Tuning in…
Tuning in…
Desert Island Discs
Presented by Roy Plomley
Known for having one of the best known voices in Britain.
Eight records
Third movement from Brahms' Symphony No. 3
Sir John Barbirolli conducting the Hallé Orchestra
I once played in an opera called The Waltz King, and I played the part of Brahms. ... And it never occurred to me that one could sing this melody, but you can.
In questa reggia from Turandot
I think if I'm not being impolite to other people. I think she is the greatest of the big singers, this fine sustained singing, which physically must be frightfully difficult. And I always play this record thinking she'll never get to the top note, but of course she always does.
Étude in A-flat major, Op. 25, No. 1Favourite
Mentally, now I have joined the staff in 1935. ... and this is what she was playing, and it has always for me ever since made an atmosphere of peace, summer, warmth, evening. Oh, Nostalda, if you like.
I've been married very happily for eighteen years, and this is the tune to which, if I may put it this way, a certain amount of my courting was done. A great deal of dancing was done, and I still sing. It's one of the most beautiful songs of its kind.
Bess, You Is My Woman from Porgy and Bess
I've always adored, if that's the right term, the music of Mr. Gershwin. It does something to me. ... I've just heard the record, I realize, of course, that I have the same love for Gershwin's music as I have for Puccini's, a chap who can really write a tune.
I've always thought that folk music is best sung unaccompanied. And of all the folk tunes I know, this one 'She Moved Through the Fair' is my favorite. And when it comes to a recording, give me every time Mr. Kenneth McKellar.
I mentioned before, how much I enjoyed meeting people in the dance band world. And one of the people I've always liked and whose signature tune I still like and play whenever I can, Joe Loss in the Mood.
Falstaff (excerpt: Falstaff asleep behind the arras)
I cannot go to any island, Roy, without some music of Elgar. And I've thought a lot about this. and I'd settled for part of Falstaff. If you recollect, you will find in the score there is a part marked Falstaff fast asleep behind the arras. He is Jack Falstaff, page to the Duke of Norfolk. He's dreaming about his youth.
The keepsakes
The book
Eric Partridge
I should like to take a dictionary. I've got several, but the one I think I would like most of all is Eric Partridge's compilation called A Dictionary of Origins, because there you have, when once you've learnt how to use the book, and that takes about six months, let me tell you There you got the nucleus, as it were, of any number of books. I'm sure you do the same. You turn up a word, and the moment you've seen that word you'll see half a dozen others, and off you go. So I want the chair to sit in.
In conversation
Presenter asks
How well could you face continued loneliness?
I think quite easily, because I never in fact lonely. I like to look at things, examine them, and if it's dark, I can always hear music. No, I'm never lonely. What would you be happiest you got away from? Noise. All was noise. I hate the noise of London's traffic. I hate little tiny noises like dripping taps in hotel bedrooms. And I try and set those to music and it never works.
Presenter asks
Did you have any plan in selecting your eight for the Desert Island?
Autobiographical, I suppose, in a way, but at the same time, I wanted to play pieces I really like. Oh, if I may misquote Cecil Rhodes: So much to play, so little time.
Presenter asks
As a boy, what did you want to be?
Well, I left Sidmouth when I was one year old. Lived in Bedford for 22 and during that time I wanted to be an engineer. And in fact, I was apprenticed to a firm of marine engineers and spent five years at it. Went to night school, failed on a trick, different subjects, each of three years, and then turned my hobby, which was singing, into a profession and gave up engineering.
The recording
Timestamps play the recording from that turn
Speaker 1
BBC Sounds, Music, Radio, Podcasts.
Speaker 1
Hello, I'm Lauren Laverne and this is the Desert Island Discs podcast. For rights reasons, the music is shorter than on the original broadcast. The presenter is Roy Plomley. I hope you enjoy listening.
Presenter
How do you do, ladies and gentlemen?
Presenter
On Idesite Island This Week is the possessor of one of the best known voices in Britain, its Frank Phillips.
Presenter
Frank, how well could you face continued loneliness?
Presenter
I think quite easily, because I never in fact lonely.
Presenter
I like to look at things, examine them, and if it's dark, I can always hear music. No, I'm never lonely. What would you be happiest you got away from? Noise.
Presenter
All was noise. I hate the noise of London's traffic. I hate
Presenter
Little tiny noises like dripping taps in hotel bedrooms.
Presenter
And I try and set those to music and it never works.
Presenter
Now you've been exposed to so many thousands of records for so many years.
Presenter
Do you have a big collection yourself? No, not now. I had quite a number of 78s, the old 78s.
Presenter
But um nowadays they're not considered.
Presenter
Quite the thing.
Presenter
But I still play them.
Presenter
Did you have any plan in selecting your eight for the Desert Island?
Presenter
Autobiographical, I suppose, in a way, but at the same time, I wanted to play.
Presenter
Pieces I really like.
Presenter
Oh, if I may misquote Cecil Rhodes.
Presenter
So much to play, so little time
Presenter
What's the first one?
Presenter
The first one is the third movement from the Third Symphony of Brahms.
Presenter
I once played in an opera called The Waltz King, and I played the part of Brahms. At that age, Brahms was twenty-three.
Presenter
And it never occurred to me that one could sing this melody, but you can.
Presenter
The third movement of the Third Brahm Symphony, Sir John Barbirolli conducting the Helley Orchestra.
Presenter
Mind you, I am bound to say that.
Presenter
At the end of the first performance of The Waltz King.
Presenter
Ernest Newman, the music critic, came along and said, How can you, Brahms, at twenty-three, sing a tune which I know jolly well you won't have written for about another forty years. You were saving it up. Right. Let's have your next record. The next record is please from
Presenter
Potunis Turundot in Questa Regia, sung by
Presenter
Eva Turner.
Presenter
I think
Presenter
if I'm not being impolite to other people. I think she is the
Presenter
Greatest of the
Presenter
big singers, this fine sustained singing, which physically must be frightfully difficult.
Presenter
And I always play this record thinking she'll never get to the top note, but of course she always does.
Presenter
Eva Turner in Questalegia.
Presenter
You're a West Countryman, aren't you, Fred?
Presenter
Yes, I was born in Sidmouth.
Presenter
In 1901,
Presenter
As a boy, what did you want to be?
Presenter
Well, I left Sidmouth when I was one year old.
Presenter
Lived in Bedford for 22 and during that time I wanted to be an engineer.
Presenter
And in fact, I was apprenticed to a firm of marine engineers and spent five years at it.
Presenter
Went to night school, failed on a trick, different subjects, each of three years, and then turned my hobby, which was singing, into a profession and gave up engineering. Did you find it tough going to start with as a professional? Harder than I thought, because I won the Blackpool Rose Bowl as an amateur in 1923, which is more or less the tops of amateur singing.
Presenter
And I tore down to a London agent and said, I've just won the Blackpool Rose Bowl. And they said, well, if you want to be a professional,
Presenter
Forget it. Don't mention it.
Presenter
You've started broadcasting quite soon. Yes, the same year, nineteen twenty three. Very exciting it was, too, because I used to have a series then called The Foundations of Music, in which I learnt such a lot, because I used to sing songs of Chassons, Cesar Franc, for
Presenter
And then, thanks to Stanford Robinson, nearly every Sunday I used to be at St. Margaret's Westminster recording or broadcasting live Bach church cantatas. Wonderful experience. In those early days of Savoy Hill the fees weren't very large, I believe.
Presenter
Oh, no. No. The Chinese studio in the basement of Savoy Hill with Cecil Dixon accompanying and a little black dog sitting under the piano, I remember very well. Tenbob.
Presenter
Yeah.
Presenter
Now, you became a regular at the Proms in London, and you toured abroad quite a bit. Yes, I did.
Presenter
In nineteen twenty six, I had a very great opportunity, thanks again to the BBC, to sing in its first international celebrity concert at Queen's Hall, which was Schoenberg's Gudder Lieder, which I managed to learn my part by heart.
Presenter
Then I went to South Africa, toured with Mary Hall. 1928, Canada.
Presenter
for about four weeks.
Presenter
Switzerland, Belgium, France? Oh, yes, I had a very, very pleasant time. And you sang in opera? Yes, I had two seasons at Coven Garden in the French season. The first time we met, you were thinking the part of Captain Bearback in a revival of A.P. Herbert's Tampa Vitas of the lyric Theatre Hammersmith. I was in the chorus. Well done.
Presenter
Well, it was a turning point in my career, I don't know about yours.
Presenter
Because that was the year of the Jubilee Drives, King George V, Queen Mary, and it emptied the theatres. Something certainly emptied ours. It did, too.
Presenter
And so I had to look around for a job.
Presenter
And quickly.
Presenter
And curiously enough I had two offers on the same day.
Presenter
One was from a film company to conduct Marku.
Presenter
The London Symphony Orchestra in the Albert Hall fortunately the soundtrack had already been recorded by Sir Henry Wood
Presenter
In a film called
Presenter
The man who knew too much. The other job was to join the BBC in London as an announcer.
Presenter
And the difference in money was this, ten pounds between three weeks' work for the film company or one year's work for the BBC, and you'll know which one I took. Yes, upon this momentous decision, let's have your third record.
Presenter
Chopin, please. The A-flat study from Obus twenty-five.
Presenter
Can I
Presenter
Mentally, now I have joined the staff in 1935. I'm wearing a dinner jacket and I'm sitting in the announcer's room.
Presenter
And there is a play, and the character
Presenter
motors away and stops his car because he sees a lighted room in a house on the roadside.
Presenter
And if you're like I am, you are always interested when you walk by in the dark and you see.
Presenter
A lit up room. You always want to know what's going on inside. Well, so did the character in this play, and he saw a woman sitting at the piano, and this is what she was playing, and it has always for me ever since.
Presenter
made an atmosphere of peace, summer, warmth, evening.
Presenter
Oh, Nostelda, if you like.
Presenter
Chopin studied number one in A Platte Major, Opus Twenty Five, played by Shura Cherkowski.
Presenter
Now Frank, you joined the BBC as announcer in 1935.
Presenter
Dinner jackets on Sunday as well.
Presenter
I'm not quite sure. Memory won't help me there. I always assumed that it was a cold Sunday supper.
Presenter
And presumably apart from newsreading, you're doing a whole lot. Dance bands, variety shows, dancers. Oh, yes. And that's one of the great things about the announcing job, you'll know. You meet so many other people. Carol Gibbons, Joe Loss, all sorts of people with dance bands. Yes.
Presenter
Well then the war came. We were sent off to one of the BBC's country outposts or what was known in those days as Hoggs Norton.
Speaker 1
Yes, I went.
Presenter
I opened the war there, not personally, but you know what I mean.
Presenter
And then I went back there in nineteen forty one. I think that's right here, yes, just towards the end of the Blitz. I had another four months there. But otherwise I was in London all the time. And for the first time Announcer stopped being anonymous.
Presenter
And a very good thing too, I maintain.
Presenter
It was caused because it was thought.
Presenter
That if Hitler's invasion scheme did come off, that they would have people.
Presenter
Naming uh announcers or newsreaders
Presenter
and to identify a name with a voice.
Presenter
is very much more difficult to falsify.
Presenter
You brought us some devastating news from time to time. I seem to associate your voice with one or two war disasters. Yes, indeed.
Presenter
Uh it was that was about the time when
Presenter
Somebody wrote to the then Director General saying, why do you keep this chap on the staff?
Presenter
We shall never win the war so long as you keep him. And he sent the postcard down to me, and it's written across it was, so that's what it is. I believe you own the card index report on you from the Nazi archives. Yes, I do. Richard Nimbleby very kindly sent it to me from Berlin immediately after the war. He was one of the first people, kind of the news boys, to get there.
Presenter
And whereas others might go for sights of bodies, scenes to photograph, the tidy mind of Dimbleby took him immediately into the cabinet file and of Chancellery, and he sent me my card. And I think I'm right in saying he sent Alvander Dell his. What does yours say? What kind of report did you have? Oh, Vorspieler Erster Klasse, which I think is extremely nice. And though I don't myself read German handwriting, I am told that in the bottom right-hand corner it says fond of the arts. Oh, nice. Well, let's have record number four, Frank. What next?
Presenter
I should like to go back, if I may, for a moment to nostalgia, because
Presenter
I've been married very happily for eighteen years, and this is the tune to which, if I may put it this way, a certain amount of my courting was done.
Presenter
A great deal of dancing was done, and I still sing.
Presenter
It's one of the most beautiful songs of its kind, Jean-Sablanc singing Why Do You Pass Me By?
Frank Phillips
Basé sommer boy.
Frank Phillips
Some members?
Frank Phillips
Don't
Frank Phillips
A few despois, boss de soi.
Frank Phillips
Jay thought it better.
Frank Phillips
Donge d'eta royal.
Frank Phillips
Okay, guys on First
Presenter
Frank, you've read the news for nearly thirty years, and about it all you've maintained the impersonal impartiality that the B V C insists on. You've never been able to let your own views color your reading. Hasn't this continued inhibition been a great strain?
Presenter
Not been quite so inhibited as you might think when you read things like Today in Parliament, where you
Presenter
Are both the opposition and the government, and you are quoting each. It becomes frankfully exciting, you know. I believe you were in the habit of putting the cut-out switch down and making comments occasionally. Not very often, and I don't think I should ever do it again. You are thinking of the fast car, are you? Yes. Yes, well, that was quite a morning.
Speaker 3
Uh
Presenter
We'd had this uh
Presenter
Bank robber, chap.
Presenter
Escaping in a fast car
Presenter
And so I when I put the cough key down, not knowing it wasn't working, said
Presenter
And really expect them to go away in a slower.
Presenter
But uh it went out all over the country and I must say I think it did sound broadcasting a power of good, publicity-wise. What else do you remember as having gone wrong?
Presenter
Well, I have read the early morning news in my pajamas more than once. That speaks for itself.
Presenter
Well, now you're retiring. That doesn't mean we're not going to hear you any more.
Presenter
I'm being retired. That's a pension thing. If you are a member of a pension scheme and they say that's it, that's it. No, I want to do as much broadcasting and stay as close to microphones and television cameras for that matter as possible. Welcome to the ranks of the worried freelancers. Well, you look jolly well. What in particular have you lined up?
Presenter
At the moment, I'm doing a weekly series of military band broadcasts.
Presenter
Uh which I find
Presenter
Slightly interesting because I have myself no knowledge of military history at all.
Presenter
And therefore, I rely enormously on my producer and on Colonel Basil Brown, the director of music at Neller Hall, who is a military historian.
Presenter
And he does know the music and the stories behind it, so that before we do each program, the three of us meet and we act as each other's devil's advocate, and that is how the script gets knocked out. What's this series called? Passing of the regiments. It deals primarily with the amalgamations of the county regiments and others in the British Army from 1922 going right up to present day. Yes. Now you're going to have a little more time for your hobbies in future. What are they?
Presenter
Fishing.
Presenter
Fizzing, fizzing.
Presenter
And then gardening.
Presenter
Let's have another record.
Presenter
This I would like.
Presenter
Very much. It's Bess, you is my woman from Poggy and Bess. I've always.
Presenter
Adored, if that's the right term, the music of Mr. Gershwin. It does something to me. I don't know what it is, but let's listen and I'll try and tell you after.
Speaker 3
From this middle I tremble, I keep this ball.
Speaker 3
Yeah.
Speaker 3
Yeah.
Presenter
Bessie was my woman now from the soundtrack of the film version of Porky and Bess.
Presenter
What's your next Regal Crack?
Presenter
The next record is uh folks on, but uh I did say that I would
Presenter
Try and explain why I like Porgy and Bess, and now I've just heard the record, I realize, of course, that I have the same love for Gershwin's music as I have for Puccini's, a chap who can really write a tune.
Presenter
Uh the next record. I've always thought that folk music
Presenter
is best sung unaccompanied.
Presenter
And of all the folk tunes I know, this one she moved through the fair.
Presenter
is my favorite.
Presenter
And when it comes to a recording, give me every time Mr. Kenneth McKellar.
Frank Phillips
My young love said to me My mother won't mine.
Frank Phillips
And my father won't slight you for your lack of kind.
Frank Phillips
Then she st away from
Presenter
Kenneth McKellop.
Presenter
I was delighted to hear about the fishing and the gardening, Frank. It sounds as if you'd make quite a resourceful castaway.
Presenter
Well, it depends rather, I would have thought, on what sort of island. It's not a bad island. You are quite a handy chap. Reasonably, yes.
Presenter
Would you try to escape? Oh, yes. Yes, I think I should. Partly because I like my fellow creatures and largely because I'm terribly fond of my family. Yes. Ever done any sailing? Yes, I've done quite a lot, largely crewing rather than sailing, and I'm not a madly good navigator. I can.
Presenter
steer by a compass, but I can't necessarily read a nautical chart.
Presenter
He would have no compass, so the best of luck. Let's have record number seven.
Presenter
Oh, yes. What fun. I mentioned before, didn't I, how much I enjoyed meeting people in the dance band world.
Presenter
And one of the people I've always liked and whose signature tune I still like and play whenever I can, Joe Loss in the Mood.
Presenter
Joe lost in his signature tune, and now we come to your last record.
Presenter
Well, I cannot go to any island, Roy, without some music of Elgar.
Presenter
And I've thought a lot about this.
Presenter
and I'd settled for part of Falstaff.
Presenter
If you recollect, you will find in the score there is a part.
Presenter
Marked.
Presenter
Falstaff fast asleep behind the arras.
Presenter
He is Jack Falstaff, page to the Duke of Norfolk.
Presenter
He's dreaming about his youth. That's right.
Presenter
An excerpt from Elgar's full stop conducted by the composer.
Presenter
Now if you could only have one of these eight records, which would it be?
Presenter
I think the peace and quiet and the lighted room, the chopper, you know. Right. And one luxury to take to this island with you.
Presenter
An arm chair.
Presenter
Very sensible idea. And one book.
Presenter
I should like to take a dictionary.
Presenter
I've got several, but the one I think I would like most of all is Eric Partridge's compilation called A Dictionary of Origins, because there you have, when once you've learnt how to use the book, and that takes about six months, let me tell you
Presenter
There you got the nucleus, as it were, of any number of books. I'm sure you do the same. You turn up a word, and the moment you've seen that word you'll see half a dozen others, and off you go. So I want the chair to sit in.
Presenter
Right, you'll be quite a long time in there, Chair. And thank you, Frank Phillips, for letting us hear your choice of Desert Island Disc. Oh, it's been great fun.
Presenter
Goodbye, everyone.
Presenter asks
Hasn't this continued inhibition [from maintaining impartiality] been a great strain?
Not been quite so inhibited as you might think when you read things like Today in Parliament, where you are both the opposition and the government, and you are quoting each. It becomes frankfully exciting, you know. I believe you were in the habit of putting the cut-out switch down and making comments occasionally. Not very often, and I don't think I should ever do it again. You are thinking of the fast car, are you? Yes, yes, well, that was quite a morning. We'd had this bank robber chap escaping in a fast car And so I when I put the cough key down, not knowing it wasn't working, said And really expect them to go away in a slower. But it went out all over the country and I must say I think it did sound broadcasting a power of good, publicity-wise.
Presenter asks
What else do you remember as having gone wrong?
Well, I have read the early morning news in my pajamas more than once. That speaks for itself.
Presenter asks
Now if you could only have one of these eight records, which would it be?
I think the peace and quiet and the lighted room, the chopper, you know.
“No, I'm never lonely.”
“turned my hobby, which was singing, into a profession and gave up engineering.”
“ten pounds between three weeks' work for the film company or one year's work for the BBC, and you'll know which one I took.”
“Vorspieler Erster Klasse, which I think is extremely nice. ... fond of the arts.”