilbert and Sullivan. You've recorded the whole G&S repertoire, haven't you?
I've recorded the whole of the [G&S] repertoire once round on the acoustical method. Once round on electrical recording. And two thirds round on the on present day recording. In fact, the last opera we made was made only just over two years ago, and that was Ruddigore, in which I sang the part of Robin Oakapple.
Presenter asks
You can look back on the musical world as it was at the beginning of the century. A very different world from today's. Are there more opportunities now or not?
I should have said there were more opportunities to day. You see, in the old days there were more choral societies than there are today. Therefore a serious singer would have more opportunities to exhibit his art than he has to day in that direction. But there was no wireless and there was no television. All they had as an adjunct to the ordinary concert world, or the opera world, or musical comedy, was making gramophone records. And as I said previously, only very few people made them. Very few people's voices were suited to this.
“Harold Samuel was not only a good friend of mine, but he proposed me for the Savage Club fifty years ago.”
“My father then tried me at the flute, but that wasn't much better. And he thought, Oh, well, he'd better try the piano. I took to it like a duck to water and from thence onwards I didn't seem to have much trouble.”
“I write about people because I like people, and I write regularly for two monthly magazines. And then I've done a good deal of musical journalism, and I've actually written two books on singing. They're technical books, of course.”
“My hobbies wouldn't help me on a desert island. I'm not a handyman in any way. If I can get anyone else to do the job for me, that is to say, looking after me, I delighted. If I'm forced to look after myself, I've got a strong bump of self-preservation, and I've no doubt I would survive.”
“The temptation, of course, is that I would like the record made by my wife. But, you know, on second thoughts, to be reminded of the absence of my wife would only cause me intense pain. Therefore I think I better set that aside and face reality. And to do so I would say that out of all the records I have chosen for this programme the one that would stay with me longest and remind me by faith is The Dream of Gerontius by Elgar.”